Bilal Mahmood of District 5 who, during the November 2024 election, was backed by political pressure groups such as GrowSF, is joining the group; GrowSF also secured a seat at the table.
Chyanne Chen of District 11, who was largely supported by organized labor. Unions only managed to get one representative at the table.
Alicia John-Baptiste, who is Lurie’s policy chief on infrastructure, climate and mobility, is representing the mayor’s office in the group.
Charter reform is now one of Lurie’s key priorities, according to the mayor’s office, and John-Baptiste is well-positioned to take the reins: She is the former CEO of SPUR, an urban think tank that recently published a report listing 10 charter reform recommendations, like increasing the power of the City Administrator and raising the threshold for issues to end up on the ballot for voters.
Senior city officials are also part of leading the conversation, including City Administrator Carmen Chu, who oversees more than 25 departments and an annual budget of over $750 million. One of the key recommendations from SPUR is to enhance the power of Chu’s position and department. City Controller Greg Wagner, who acts as the city’s auditor and chief financial officer, is also involved.
GrowSF influence is growing in the Lurie years: Tyler Law, Lurie’s former campaign consultant, is now serving as the group’s senior advisor, as is Lurie spokesperson Max Szabo. GrowSF has aligned itself with Lurie’s agenda, including the upzoning proposal and the effort to reform permitting in San Francisco.
From the business sector, Larry Baer, the president and CEO of the San Francisco Giants, joins the group as the co-chair of Advance SF, a business coalition advocating for downtown revitalization. The group’s members include major employers like OpenAI, Google, PG&E, Visa, Gap and Waymo.
Meredith Dodson, head of both the San Francisco Parent Coalition and its political affiliate SF Parent Action, is also at the table. Dodson and her group backed the 2022 school board recall.
Andres Power, a former policy director to former Mayor London Breed and co-founder of PR firm West Advisors, has found his way back to City Hall: He is at the table through Abundant SF, a YIMBY-aligned advocacy group pushing for housing and transit policies, and led by tech executive Zack Rosen and political strategist Todd David.
After publication, Melanie Matthewson, a legislative aide to Mandelman, said two more members from labor unions had been added to the effort: Zach Goldman, a staff director of SEIU 1021, which is the city employee’s union, and John Doherty, vice president for subcrafts at the San Francisco Building and Construction Trades Council, a group of 24 unions related to development.
Doherty also serves as the business manager and financial secretary of IBEW Local 6 representing electricians and electrical workers in San Francisco.
Likewise, major philanthropic foundations are joining the discourse on charter reform.
The foundation has become a key philanthropic partner to the Lurie administration, contributing to emergency food assistance, homelessness, and immigration defense, among other things. It is the largest family foundation in San Francisco, with $3.8 billion in assets.
Others are Fred Blackwell, the CEO of the San Francisco Foundation, who was also the executive director of the San Francisco Redevelopment Agency and the director of the mayor’s office of community development under former Mayor Gavin Newsom.
Bob Fisher is the son of the founders of retail giant Gap Inc. and a co-founding trustee of the Pisces Foundation, which supports environmental and community causes. Fisher has spent his career in retail and serves on the board of Gap, where he has held leadership roles including chief operating officer and president of brand operations.
Susan Hirsch is a principal at Third Plateau, a social impact consulting firm. Hirsch, a Bay Area philanthropist, is connected to Third Plateau through the merger of her firm, Hirsch Philanthropy Partners, into the consulting group.
Arce is also a special assistant to Northern California District Council of Laborers and was the director of San Francisco’s Office of Economic and Workforce Development for five years from 2018 to 2023.
Katherine August-deWilde, president of Partnership for San Francisco, represents major employers focused on downtown revitalization. Rodney Fong, CEO of the Chamber of Commerce, and Tim Omi, president of the Council of District Merchants Associations, are also at the table. Anna Marie Presutti, the CEO of SF Travel, joins them.
There is also Shola Olatoye, the inaugural CEO of the San Francisco Downtown Development Corporation, a nonprofit that channels private funds into public improvements for downtown revitalization. The group has raised over $60 million so far, including money from billionaires such as Gap’s Fisher, who is also in this charter reform group, and Ripple’s Chris Larsen.
SPUR’s governance proposals also served as the basis for Lurie’s move toward using policy chiefs, a deputy-mayor-like system to streamline how city department heads report to the mayor.
Rosenfield previously served as the mayor’s budget director for five years under Mayor Willie Brown, and as the city controller for 16 years. He was known as the “adult in the room”, and respected by politicos of all stripes during his tenure at City Hall.
Natalie Sandoval is the other think-tank representative; she is the executive director of the Urban Land Institute San Francisco. Sandoval is also the vice-chair of the Oakland planning commission.
Lynn Mahoney is representing San Francisco State University as its 14th president.
Anni Chung, president and CEO of Self-Help for the Elderly, represents programs serving mostly immigrant seniors with health, social, educational, and housing services.
Michael Pappas, executive director of the San Francisco Interfaith Council, connects diverse faith communities to support vulnerable populations.
Shakirah Simley, executive director of the Booker T. Washington Community Service Center, brings the perspective of one of the city’s oldest Black-led and Black-serving community organizations.
Sherilyn Adams, CEO from Larkin Street Youth Services, is also in the charter-reform group, though she was accidentally left off from the mayor’s initial list, according to Matthewson of Mandelman’s office.



Thank you for the introduction to the group. Could you please point me to an article where the reasons for the ‘reform’ as stated by this group of unelected people are outlined?
I presume the lack of an Inspector General, the failure to use prop C funding for permanent housing (and reigning in the ability of the mayor to thwart the peoples wishes by not funding or spending the money gathered by measures passed by the people), and the failure to provide affordable housing for working people will not be addressed in this ‘reform’.
Hector, we desperately need reform so that the billionaire oligarchs behind 90% of this commission can have lower taxes and eliminate all the pesky environmental, safety, and labor regulations that impede their economic objective (i.e., owning every square on the game board, all the pieces, and all the $$$).
Why not skip this Potemkin malarky and just go full techno-feudal, since that’s where this is clearly heading?
Waymo is a major SF employer? And google already listed …
No MUNI or public works representatives?
Does this mean the charter will work on the evil goal of continued degradation/replacement of our public transit with Waymo and their ilk? Waymo is the new Uber …
No need to engage with a chat model to see obvious gaps in representation here:
School district, Fire, police, parks, port, SFO, Latino community, artists, scientists – it’s a long list!
many thanks to Mission Local for this day lighting reporting – more journalist awards on the way!!
“obvious gaps in representation here: School district, Fire, police, parks, port, SFO, Latino community, artists, scientists”
So how many people do you want on this commission? 50? 100? That would guarantee nothing would get done.
And all those folks would say is to repeat the past mistakes – spraying money at those who add the least. Reward losers and punish winners.
This is a coup by the rich. Don’t fall for it.
Excuse me, largely unelected group.
So what? They were appointed by elected officials. So if you don’t like this choice, then vote differently.
Appointed by whom exactly? Zero transparency here, just how they like it
The article answers your question: by Lurie and Mandelman.
the article clearly states the taskforce was appointed by the Mayor and Board President.
Reform of the City Charter has been a stated goal of the Mayor.
Before any one gets mad and tries to argue, I’m not taking a position on the membership of this taskforce, just explaining some simple misunderstandings.
I think it’s fairly straightforward government policy that the (elected) Mayor can create working groups to study issues and propose recommendations.
Any reforms to the City Charter need to be approved by the voter (and can be placed on the ballot either by petitions or the Board)
You had a vote on those who appoint such commissions. If you did not use that vote wisely then that is nobody else’s fault.
What horseradish.
Disgusting. I trust exactly 2 of that group with doing anything actually positive for SF residents.
The rest are carpetbaggers and climbers.
I can see SF’s new constitution now. It’s one page and says, “only billionaires and corporations will be eligible to vote.” The rest is about increasing taxes on everyone under a 250 million net worth, eliminating taxes on the wealthy.
We’re getting railroaded here.
Can we finally put to rest that San Francisco is a progressive city? It is not. And it is not a city that even pretends to represent its constituents that make under six (and probably seven) figures. It is a city that has given up the pretense of building affordable housing or making it possible for the working class (and even middle class) people who do so many of the city’s jobs to live here. A city by the wealthy for the wealthy, symbolized by our billionaire mayor.
It has never been actually controlled by progressives. I worked on the Matt Gonzales and witnessed the death of that movement at the hand of Gavin Newsom, subsequently buried and piled on upon by the Citizens United ruling that equates corporate spending with Constitutionally protected individual free speech which is no longer protected from persecution. We watched this backslide of Democratic ideals happen under so-called ‘Democratic’ leadership and processes. We didn’t stop it. Our options have only diminished since that time.
Sure do wish Gonzalez hadn’t pitched in his “Green Party” support for the SFUSD school board recall, validating it as some sort of progressive hero. Hearsay is that his support was based on the George Washington mural issue? Ironically Gonzalez, at the time of his run, couldn’t have cared less about Ammianos Prop H and funding such trifles as art, sports or music in our public schools. Don’t forget that Mike Pence was at Stanford the night of the heavily funded BOE recall, CONGRATULATING the Bay Area for it. For anyone still thinking the BOE “deserved it” please note that it was that election which began the trajectory, bringing us to where we are now. A tech housewife transplant with extremely limited experience with or context for our public schools is now “steering” the discussion. Shame.
What an incredibly unrepresentative bunch of people. Money doesn’t talk, it swears. I think it was Karl Marx who said that. Batten down the hatches. Peskin’s alternative ballot proposal was a mistake. (Which is why I voted against it.)
It’s going to take many years and administrations to unwind the damage this group is going to do, if it will even be possible.
It was Bob Dylan from hi song “”m alright Ma”. It was a big loss for our city that Aaron lost to Lurie😢💔
Waymo is a major SF employer? And google already listed …
No MUNI or public works representatives?
Does this mean the charter will work on the evil goal of continued degradation/replacement of our public transit with Waymo and their ilk? Waymo is the new Uber …
No need to engage with a chat model to see obvious gaps in representation here:
School district, Fire, police, parks, port, ethnic community, artists, scientists – it’s a long list!
many thanks to Mission Local for this day lighting reporting – more journalist awards on the way!!
What would a Muni representative have to offer on this topic? Other than their usual bleating to give them more money?
This initiative is about change and not more of the status quo.
Where is the representation of Latino and working class San Franciscans?
Larry Baer, huh? Another person from the San Francisco Giants on the board but the Giants themselves can’t attract top events to their park that other parks can. Point and case is the Savannah Bananas who wanted to play at Oracle Park. But no, the Giants couldn’t figure out the finances to make it happen. Other major cities – San Diego, Anaheim, Chicago, Boston, Sacramento, Scottsdale, New York can figure out when attracting people to their City is a higher value than getting gate taxes, but San Francisco apparently can’t.