A sign for Golden Gateway Garage detailing hours of operation, a contact phone number, and notice of monthly parking availability.
The locus in quo: The city-owned Golden Gateway Garage on Nov. 6, 2026. SFMTA staff knowingly approved an agreement in April allowing more ICE vehicles to park at the garage. Photo by Clara-Sophia Daly.

The San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency knowingly leased parking spots in a city-owned garage to Immigration and Customs Enforcement this year, according to internal emails obtained through a public records request.

The emails document a clear violation of the city’s sanctuary law, which prohibits cooperation with immigration enforcement, according to a half-dozen immigration attorneys knowledgeable about sanctuary laws. 

SFMTA leadership told Mission Local it was not aware of its staffers’ actions until recently.

Earlier this month, Mission Local reported that ICE vehicles were parked in a city-owned downtown garage: The Golden Gateway Garage at 250 Clay St., just three blocks from the city’s ICE field office. 

A concrete parking structure wall along a city street lined with trees and parking meters.
The federal government-contracted section of Golden Gateway Garage at 250 Clay St. Photo by Nicholas David.

Hundreds of immigrants have been detained at that office, or taken there after being arrested in and around the Bay Area. ICE vehicles at the garage were used to transport agents and detained immigrants, including to and from enforcement operations, according to activists who have been monitoring the garage for months.

The city contracts a private firm, IMCO Parking, to operate the garage. Last month, Parisa Safarzadeh, a spokesperson for the SFMTA, said the agency was aware that the city had approved a subcontract between IMCO and the federal government for use of the garage, but said the agreement “does not specify” which agencies were assigned parking spots. 

From: xxxxxxxxxxx@sfmta.com

Sent: Wednesday, April 22, 2026 9:34 AM

To: xxxxxxxx@sfmta.com; xxxxxxxxx@sfmta.com

Subject: Re: ICE

Where is the for again? If we have the space, I don’t mind taking the money.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Parking & Curb Management
San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency


From: xxxxxxxxx@sfmta.com

Sent: Wednesday, April 22, 2026 8:57:32 AM

To: xxxxxxxxxx@sfmta.com; xxxxxxx@sfmta.com

Subject: Fw: ICE

Thoughts? It is revenue, afterall….

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Parking & Curb Management
San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency


From: xxxxxxxx@reimaginedparking.com

Sent: Wednesday, April 22, 2026 8:29 AM

Subject: Re: ICE

I appreciate your approval for the 28 spaces for $500 per space tax-exempt. Now, they would like to add 35 more additional space but outside the gated area. …

But emails obtained through a records request show SFMTA staff plainly knew the city-owned parking lot was used by ICE. The emails, from April 16 to Sept. 25 of this year, show two staff members more concerned with raising revenue from leasing parking spots to ICE than the city’s sanctuary ordinance. 

In April, the private parking operator that manages the Golden Gateway Garage emailed SFMTA staff to ask whether ICE could obtain 63 additional parking spaces in the garage, which since 2010 has had spots set aside for federal agencies, including ICE. 

“We were reach[ed] by DHS-ICE, and they would like to add … more space[s],” reads an April 16 email from an employee of parking operator to an SFMTA employee. The subject line of the email is “ICE.”

The emails obtained from SFMTA were redacted by the agency, and the employees’ names and email obscured. 

“Let me know your thoughts,” asks the IMCO employee.

The SFMTA employee responds, wanting details on the “current deal with ICE.” The SFMTA worker receives the information and, on April 20, writes, “Approved to proceed.”

In a subsequent email on April 22, the IMCO employee requests more parking spaces for ICE, saying the agency will pay between $430 and $500 per month, per space. 

At this point, the SFMTA staffer forwards the email to a colleague.

“Thoughts? It is revenue, afterall….” the staffer writes on April 22 at 8:57 a.m.

“Where is [this] for again? If we have the space, I don’t mind taking the money,” the colleague replies half an hour later.  

Months later, on Aug. 11, an IMCO staffer emails SFMTA staff asking for a signature on the lease for parking spaces. The email subject line is “ICE Lease.” Two SFMTA staffers, presumably the two employees involved in April, correspond about signing the lease.

“Do you want to sign off on this one?” one writes. “Sure. Send me a Docusign,” the other responds. 

The contract was eventually ratified in September.

“We are all set to move in,” reads a Sept. 24 email from an ICE staffer to a Reimagined Parking staffer, the parent company of IMCO. “Thank you, [redacted], for the support in this negotiation with Uncle Sam,” reads a Sept. 25 email from the parking operator. 

Angela Chan, an assistant chief at the public defender’s office who helped author both city and state sanctuary laws, is one of six attorneys who told Mission Local the exchanges reveal clear violations of the city’s longstanding prohibition against staff assisting immigrant enforcement.

“SFMTA flagrantly violated both the Sanctuary Ordinance and the ICE Free Zones Ordinance, which prohibit the use of city resources to assist with immigration enforcement,” Chan said, also citing a more recent law from Supervisor Bilal Mahmood. 

“They effectively turned part of a city garage into a staging ground for immigration raids throughout the Bay Area.” 

The prohibition against working with ICE should not have been a surprise to SFMTA employees, who received an all-staff memo in January 2025 reminding them that “City agencies and employees are generally prohibited from using city resources to assist ICE in enforcing federal immigration laws.”

SFMTA leadership did not know the two staffers had approved ICE use of the city’s garage until the issue was raised last month, the agency said.

Both staffers were subsequently fired, according to a department source and Supervisor Mahmood. 

SFMTA said it is “not a party” to the agreements between the private operator and the federal government. It said that “creates complications for the legal path forward.”

“We are deeply concerned about what we have learned in recent weeks, and I remain in regular communication with community members throughout the process,” read a statement from SFMTA Director of Transportation Julie Kirschbaum. 

“We continue to work closely with the City Attorney’s office to find a legal pathway to remove ICE from our garage and I will not stop this work until we identify a solution that achieves that goal.” 

Mission Local reported earlier this month that the city retains the “sole discretion” to terminate the parking garage contract. SFMTA has not said why it has chosen not to do so.

Sources within the SFMTA said the goal has “not been to get the operator out of the garage. The goal is to get ICE out of the garage.” IMCO, the garage operator, is a major contractor for the city. It manages 15 of 48 SFMTA parking facilities, according to documents reviewed by Mission Local. 

The parking contract is significant. According to the emails between SFMTA staffers, ICE had been paying more than $300,000 annually for 84 spaces in the Golden Gateway Garage on Clay Street since 2024, although ICE vehicles have been in the garage for at least 16 years, documents show.

The extra 63 spaces ICE requested in April would more than double the contract’s annual value.

Since the contract with ICE was publicized on Oct. 30, the SFMTA has consulted with the city attorney’s office and on Nov. 2 wrote a letter to the federal government asking it to “immediately remove” the ICE vehicles. The city attorney’s office did not respond to detailed questions, citing attorney-client privilege.

In a Nov. 18 letter to Mahmood, who had asked the agency for more information on the matter, the SFMTA wrote that, moving forward, parking garages would be managed directly by the agency, not private subcontractors. 

Shelby Weiss, a spokesperson for Mayor Daniel Lurie, did not answer questions about whether the city would cancel the contract and reiterated that “city resources cannot be used for civil immigration enforcement,” and that it is exploring “all options to remove the vehicles.”

David Campos, a former deputy city attorney and former city supervisor who authored a key amendment to the city’s sanctuary ordinance, said the SFMTA retains the “right” and “authority” to end its contract at any time. 

“If they allow this to continue,” he said, “it is because they are choosing to do so.”

Clara-Sophia Daly is an award-winning journalist who covers immigration for Mission Local. Previously, she reported for the Miami Herald, where she covered education and worked on the investigative team. She graduated with honors from Skidmore College, where she studied International Affairs and Media/Film, and later earned a master’s degree from Columbia Journalism School.

Her reporting portfolio includes investigations into a gymnastics coach who abused his students for more than a decade — work that led to his arrest.

She also covered the privatization of Florida’s public education system, state-funded anti-abortion pregnancy centers, and the deputization of university police officers under federal immigration programs.

A Bay Area native, she first joined Mission Local as an intern for a year during the pandemic — and is excited to be back writing stories about immigration.

Got a tip? Email her at clarasophia@missionlocal.com. Her signal is clarasophia.13

Nicholas was born and raised in San Francisco, and has been tracking the city's changes and idiosyncrasies ever since. He holds a bachelor's degree in English literature, and has written for local outlets since 2024.

Nicholas writes the "Richmond Buzz" neighborhood column, and covers culture and news across town.

Join the Conversation

3 Comments

  1. By this logic, isn’t the city breaking the law by providing water to the building ICE is operating out of? The city should also ban any incoming flights landing at SFO if an ICE agent is on board.

    +2
    -6
    votes. Sign in to vote
  2. “a clear violation of the city’s sanctuary law, which prohibits cooperation with immigration enforcement, according to half a dozen immigration attorneys”

    Well of course an immigration attorney is going to say that. Doesn’t make it true.

    Sanctuary laws, as well as being overridden by federal law, only require that the city doesn’t actively go out of its way to assist ICE. Nowhere does it say that ICE vehicles cannot use the city’s streets and parking facilities. Or that the city should impede the legal activities of federal law enforcement agencies. To disallow ICE vehicles would be blatantly discriminatory as well as running afoul of the supremacy clause.

    +6
    -12
    votes. Sign in to vote
Leave a comment
Please keep your comments short and civil. Do not leave multiple comments under multiple names on one article. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *