A large neoclassical building with a prominent dome, symmetrical facade, columned entrance, and a wide plaza lined with trimmed trees.
Polk and Grove. San Francisco City Hall faces Civic Center Plaza early morning, October 2025. Photo by Jay A. Martin.

With good luck and a free and fair election, Democrats could win in Texas, Maine, Michigan, Kansas, Alaska, Iowa, Ohio and elsewhere. In Los Angeles, a democratic socialist is in the catbird seat to win the mayor’s race. 

In many of these places, San Francisco is still viewed as a wild realm where barefoot hippies roam the streets, Pigpen McKernan and Janis Joplin will take all your booze and drugs, and doped-up vagrants will kill us all by giving everybody syphilis. 

But San Francisco is going in a different direction. It’s been going in a different direction for a long time. Voters here, barring unforeseen lunacy, will likely punch a straight or damn near straight ticket that’s a longtime wishlist and lavish recipient of record-breaking donations from button-down billionaires. 

Should that wishlist be fulfilled — and funding differentials and every other indication strongly suggests it will be — San Francisco voters will blithely abridge their ability to place legislation directly onto the ballot, a right granted to them in 1898, 13 years before California women were given the right to vote. 

All it took was nearly $14 million dollars (and counting), which has deluged the city’s mailboxes and cellphones and televisions with messages that the road to hell is paved with a system of checks and balances, and that governance is best left to one person (the mayor).

The effort to pass this and other measures to strengthen mayoral power — and drastically curtail the ability of less wealthy politicians, unions or regular people to signature-gather items onto the ballot (most notably, taxes on big business) — is outraising its opposition by a margin of nearly 19-to-1.

Team Lurie has amassed enough money to purchase a high-end M1 Abrams tank to consolidate mayoral power, against around three-quarters of a million bucks aimed at undercutting Prop. D, just one of his three measures (D, E and F)  

Is San Francisco still a liberal city? It depends on what you mean by “liberal.” Candidates here who try to whip up the electorate with dire warnings about transgender people trying to infiltrate your restroom or your daughter’s sports team tend to clock about 4% of the vote.

But, for more than 30 years, San Francisco voters have opted for citywide leaders who generally favor less regulation and taxation of business, a police-oriented approach to crime and disorder, tougher sanctions on the homeless, and less-generous general city services. 

That’s not exactly big-city liberalism, let alone socialism. San Franciscans do not get worked up about gun control, abortion rights or minority rights either; these are settled issues. We are fighting about budgeting, public safety, surveillance and other municipal issues. The paths we are taking there are not necessarily reflexively liberal, either.

A collection of political mailers and a newspaper clipping featuring portraits of a man in a suit, with text including “YES” and “Vote.”
Lurie, Lurie everywhere: Mayor Daniel Lurie’s committee to ‘clean up city hall’ has raked in filthy amounts of money and blanketed the city in real and virtual ads.

The times, they are a-changing: In 2024, San Francisco, a renter-supermajority town, voted down a statewide measure seeking to expand rent control by a gaudy 57 to 43 ratio. In prior eras, that would’ve been unthinkable. 

In just 2018 alone, San Francisco approved (signature-gathered) measures that gleaned billions from big businesses to fund homeless housing and programming and early childhood care. 

That was then. This year, in June, voters spurned Prop. D, a union-led drive to plug a hole in the city budget by levying a tax on businesses whose top executive gets paid more than 100 times the salary of the company’s median employee.

The prevailing view had been that, even a small amount of campaign cash would be enough for a measure appealing to San Franciscans — like, you know, a tax on companies with greedy CEOs. 

No more: Mayor Daniel Lurie mustered a big-dollar campaign against it. The measure lost, and it wasn’t particularly close. It was an epochal moment — and a gut punch for city labor, which blew all its money trying to pass it. 

In the last decade, signature-gatherers or a minority of the Board of Supervisors placed tax measures on the ballot no fewer than 15 times. If, on Tuesday, voters agree to elevate the ballot threshold, it’s difficult to foresee big businesses being subjected to any unwanted taxes moving forward. 

And yes: That’s what this is really about. 

So, if the nation goes as Democrats hope and pray, San Francisco will be what it always is: an outlier. But not the manner of outlier San Franciscans are accustomed to thinking of themselves. 

Cartoon shows wealthy businessmen labeled “trusts” as robber barons guarding money bags, while workers kneel and scrape for coins. A banner reads “Stiff is Unopolol.” Background: factory and field.
‘History repeats itself…’ Illustration by Samuel D. Ehrhart, 1889, Puck Magazine

There is an established San Francisco election tradition of not even waiting for all the election night votes to be counted to proclaim that the results reinforce your preexisting narrative. 

Your humble narrator is violating that tradition — somewhat — by not even waiting for election night; zero votes have thus far been counted. 

Could we be surprised? Possibly. But it doesn’t feel that way: If this election were an NCAA tournament, it’d be one where you could reliably pick all the top seeds and, guess what? Duke and Kentucky in the finals. 

Despite a scandal here and there — dubious contracts, poorly vetted appointees, too much coffee and Instagram — Mayor Lurie remains earnest, likeable, omnipresent and popular.

He has activated an entirely new donor class (largely wealthy people he worked with in the nonprofit world). He also benefits from big-dollar donations from this city’s messianic tech billionaires, some of whom backed his opponents in 2024. 

He’s got old money, he’s got new money, he’s got his own money. It’s a lot of money. That helps when you’re also subsidizing a 24/7/365 political PR campaign. 

There have always been wealthy and powerful San Franciscans, and this has always been a big-money town. But San Francisco’s wealthiest now have unprecedented control of city politics.

Given the city’s serial boomtown status, this is a significant claim to make: Historian Gray Brechin notes that, for many decades, all of California was de facto ruled not from Sacramento but from 1 Market St., which was formerly known as the Southern Pacific Building, named for the railroad that, yes, de facto ruled California. 

But what’s different now is not just the level of inequity but the utter weakness and rudderlessness of even token opposition to this concentration of wealth and power. 

A decade ago, it was a scandal that VCs were sending around emails soliciting four-digit donations from their colleagues or telling CEOs how to lecture their employees to vote. Now, VCs drop $500,000 on their preferred political candidates with all the nonchalance of someone buying a pitcher of hoppy lager at the local tavern. 

In the olden days of 2019, no millionaire or billionaire saw fit to put serious money into the DA’s race. Those days are over. After Chesa Boudin eked out a narrow victory, during the pandemic, the city’s haves staged something of an ideological Brooks Brothers riot.

The level of vitriol and money, and vitriolic money, skyrocketed. Donors playing .500 ball politically with hefty donations have supersized their gives, a strategy akin to “blitz scaling.” 

He’s got old money, he’s got new money, he’s got his own money. It’s a lot of money. 

Many millions of dollars as a political ante is irrelevant to the city’s richest. The $500,000 recently dropped by cryptocurrency billionaire Chris Larsen to back his preferred District 10 supervisor candidate is akin to a person with a $1 million net worth donating around $37.

The city’s neighborhoods-vs.-Downtown power struggles of yesteryear are now neighborhoods-vs.-global wealth.

Even before they were drowned in cash, the city’s so-called progressives were underwater; their progressive social and governmental ideals that didn’t threaten the wealthy, like marriage equality or universal healthcare, were long ago appropriated by the city’s moderates.

Everything else that can’t be explained in an Instagram stand-up — housing, public safety, evidence-based methods of treating drug addiction — splintered the coalitions that once propelled grassroots candidates into office. 

The city’s remaining progressives have lost more than political power: They’re losing the demographics game.

There is less and less of a viable working class living within San Francisco city limits. Tenants are no longer a coherent political force. The young progressives who once flocked to the city can’t afford to live here.

The ones who gained a foothold when the gaining was good skew older and older, and aging progressive leaders are struggling to speak the same political language as the city’s younger voters. And city progressives have long skewed disproportionately white. 

For some time, it’s been hard to put a finger on what city progressives stand for. They do complain — accurately — that their opponents are funded by billionaires.

But the solutions, so far, have looked mostly like  proposing revenue measures to soak big business, and using that money to fund programs and nonprofits that can barely patch the hole that the rising cost of housing (and everything else ) has torn in the city fabric.

And on Tuesday, voters will likely implode the ability to signature-gather for such revenue measures. 

A collection of political mailers and flyers advocating for San Francisco Propositions C, D, E, and F, featuring photos of Daniel Lurie and lists of endorsements.
The 2026 San Francisco Midterm Election is brought to you by Mayor Daniel Lurie

If and when Lurie’s charter reforms are enacted, he will be one of the most powerful mayors in the city’s history — and this city already had a strong-mayor system.

Lurie will have a free hand to remake city departments and reshuffle hundreds of employees and the majority of city commissioners will find themselves sitting atop a figurative trap door, ready to be dropped into a pit of fire for a single displeasing vote. Or, in fact, for no reason at all. 

He all but certainly won’t have to worry about signature-gathered revenue measures anymore. 

But even a mayor blessed with electorally mandated bionic enhancements won’t have the ability to counter the city’s biggest problem. San Franciscans worked themselves into a lather about lawlessness and chaos when the city’s reported crime rates hit historic lows.

But San Francisco really is facing an affordability crisis, which figures to go to infinity and beyond with the coming IPOs of Anthropic and Open AI. 

If and when residents begin laying affordability problems at Lurie’s feet, he’d be in trouble — because no mayor can expediently lift this city out of an affordability crisis.

San Francisco’s chief executive cannot unilaterally lower interest rates. Even if the mayor wanted to, he or she couldn’t stanch the reams of international wealth that flow into the city — which drives up prices at speeds far outstripping even the most expedited construction schedules. 

That’s San Francisco’s challenge for the future. What this city will look like in the coming years is anyone’s guess. But what it won’t look like is the city of Pigpen and Janis, where rent was cheap and life was wild. Sooner or later, the rest of the nation may catch on to that. 

Sooner or later, we may too.  

Joe is a columnist and the managing editor of Mission Local. He was born in San Francisco, raised in the Bay Area, and attended U.C. Berkeley. He never left.

“Your humble narrator” was a writer and columnist for SF Weekly from 2007 to 2015, and a senior editor at San Francisco Magazine from 2015 to 2017. You may also have read his work in the Guardian (U.S. and U.K.); San Francisco Public Press; San Francisco Chronicle; San Francisco Examiner; Dallas Morning News; and elsewhere.

He resides in the Excelsior with his wife and three (!) kids, 4.3 miles from his birthplace and 5,474 from hers.

The Northern California branch of the Society of Professional Journalists named Eskenazi the 2019 Journalist of the Year.

Join the Conversation

50 Comments

  1. ” Tenants are no longer a coherent political force.”

    Why is that Joe? Is it because the “Progressives” have been pushing anti-housing policies on tenants for decades and that they have finally woken up to this?

    There is plenty of support for real Progressive policies: limits on policing, including Flock cameras, support for social services, including housing for the homeless, and higher taxes (probably, we will see how C and J do – but I predict they will win and I is still too close to call). But the natural base for the Progressive movement in San Francisco has (finally!) soured on the anit-housing preservations wolves in Progressive clothing.

    San Francisco desperately needs a muscular left to oppose the billionaires. It won’t come the limousine liberal class of land owning preservationists: Peskin, Chan or Preston. We need new Progressive leaders in the Mamdani mold.

    +11
    -4
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. Any progressive movement that doesn’t want young, high earning, urban tech workers (big part of Mamdani’s base!) in its coalition is obviously DOA in 2026. SF’s “progressives” are just western neighborhood NIMBYs, old school preservationist NIMBYs, and the NGO / Union industrial complex.

      +5
      -4
      votes. Sign in to vote
    2. The path to muscular progressive/leftism does not run through public sector labor unions or government funded nonprofit poverty charities.

      +3
      -3
      votes. Sign in to vote
    3. I 97% agree with this comment, but not with lumping Dean Preston in with Peskin and Chan. Dean worked harder to build housing in his district than almost any supervisor. I was just walking by the new affordable building at Haight and Stanyan and saw lights on on the 7th and 8th floors. Those people have homes because when London Breed’s housing department proposed six stories, Dean insisted: make it taller.

      Not all of his efforts were that successful because they were blocked by moderates like Breed, and those that were successful, his contribution was erased. For example, after he’d pushed for literally years for housing on the Panhandle DMV site, Gavin Newsom invited Breed, but not Preston to the press conference announcing the state was evaluating it.

      It’s true that Dean didn’t prioritize market-rate developments in low-income, gentrifying neighborhoods, and sometimes voted in favor of challenges from neighbors seeking more affordability in these cases, but here too, memory is selective. Eight supervisors voted in favor of the challenge to the infamous Nordstrom’s parking lot development, including Myrna Melgar, who has gone on to become a YIMBY hero anyway. And Dean never opposed a building because of its height or aesthetics, unlike Peskin, and for that matter unlike Stephen Sherrill, who raged against the Marina Safeway development in his district and held onto his SF YIMBY endorsement anyway.

      Dean Preston was also the first supervisor to support making Car-Free JFK permanent, and has consistently supported Sunset Dunes. So I think you have a point with regard to Peskin and Chan, but Dean isn’t part of that neighborhood preservationist wing. Look past the GrowSF spin, and he is already the left-urbanist change you (and I) want to see.

      +4
      -6
      votes. Sign in to vote
      1. Peskin, Chan and Preston are all united as servants of city funded poverty charity nonprofits and public sector labor unions.

        The charity nonprofits most instrumental in land use policies are the Affordable Housing (TM) developers at the Council of Community Housing Organizations/SF Information Clearinghouse which has set the progressive land use agenda for 30+ years.

        When these complex political and economic systems are maximized on one variable–fund Affordable Housing (TM) and poverty nonprofits and increase union headcount–then all other variables are distorted.

        “Progressive” land use and housing policy has been constrained to serve the needs of driving more money in in-lieu and impact fees to these nonprofits. Dean Preston took no steps to challenge this regime, other than dropping $100K on Prop I to feed the beast. Connie Chan and Aaron Peskin defer to the SFIC cartel and advanced its interests.

        DSA, for its part, has been captured by these corrupt operators. This is why DSA SF has been constrained to demanding more money for labor and poverty nonprofits and their means testing while DSA nationwide has made strides on a broad based universal non-means tested affordability agenda.

        As one who is 10 months away from Medicare, I can state that these ideas have not changed in 30 years as the City has changed, since these ideas have not gained traction and the City has moved on.

        What we have are people who should be retired trying to set a political agenda for people who are 1/3 of their age, and trying to inculcate these failed, corrupt approaches into the next generation.

        +6
        -2
        votes. Sign in to vote
      2. I walked past the The Hub which remains a shelled out Honda dealership and other holes in the ground because Dean lied and said we needed to spend another decade to study a plan that took S.F. Planning a decade to write.

        +5
        -1
        votes. Sign in to vote
      3. Scottf,

        Wonderful summation of Preston’s career.

        I first met him at one of our weekly ‘Mayoral Candidates Debate’ in front of City Hall in 2007 when I was running against Newsom and De Renzo and I and all of the other candidates except for Newsom gathered weekly and it was a Pure San Francisco scene …

        A little taste …

        ‘Grasshopper’ who had a huge thing got on top of his illegal cab naked and played a pretty cool heavy metal riff filled guitar while Kenny the Clown (used to play B ball for Cal) weaved around the crowd on a skateboard twirling flaming batons and ‘Naked Yoga’ author George Davis (also a candidate) did his standing around in the raw thing and I supported Dr. Ahimsa Sumchai and Bill Lee told me that ‘they’ watched us out the Mayor’s windows and considered having us all arrested now that was an election season that we did ten or twelve weeks in a row closing the season with The League of Women Voters Forum at the Main library where I brought the house down by replying to Gavin siding with a question about more Big Brother cameras by agreeing that putting more cameras around was a good thing to which I replied to a stunned packed house …

        “Yeah, Gavin, if there had been more cameras in City Hall last year you wouldn’t be up here on this stage today would you ?”

        The Venue was drowned in a combination of loud groans and laughter.

        We’ll leave that there as an inside baseball.

        Preston was watching and I didn’t recognize him and after he showed up a couple of times I got suspicious because he was wearing a suit and went over and accused him of being an FBI agent.

        Guys like Dean and Gonzalez and Chesa and Harvey Rose make my addiction to this Scene worth it.

        go Niners !!

        h.

        +1
        -5
        votes. Sign in to vote
  2. What an odd framing.

    Only in San Francisco are (so-called) “progressives” against a dramatic increase in housing supply in order to address the underlying “5-decades-in-the-making” housing shortage driven by “local control” NIMBYism.

    Only in San Francisco do (so-called) “progressives” back status quo anti-housing candidates like Connie Chan, Dean Preston and Aaron Peskin.

    Progressives everywhere else in the country, e.g. NYC Mayor Mamdani, support all-of-the-above pro-housing policies.

    Go figure.

    +10
    -7
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. > “Progressives everywhere else in the country, e.g. NYC Mayor Mamdani, support all-of-the-above pro-housing policies.”

      In NYC, the current high-profile progressive candidates are Darializa Avila Chevalier and Claire Valdez, whose political rhetoric on housing is indistinguishable from Chan/Preston/Peskin. Also, Mamdani supports strong tenant protection, which you and your ilk reject.

      Your desire for neoliberal, Pride-flag-flying social conservatives like yourself to be considered the true progressives reeks of desperation. You’re a real estate attorney, not a progressive.

      +6
      -5
      votes. Sign in to vote
      1. RLE,

        You’re really brilliant and I’ve waited for either you or Marcos to final tire of Karl’s screeching lies and misrepresentations.

        You’re smart too, Karl but reading you is irritating for anyone who knows as much or more than you and cares about how the issues touch ordinary people.

        I’m somewhat surprised that none of you have gone over the edge and drank the Koolaid and bought the line or fallen in the trap or been snowed like I have been with Artificial Intelligence at Present and the effects it will in my opinion have on Future elections.

        I give you Elon Musk:

        “There is no way we can control something so much smarter than us.”

        And, Yuval Harari:

        “There is a hill where I live that has no diamonds or gold or even good soil but 3 billion people are willing to die fighting over control of that hill because they have conflicting stories about that hill.”

        and

        “Language is the OS (operating system) of the Human species and AI has hacked our language and can use it to control us.”

        Anyway, I’m steeped in this stuff and I don’t believe elections will have any meaning at all pretty much from now on and that’s a good thing for Humanity and especially for Planet Earth.

        After today’s election of Connie Chan we can get back to real action …

        go Niners !!

        h.

        0
        -7
        votes. Sign in to vote
  3. Media largely treating Lurie with kid gloves has also played a role in giving him Teflon status come election time. He seems to be given the benefit of the doubt in ways that media would never do for a progressive.

    +9
    -6
    votes. Sign in to vote
  4. Things really began to go downhill when Gavin Newsom gamed the system, delaying his appointment as lieutenant governor, in order to appoint Ed Lee as mayor. Ron Conway being his puppet master, Lee was a critical component in the takeover of SF by Uber, Airbnb and other tech-related businesses. London Breed continued Lee’s efforts and here we are now with a mayor who is so predictable and despicable that he could be replaced by an AI mayor and nobody would notice.

    I remember when Dr. Julianne Malveaux spearheaded the effort to collect signatures and get a proposition on the November 1984 ballot that divested San Francisco pension fund from South African investments, due to Apartheid.

    Now we have a Mayor and billionaires who want to make it more difficult for citizens to get often-meaningful propositions on the ballot, all the while they included a poorly-worded proposition on tomorrow’s ballot that targets one person (if anyone at all) and does not improve the lives of San Franciscans – or anyone else.

    Still, I’m convinced that the mayor, his cronies on the BOS, his billionaire pals and others will all be defeated by their own hubris. Hopefully, there will be something left of what we know as San Francisco.

    +7
    -5
    votes. Sign in to vote
  5. “In order to deal with the crisis of unaffordable entry-level automobiles, I propose to unleash the magic of the free market and create a glut of Lamborghinis and Ferraris. Trickle down, yatch!”

    +5
    -3
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. Nonprofit funded affordable housing in San Francisco starts at $1,000,000 per door to build, by the way. I guess we’re making Lambos and Ferraris for the low income?

      +2
      -1
      votes. Sign in to vote
      1. It’s now actually closer to $1.25MM per door — and it more like a Model T at Lambo/Ferrari pricing.

        It’s an utterly ineffective, nonsensical and unsustainable approach to the housing crisis — which is fundamentally a chronic housing shortage — 5 decades in the making — which is driving up housing costs across the board.

        (So-called) “progressives” in SF fail/refuse to acknowledge this fundamental economic fact — whereas (actual) progressives in the rest of the country understand this reality.

        +3
        0
        votes. Sign in to vote
  6. “For some time, it’s been hard to put a finger on what city progressives stand for. They do complain — accurately — that their opponents are funded by billionaires. But the solutions, so far, have looked mostly like proposing revenue measures to soak big business, and using that money to fund programs and nonprofits that can barely patch the hole that the rising cost of housing (and everything else ) has torn in the city fabric. And voters will on Tuesday likely implode the ability to signature-gather for such revenue measures. ”

    Cue “The Miracle Worker” theme: “He knows! HE KNOWS!”

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QlKuJBiw1ac

    Next up:

    – How did we get to a place where the progressive left is advancing nationally but retreating in San Francisco?

    – How do we detach those who led us here from future leadership and access to resources to enforce that?

    – What kind of novel political structures can we build to both chart a path out of the wilderness that the cartel, the junior partners of the political class, led us into to ensure that this kind of cooption will never happen again?

    +5
    -4
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. What we have here is that funded operators have control over labor and city funded nonprofits and that these operators only do what they’re funded to do.

      They are funded to hold political portfolios that do not resonate with the voters, they only center that which is funded.

      We’ve seen this in the Mission where the only times that the nonprofit cartel “lights up” are when there is funding involved or to be had or even goes silent when their stated agenda is overrun by funding.

      Nowhere in the cartel’s portfolio do we see policies or reforms promulgated for any public facing government function such as DPW, Rec and Park, Muni or even the fricken Library or Ethics, policies that might make a material difference for working San Franciscans.

      Instead, we get a monomaniacal fixation on housing and homelessness and running revenue measures to launder money through that.

      Housing relies on scaring the shit out of tenants for decades with no hint of solutions, crying wolf, and maximizing politics solely on funding Affordable Housing (TM), feeding the grift.

      Homeless and public squalor are defended using demographic craven prejudice fueled guilt trips and shaming. CoH has lost 7 successive practically identical punitive anti-homeless ballot measures and changed nothing in their political approach. In street addicts, the revenue addicted political class sees themselves.

      This agenda has long since failed to resonate, yet they’re repeating the same thing over and again, expecting a different result each time.

      It is not all about housing and land use. It is not all about public sector labor good union jobs. It is not about serving a political class.

      It is about reading the population scale political room to figure out where popular sentiment intersects with a progressive political agenda that is not bound by funding and might conflict with that funded agenda.

      +2
      -5
      votes. Sign in to vote
  7. Where does this put San Francisco overall? e.g., are we moving from 80th percentile left most in the U.S. to 70th percentile?

    +3
    -2
    votes. Sign in to vote
  8. If you want to know why progressive politics are failing, look no further than progressive poster child Tim Redmond (48Hills) commentary on Joe’s article:
    “There is no such thing as a legitimate progressive agenda that doesn’t start with taxing the rich. Even if all the money we get from those taxes isn’t used productively, reducing the wealth at the top is critical to our survival as a society.”

    He said the quiet part out loud. Tim’s progressive world view is not about helping those at the bottom. It’s about hurting those at the top. That sort of nihilistic, zero-sum thinking — where it’s better to reduce the pie for everyone rather than allow some people to accumulate too much wealth is exactly why the majority have moved on from the San Francisco progressive dinosaurs. Their solution to everything is more taxes regardless of whether the spending creates any benefit. “Reducing wealth at the top” is their goal regardless if that makes everyone worse off

    +2
    -3
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. @Greg 26 – Redmon’s “reducing the wealth” framing is unfortunate simply because of how people like you will distort it, but the underlying fact is undeniable: the transfer of wealth from the many to the few is the problem here. It’s what’s damaging those at the bottom, and progressives are right to focus on it.

      0
      -4
      votes. Sign in to vote
  9. We need an article explaining who owns homes and rental units to really get the distinction between the supply and demand argument vs wealth inequality. We have all seen the empty units of owners who are waiting it out. I am also tired of hearing from owners who complain about rent control and have no self awareness of or gratitude for the property tax controls.

    Also, the discourse around signature thresholds is confusing. It seems that whatever ballot item is added, the 1% interests put two more to combat it. Is it really a successful tactic? or more about putting it on a ballot so prople talk about it and eventually come to see the evidence? Can we not legislate without ballot items?

    +1
    -2
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. @Cassandra – With the passage of Prop D, grassroots campaigns without a ton of money will have an even harder time gathering signatures. Well-funded astroturf campaigns will of course continue to buy their way onto the ballot.

      +1
      -2
      votes. Sign in to vote
  10. Yeah, we been whipped pretty good,

    I’d argue that Willie had much more power than any of the long line of lackeys all the way up to Lurie who is the only one with his own money and, keep in mind that my talking clock (Alexa) says that the Mayor only has 30 to 50 million and his mom is worth a billion three so if she get’s pissed at him he’s as poor as Chakrabarti.

    lol

    Naw, Willie controlled every appointment to every commission and he changed Elections bosses 3 times I believe it was within 2 years so’s he could get one to order a couple of million ballots out of state for his private stockpile and I don’t know if those were the ones that ended up over a bar in Stinson Beach but they were everywhere and the upshot was that Newsom get’s to run for President.

    Yeah, Willie appointed Gavin as a solid to Gordon Getty whose son was Gav’s bestie.

    Willie once fired a Planning Commission member for being the sole vote against overloading Sutro Tower with a few tons more antennae against the advice of engineers whom everyone know don’t know shit.

    lol

    Willie’s real power that none of the other mayors had including this one is that he was widely loved by the City Workers and I watched him stand up in front of a couple of thousand of them and say something like this …

    “How many of you didn’t have a job until I gave you one ?!”

    “I’ll tell you what, if you don’t do what I say now you won’t have a job tomorrow!”

    Bottom line on Lurie is still that he’s not an asshole with two faces so that counts for a lot with people like me who think the Big Train from Howard Street and Silicon Valley is about the change it all and I mean before Mayor Lurie finishes his second term.

    go Niners !!

    h.
    The longer I look back on the Gonzalez years the more I am amazed how much power he was able to get away from the Mayor and give back to the people like appointments to the Police Commission and Planning Commission and Elections Commission and the Board of Appeals and every other major commission as I recollect.

    This is just the pendulum swinging back to the right only this time

    +4
    -6
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. Ran into Kathrin Moore at Rainbow yesterday. She finally stepped down from the Planning Commission after 20 yr.

      Ammiano said in 2008 that this is merely a swing of the pendulum and that things would swing back. That’s not happening. This is a sandbagging, a controlled demolition, a managed surrender, an inside job.

      +3
      -2
      votes. Sign in to vote
      1. @marcos – The “pendulum” is a myth, right up there with the horseshoe, and both are literally 1-dimensional thinking. Tales told to overlook far more complicated realities.

        +5
        -1
        votes. Sign in to vote
        1. Jym,

          Don’t pick a word fight with Marcos.

          It would be like picking a sword fight with Zorro.

          The Pendulum meme reference is a double entendre colloquial stochastic Mission Local banter style often encountered around these parts.

          Nice to see you here on this holiest of Political Junkie days when you need peers at your elbow.

          go Niners !!

          h.

          0
          -4
          votes. Sign in to vote
  11. Hey Joe,
    Here is a reality check for you to go w/your glass of
    ( liberal ) white whine.
    San Francisco has not had a Mayor who spoke up for private sector workers since Mayor Christopher and Mayor Shelly.
    Since Mayor Shelly,
    every single SF Mayor has been in bed w/SF city workers, i.e., public sector workers who already get way more in wages,
    paid benefits,
    and city-paid retirement plans than private sector workers will ever receive.
    Also,
    In addition to that,
    between extremely unbalanced labor agreements,
    and public sector labor laws,
    public employees are essentially
    fire-proof from the day they are hired to the day that they retire.
    That’s SF Socialism,
    for public employees only,
    And that’s Very SF!
    You miss Janis,
    She would still be here if she could have lived her life w/a modicum of
    self-control,
    and self-discipline.
    You may think that the 1960’s made
    SF great.
    That’s incorrect.
    The 1960’s destroyed a great city.
    Cry, the beloved city.
    Go Niners!!
    Bob

    +2
    -4
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. Bob — 

      I feel that you should be aware that some ding-dong is signing your name to stupid comments.

      Yours,

      JE

      +4
      -2
      votes. Sign in to vote
      1. Joe,
        You’ve got a very good sense of humor.
        And I do appreciate your work.
        As they would have said in the’ ‘60’s,
        Don’t Worry,
        Be Happy!

        +2
        0
        votes. Sign in to vote
  12. Lurie and his cabal are repugnant, and voters who blindly approve of his self-serving policies and advertising are short-sighted. Unchecked, never-ending unilateral power in the hands of a nefarious mayor is dangerous.

    It is disappointing that there is not enough housing available and at decent rates in SF these days. the smart, empathetic and low to middle income voters who oppose Lurie have been priced out of this city or cannot afford to move here.

    +2
    -4
    votes. Sign in to vote
  13. Laurie’s Gilded Age

    or

    Chesa’s Crime Wave

    Jeez, what a tough decision. Hard to understand why voters prefer the former.

    +1
    -6
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. this framing is disingenuous. there is a rational middle ground in between the two options: let billionaires commit white collar crime unchecked or let violence run amok in the city.

      +3
      0
      votes. Sign in to vote
      1. @This [lack of] Common Sense is disappointing – There was no Chesa’s Crime Wave, violence did not run amok in the city. Violent crime was at historic lows while Chesa was in office, though alarmist media fearmongering about it soared.

        0
        -2
        votes. Sign in to vote
  14. San Franciscans are less politically informed and less politically active than West Virginians. It’s funny how people here look down their nose at me when I tell them where I’m from. But SF and WV the same in a few ways: vocal, stupid people vote against your own interests, you’re addicted to trickle-down economics, and you value actual labor LESS than the rednecks do. Meta at least needs WV’s natural resources for data centers, Meta doesn’t want Bay Area workers because humans, especially here, are expensive.

    At least when people in WV are hurting, their communities rally together to help each other. The residents of this city do not care about each other, and that’s why everyone’s doubled down on this self-serving mayor. People will always condone behavior they wish they could get away with, so until the “PEOPLE” of San Francisco start to think critically and become actually measurably better/smarter/critically aware, this city will deservedly continue to flounder.

    We’re planning to leave in January so that we don’t have to listen to everyone bitch for the next two, four, six, eight, ten years about their do-nothing representative or why no new businesses are coming into D8. This city worships artifice, so get what you deserve. 80 BILLION dollars of losses from a company that’s more heavily guarded than our city hall? That’s acceptable? You’re beyond help.

    +6
    -14
    votes. Sign in to vote
      1. Billy does come across as permanently angry and agitated. In a city known for being chill and relaxed, I can see why she feels that she does not fit in here and needs to go back home to West Virginia. I feel genuinely sorry for anyone who feels like a fish out of water here. This place doesn’t suit everyone.

        More generally I think that Joe is right to attribute the ideological sea change in this city to demographic changes. For a good thirty years now young liberal and open-minded but politically moderate knowledge workers have been moving here. While old school left-wing progressives have been dying off or becoming the regressives, saying no to any and all change. This could be a healthy trend.

        +6
        -1
        votes. Sign in to vote
    1. I’m glad there’s a ratio here because it proves my point, and this article too. Popular opinions are what got you losers to this point in the first place.

      0
      -7
      votes. Sign in to vote
  15. Thanks for all your reporting. I won’t be engaging with your rag or bullied by the cunts in your comment section anymore. I truly hope your gilded city burns to the ground.

    +2
    -11
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. @Billy King – Yeesh. My Ohio River valley childhood taught me that resentment as a political force generally achieves nothing of value. Have fun being a dupe of the J.D. Vances of the world.

      +4
      -2
      votes. Sign in to vote
Leave a comment
Please keep your comments short and civil. Do not leave multiple comments under multiple names on one article. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *