A sidewalk beside a fenced industrial building with yellow caution tape, a no parking sign, trash bins, and some discarded items on the ground suggests a recent police presence in the area.
Caution tape lines the Bayshore Navigation Center on June 1, 2026. Photo by Marina Newman.

Two homeless shelter workers likely will be tried on charges of aiding a suspect who allegedly shot and wounded a police officer after a San Francisco judge on Friday said prosecutors had presented enough evidence to go to trial. 

But San Francisco Superior Court Judge Dawn Payne said she would give a formal ruling on Dec. 16, after lawyers submit additional arguments. 

“I do think the people have met their burden,” said Payne, near the conclusion of a contentious and long-delayed preliminary hearing. “But maybe [the defense] will change my mind.” 

Prosecutors and police say Oliver Barcenas and Erika Porter helped to hide robbery suspect Norris Reed III at the Bayshore Navigation Center on May 31 after he fled police following a shootout in which he critically wounded Officer Brittney Taylor. Reed took refuge at the shelter, sitting in a courtyard for nearly 90 minutes while officers frantically searched for him. 

Barcenas, a supervisor, is facing charges of allegedly helping to hide Reed when he failed to call police reporting Reed’s location at the shelter and gave him a jacket and hat upon his request. 

Porter, a security aide, police said, is accused of misleading officers when she told police she spotted him running away from the shelter. 

If convicted on two felony charges of acting as an accessory after the fact and obstructing or delaying a police officer, Barcenas and Porter could each face time in prison. Barcenas, who was on probation at the time on a prior gun charge, could face additional time for violating his probation. 

The case has raised questions with shelter officials protesting what they say is an over-aggressive response by the San Francisco’s District Attorney’s office to a case in which a police officer was critically wounded. 

The defendants and shelter say they were between a rock and a hard place. 

Reed, who was armed with two guns, threatened and warned them not to call the police, Barcenas’ lawyer and the former head of the shelter said to Mission Local. Barcenas acted at the direction of his superior, an assistant director at the shelter, his lawyer said in court. 

The district attorney’s case hinged on key surveillance and body camera footage.

Surveillance footage played in court Friday appeared to show Barcenas handing Reed a jacket and hat through an open window. Body camera footage of officers’ questioning of Porter also showed the shelter worker giving an incomplete story when asked where Reed was. 

In surveillance footage shared Friday, workers were startled by the sound of gunfire at approximately 10:45 p.m. on May 31, when the gunfight between Reed and San Francisco officers erupted. 

Minutes later, footage obtained from the shelter appeared to show Reed sprinting away from officers down Bayshore Boulevard. Seconds later, he doubled back at a walking pace, turning into the shelter. 

Footage showed Reed idling in the shelter’s courtyard for approximately a minute before following an unidentified shelter worker into the building through a front entrance. 

Porter, who was at the front desk, screamed at Reed to leave, video showed. Barcenas and others escorted Reed back out into the courtyard, shutting the front door behind them. 

Porter, who was wrapping up her shift when the incident occurred, packed up her things and appeared to exit through the back entrance and left for her car parked outside, according to footage. A police officer asked if she had seen Reed. 

“I was parked here the whole time,” said Porter to the officer. 

“I saw him running that way,” she said, pointing down the street. 

Porter did not say that Reed had been in the shelter. 

Porter and Barcenas were charged and arrested in August, two months after Reed was eventually located and arrested after midnight on June 1. 

Porter was shaking uncontrollably as she told officers she “didn’t want to get anybody in trouble,” and that she feared for her life, body camera footage showed. Rose Mishaan, Porter’s attorney, acknowledged her client did not give  officers the full story, but said she did not know that Reed had not left the shelter and was hiding in the shelter’s courtyard. 

Mishaan said that Porter’s actions could be considered, at worst, a misdemeanor. 

“She was just terrified,” said Mishaan, outside of the courtroom. “She really didn’t understand what was going on.” 

Mishaan said the district attorney’s office is treating the case more aggressively because it involved an officer’s potential loss of life. “They’re just kind of looking for people to blame,” she said.

The judge will review final briefings on Dec. 10, and issue a ruling on Dec. 16. 

If the case goes to trial, the district attorney’s office will have to prove “beyond a reasonable doubt” that Porter and Barcenas knowingly concealed Reed from police, helping him to evade capture. The burden of proof is higher than that needed at a preliminary hearing. 

“It’s flimsy,” said Gabriel Navarrette of the evidence against his client, Barcenas. “There are just some facts that they are not going to be able to get because they just don’t exist,” said Navarrete. 

Still, he said, the judge may decide that the ultimate decision-maker will be a jury. 

Marina Newman is a staff reporter at Mission Local covering Bayview-Hunters Point. Marina began at Mission Local as an intern in 2025 and previously reported on national and international news for the Pacifica Evening News.

Marina was born and raised in San Jose and graduated from UC Berkeley where she studied American Studies and Digital Journalism. You can reach her securely on Signal @marinanewman.12.

Leave a comment

Please keep your comments short and civil. Do not leave multiple comments under multiple names on one article. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *