The San Francisco Unified School District is finally overhauling its loathed lottery system for elementary-school enrollment. But even in the early stages of its replacement, parents worry it’ll have a worse outcome than the status quo.
Last week, the school board voted to overhaul the lottery in favor of a new plan to guarantee every child a spot in their neighborhood elementary school, with the option to apply for limited spots in citywide programs like special education, K-8 schools and language immersion.
Details of the new enrollment policy will be developed over the coming months and voted on in April.
But a range of San Francisco groups with very different views on education are speaking out in opposition to the plan.
Some are calling it segregation, charging that neighborhood schools will enable parents who live in wealthier enclaves to circle the wagons and keep children from poorer areas out. Racial justice organizations like Coleman Advocates and NAACP, among others, have come out against the plan.
“This school board did not stop to look and listen to the Black and brown community,” said former NAACP president Rev. Amos Brown. “They rushed the decision through, and it’s done.”
The current lottery system, like many previous SFUSD enrollment plans, was meant to overcome residential segregation. But, over time, the district found that parents learned to “game” the system, resulting in even more segregated schools.
The district says it now intends to distribute funding and resources in a fair way that will make all neighborhood schools into “great” schools, across the board. There is currently no plan for how this will happen, but Hong Mei Pang, the district’s head of staff, said a plan will be developed alongside the final enrollment policy, which is slated to go into effect for the 2028-29 school year.
The San Francisco Parents Coalition, which has advocated for more parent choice in schools, is not happy.
“I’m thrilled that we have district leadership that believes that our schools can be great,” said Rebecca Kee, the group’s executive director. “But where they lose parents is thinking they can do it quickly without costing years for our most underserved kids.”
Few parents seem to believe that a fair distribution of resources will actually happen.
Philippe Marchand, a parent of three SFUSD students, says the board’s promise to invest in all schools equitably is about as empty as the slogan that Froot Loops is part of a balanced breakfast.
“The value of the claim is entirely contained in an accompanying action that might or might not be taken,” said Marchand, a stay-at-home public-school dad who earned his Ph.D from the University of California, Berkeley, in environmental science, and spent years working as a statistician, data scientist and teacher.
District staff have also said that fully implementing a plan to equitably resource schools, once it exists, would take five to 10 years, with the likelihood that it’ll take closer to 10.
“That’s ludicrous,” said Roberto Guzman Rivera, who has three kids at Guadalupe Elementary School in the Excelsior, where he serves as PTA president. “If they’re doing it, we need it now. We need to see the changes.”
The pushback was anticipated. The new system — which was not only the board’s choice, but the option recommended by SFUSD Superintendent Maria Su — did not poll well with parents.
Su admitted that some district staff also had doubts. “You can’t school-assignment your way into having a great school,” deputy superintendent John Davis said.
But Su argued that the neighborhood school system will force the district to distribute resources fairly between schools.
“This district and I will fully own that, and have historically made a lot of promises to our families and continually broken them,” Su said. “But hopefully you’re seeing a shift in the tides.”
SFUSD has been under pressure to provide fair education for lower-income and minority students since the 1960s, though the definition of “fair” has always been contentious. The district’s proposed budget cuts in January of this year, for example, disproportionately affected schools with low-income students.
While many agree that students with limited English skills or learning disabilities deserve more resources, there’s no consensus about how much money should be spent on historically understaffed and underfunded schools.
Vanessa Marrero, the president for the San Francisco chapter of Parents for Public Schools, which organizes parents to advocate for public education, said that the entire city is segregated — economically, racially and socially — in ways the school district now needs to take into account.
Her group called on the district to pause development of the new enrollment policy for more community input.
“We’re open to consultation with the school district, but what we are not going to accept is segregation,” Marrero said. “We’re not going to accept inequitable outcomes.”
SFUSD’s Pang said that the district is committed to working with families and educators, and that the next phase of this process will include looking at citywide transitional kindergarten, language-immersion applications and special education.
And, she said, the district will grapple with how to provide equitable resources — and even how to define what that means.
“We recognize the concerns around how we will provide a schooling experience that meets the needs families really are asking for, particularly in neighborhoods that are historically underrepresented,” she said.
But parents like Guzman Rivera, meanwhile, are circulating a petition asking that SFUSD come up with and begin implementing an equity plan now, before changing the process for school enrollment.
Among their demands: fully staff special education, provide a fair appeals process for parents dissatisfied with their assigned school, and expand Spanish, Mandarin and Cantonese programs into more neighborhoods.
And, petitioners say, do not adopt any new implementation plans without their input.
“When they make decisions,” said Jenny Garcia, whose daughter attends Guadalupe Elementary School, “they don’t think about the kids and how it’s going to affect them.”
Correction: Due to an editing error, a previous version of this article noted that Chinese for Affirmative Action is against the enrollment plan. The group has not taken a stance.


I am one of the parents who did not get either of the choices in the lottery process. We applied to 7 schools, across the whole city and in our neighborhood. None were unreasonable. We didn’t get either of them.
The wait-list process is ridiculous and likewise didn’t get any placement for us. The closest we got was the school 100 feet from us, where we were 30 in line by school beginning.
Our initial placement was at a far away school with 2/10 rating. We looked at the reviews and did extensive research on it. The problems called out by parents were all about bullying that the teachers are legally not allowed to do anything about.
I agree this is a resourcing issue. Those schools need basically double the funding. One track to run a normal school and one track to address all the behavioral and other gaps. How is this going to happen?
I’ll believe that the SFUSD can change and address these issues when they publish clear financial proposals, not equity propaganda. Show us the positions needed, and where is the gap..show us the salary ranges. Show per-school deficit. Show the overall budget.
The goal should always be neighborhood schools, so hopefully this is a step in the right direction. The tricky part is raising up the poor performing schools so that everyone gets a good education.
I think this system will be less “game-able” than the current one, which in the end wound up benefitting white, affluent parents more. Whether it’s more equitable will depend very heavily on how each schools’ attendance-area boundaries are drawn, but the reality is that with bussing not an option, there are going to be some schools that are heavily segregated, and others which perform poorly, no matter what system we endorse. This one at least will help parents plan for things like transportation.
School board members were recalled in 2022 for trying to de-segregate Lowell. Now, the new replacements will further segregate the rest of SFUSD.
Ralph, the 2022 recall was about a lot more than that, most notably about the fixation with renaming schools over re-opening them after Covid.
What is sad is how race still dominates SFUSD discussions. Getting rid of the three worst culprits evidently has not changed that. Until we adopt a color-blind allocation policy the squabbles will continue.
“Color-blind” policies re-entrench racial segregation and inequality.
Your post confirms exactly the point I was making i.e. this obsession with race within SFUSD. We need to treat children as individuals rather than as convenient stereotypes.
“The district says it now intends to distribute funding and resources in a fair way that will make all neighborhood schools into ‘great’ schools, across the board.”
And then:
“There is currently no plan for how this will happen.”
That’s everything you need to know. Good reporting, ML.
SFUSD loses about 500 students every year. I worry that this change will result this enrollment drop rate to double or triple. Families will get frustrated when they see school seats they desperately want for their kids are intentionally kept empty.
The question is if the district and this board are willing to reverse course if/when the data shows an acceleration of parents’ flight from SFUSD.
The fact is right now the lottery system is fine. I had not met one parent who did not get into one of their top 3 schools. People have the freedom to choose a school anywhere in the city, no matter what neighborhood they live in. That is fairness. What they are now talking about is forcing poor kids to attend bad schools. This is just awful.