Three white vans with yellow reflective tape parked in a concrete garage behind a metal gate.
White vans parked in an enclosed area inside the Golden Gateway Garage, owned by the SFMTA. Photo by Andres Jimenez Larios.

The federal government has agreed to remove Immigration and Customs Enforcement vehicles from a city-owned parking garage and relocate them elsewhere, according to emails obtained by Mission Local. 

The move comes three weeks after Mission Local first reported that ICE vehicles were using dozens of parking spaces at a downtown garage owned by the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency. Those vehicles were presumably active in enforcement operations across the Bay Area.

The federal government hopes to remove the ICE vehicles by Monday, Nov. 23, according to a Friday email from Jason Cawthorne, a director at the Government Services Administration, the federal entity that has assigned spots to ICE at the garage for over a decade.

In the email, which was sent to the San Francisco Municipal Transportation on Nov. 20 and reviewed by Mission Local, Cawthorne wrote that the federal government will forfeit its 147 spaces at the garage and negotiate a new lease elsewhere.

A source close to the matter said Mayor Daniel Lurie had called the General Services Administration multiple times since the city became aware in late October that ICE was using the city-owned garage. The mayor asked the agency to remove the ICE vehicles, the source said. 

From: Kirschbaum, Julie B

Sent: 11:13 AM

To: Jason Cawthorne – PMBC, +2

Subject: RE: GSA Parking Lease at 250 Clay Street

Dear Mr. Cawthorne,

Thank you for your response to my letter and for understanding that the use of a city garage by ICE vehicles is inconsistent with the City’s laws and policies.

We appreciate your commitment to remove all vehicles from the Golden Gateway Garage on Monday, November 23.

We see the removal of these vehicles as urgent and will reach out immediately.

Sincerely,
Julie Kirschbaum

Julie Kirschbaum
Director of Transportation
San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency


From: Jason Cawthorne

Subject: GSA Parking Lease at 250 Clay Street

Good Morning,

I’m reaching out to share GSA’s current plan related to the parking lease at 250 Clay Street and its use by ICE vehicles.

GSA is currently negotiating a new lease to move the 147 spaces out of the 250 Clay Street garage. We are finalizing pricing and costs to install security gates and card readers for the new location. Once signed, it would then take approximately 3-4 weeks for the work to be completed.

As an interim solution, we plan to move the vehicles before that work is completed. We are targeting Monday, November 23 to make that move, and are waiting for confirmation from the new lessor that this will be possible; we hope to have that confirmation today.

GSA understands the concerns raised and wants to work with you to determine a path forward that works for both groups. We’re available to meet to discuss in more detail.

Thanks,
Jason

Jason Cawthorne
Director
Central Pacific Coast Service Center
Office of Facilities Management
U.S. General Services Administration

Mission Local first reported the garage’s use by ICE on Oct. 30. The SFMTA on Nov. 2 wrote the federal government urging it to “immediately and permanently cease parking ICE vehicles” in the Golden Gateway Garage at 250 Clay St.

On Thursday, Mission Local reported that SFMTA staff had knowingly signed off an “ICE Lease” deal for parking spots in the garage, an act that half a dozen attorneys said was a plain violation of the city and state sanctuary laws prohibiting cooperation with immigration enforcement.

One SFMTA staffer had written, “If we have the space, I don’t mind taking the money.” 

The federal government’s decision Friday ends an at-least 16-year history of federal immigration vehicles parking in the garage, according to contracts.

Cawthorne, the General Services Administration staffer, wrote that the ICE vehicles would be relocated and that finalizing a lease and installing “security gates and card readers for the new location” would take about a month, but “we plan to move the vehicles before that work is completed.” 

Entrance to a parking garage with a clearance height of 6′6″ and a sign displaying hourly and daily parking rates.
Golden Gateway Garage at 250 Clay St. Photo by Nicholas David.
A row of parked black SUVs in a parking garage, with a blue pillar sign marked with the letter A.
Dozens of SUVs with no license plates and tinted windows parking at the Golden Gateway Garage. Photo by Clara-Sophia Daly.

“We are targeting Monday, November 23 to make that move, and are waiting for confirmation from the new lessor that this will be possible; we hope to have that confirmation today.”

Julie Kirschbaum, the director of transportation at SFMTA, thanked Cawthorne for his response and for “understanding that the use of a city garage by ICE vehicles is inconsistent with the City’s laws and policies,” according to the emails. 

She wrote that she “appreciates” his commitment to remove the ICE vehicles. “We see the removal of these vehicles as urgent,” she wrote.

Mission Local previously reported that the SFMTA retained “sole discretion” to cut its contract with the private parking operator that subleased spaces to the federal government. That contract governs more than a dozen garages, however, and the SFMTA had sought a way to remove the ICE vehicles without affecting the larger contract.

The garage lies in close proximity to the ICE field office at 630 Sansome St., where hundreds of immigrants have been detained or taken to after being arrested in and around the Bay Area. 

Agents used the garage to store vehicles, which helped the federal government transport detained immigrants, including to and from arrests at homes, workplaces, and traffic stops, according to activists who have been monitoring the garage for months.

Additional reporting by Io Yeh Gilman.

Clara-Sophia Daly is an award-winning journalist who covers immigration for Mission Local. Previously, she reported for the Miami Herald, where she covered education and worked on the investigative team. She graduated with honors from Skidmore College, where she studied International Affairs and Media/Film, and later earned a master’s degree from Columbia Journalism School.

Her reporting portfolio includes investigations into a gymnastics coach who abused his students for more than a decade — work that led to his arrest.

She also covered the privatization of Florida’s public education system, state-funded anti-abortion pregnancy centers, and the deputization of university police officers under federal immigration programs.

A Bay Area native, she first joined Mission Local as an intern for a year during the pandemic — and is excited to be back writing stories about immigration.

Got a tip? Email her at clarasophia@missionlocal.com. Her signal is clarasophia.13

Nicholas was born and raised in San Francisco, and has been tracking the city's changes and idiosyncrasies ever since. He holds a bachelor's degree in English literature, and has written for local outlets since 2024.

Nicholas writes the "Richmond Buzz" neighborhood column, and covers culture and news across town.

Leave a comment

Please keep your comments short and civil. Do not leave multiple comments under multiple names on one article. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *