A person wearing a white lab coat painted with a black silhouette of the United States and the text “Save our healthcare,” “Protect our doctors & patients.”
Outside of William J. Rutter Center, residents, nurses, and community members demand a stronger policy to keep patients and healthcare workers safe from ICE on Nov. 17, 2026. Photo by Zoe Malen.

A young man brought to a San Francisco emergency department earlier this year by immigration enforcement agents was terrified. His family did not know where he was, and he did not know when he would see them again. 

Dr. Francesco Sergi, a resident physician at the University of California, San Francisco who helped care for the man, said medical staff were able to contact his relatives and let them know he was alive and in the hospital. But other patients in Immigration and Customs Enforcement  custody have not been so lucky, Sergi said, with agents preventing them from contacting family or attorneys, and medical staff having to negotiate with ICE agents to protect patients’ rights.

Sergi was among more than 50 doctors, nurses and immigrant rights advocates who rallied outside a University of California Board of Regents meeting at UCSF in Mission Bay Tuesday morning, demanding that university leaders adopt systemwide policies to better protect patients in ICE custody.

Although state and local laws restrict immigration enforcement in hospitals, ICE agents can still accompany people who are already in their custody to medical appointments under California Senate Bill 81, enacted in September 2025. 

But healthcare workers on Tuesday demanded that the UC Board of Regents establish clearer rules to protect staff and patients: 

  • Requiring staff to ask agents to leave during medical exams;
  • Ensuring patients can communicate with family and lawyers; 
  • Verifying that patients can get follow-up care before they are sent back to detention.

According to Sergi, the UCSF resident physicians participating in Tuesday’s rally have, between them, cared for about 10 patients in ICE custody at San Francisco hospitals over the past year. In some encounters, he said, ICE agents have refused to leave examination rooms, prevented patients from contacting family members or attorneys and pressured doctors to discharge patients before a safe medical discharge plan was in place, he said. 

Without clear institutional rules, “a lot of folks are just unsure what to actually do in these contexts,” Sergi said. 

A person wears a purple T-shirt that reads “ICE OUT OF OUR HOSPITALS” in white letters.
Outside of William J. Rutter Center, UCSF Mission Bay, a rally takes place on Nov. 17, 2026 demanding ICE out of hospitals. Photo by Zoe Malen.

Debate over hospital safeguards

Dr. SatKartar Khalsa, a fourth-year emergency medicine resident at San Francisco General Hospital, and a regional vice president of the resident physicians’ union, said existing UC policies largely address cases in which agents enter hospitals to search for someone, rather than when ICE agents bring patients who are already in their custody.

Khalsa said agents have sometimes refused their requests to leave examination rooms, requiring negotiations before they could privately treat patients.

“You can feel it in the air, in the whole floor and the whole hospital when ICE is with a patient,” Khalsa said in an interview on Monday. “It just creates so much fear.”

In an emailed statement, a spokesperson for UC Health wrote, “UC is committed to providing safe, compassionate care to every patient, regardless of immigration status.” 

The statement says that UC has adopted the California Attorney General’s September 2026 guidelines as systemwide policy, which require hospitals to protect patient information and direct staff to notify administrators and consult legal counsel when immigration agents request access to facilities, patients or medical records.

“Care for patients who arrive in law enforcement custody follows the applicable hospital or clinic procedures,” the statement reads. 

The Attorney General’s guidelines address several issues raised by the residents, including patient privacy, communication with family members and attorneys and discharge planning. They direct healthcare workers to request that agents leave during examinations and report refusals to hospital administrators or legal counsel.

But the UC statement did not specify how individual hospitals have implemented those provisions, or whether staff have been trained on them. 

The union that represents UC resident physicians has proposed an eight-page “model policy” that would require all hospital staff to ask ICE agents to leave during medical examinations, facilitate confidential communication with relatives and lawyers and prevent ICE agents from making medical decisions for patients. 

The proposal goes further than the Attorney General’s guidelines in some respects, requiring written assurances that patients will receive medications and follow-up care before they are returned to immigration detention. 

Under the proposal, ICE would have to identify the medical provider responsible for a patient’s subsequent care and provide written assurances that prescribed medications, equipment and follow-up treatment would be available. 

The Attorney General’s guidelines require hospitals to make reasonable efforts to confirm that immigration facilities can meet patients’ medical needs, but provide for escalation and documentation when safe discharge cannot be verified. Neither the guidelines, nor the proposed policies, establish how hospitals could compel detention facilities to deliver promised care after patients are transferred.

Statewide push for patient protections

Elsewhere in California, healthcare workers have already pushed for stronger protections for patients.

Los Angeles County hospitals, including L.A. General Medical Center, adopted new policies in March governing the treatment of patients in immigration custody, including protections for patient privacy, and the right to communication with family members and lawyers.

Highland Hospital in Oakland has protocols directing staff to ask immigration agents to leave during medical evaluations, although healthcare workers there have raised concerns that the protocols aren’t being followed consistently.

Some UCSF nurses at Tuesday’s rally, who declined to give their names, also expressed fears for the safety of healthcare workers, citing the case of Ann Lawani, a nurse and professor at the University of San Francisco, who remains in ICE custody following her September arrest at her home in Lodi. 

The consequences of ICE presence at hospitals and clinics extend beyond the patients who are already in ICE custody, Khalsa said. They described treating other patients who had put off seeking medical attention for dangerous conditions because they feared being reported to immigration authorities.  

“I’ve had several patients that have delayed seeking care because of misconceptions that their presence would be reported to ICE or to the police,” Khalsa said. 

They described diabetes patients who required intensive care after they went without insulin, and others whose untreated high blood pressure caused organ damage. 

Khalsa and Sergi emphasized that they haven’t witnessed an ICE raid at a hospital, and that patients, no matter their immigration status, should not be afraid to get medical treatment. 

“We really want to set limits so that all of our patients can feel safe when they’re accessing care,” Sergi said. 

Protesters holding signs that read “Nurses Say Abolish ICE.”
Outside of William J. Rutter Center, residents, nurses, and community members march in a circle chanting “ICE Out” on Nov. 17, 2026. Photo by Zoe Malen.

Sarah Hopkins reports on SoMa, Mission Bay and other matters for Mission Local.

With a background in science writing, she has reported on environmental justice, climate change, technology and intersections between science, politics and law. She earned a master's degree from MIT's science journalism program in 2024.

Her reporting has appeared in the Guardian, Inside Climate News and Undark Magazine, among other publications. She is fluent in Spanish.

You can reach her securely on Signal @sarah.270.

Leave a comment

Please keep your comments short and civil. Do not leave multiple comments under multiple names on one article. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *