Shantel McClendon outside of her Valencia Gardens apartment. Photo by Eric Murphy.

The fight for a mother of five to remain in her Valencia Gardens home was revived Wednesday as The John Stewart Company, the property’s manager, signaled its willingness to challenge a judge’s decision last month that granted the family a reprieve from eviction. 

The “notice of appeal” filed Wednesday by the property management company will give it room to pursue further legal action against Shantel McClendon, who has been living at the public housing complex on Valencia and 15th streets for 15 years.  

The John Stewart Company had been attempting to evict McClendon and her five children from their Valencia Gardens home since April. The management company’s grounds for eviction has most recently stemmed from concerns around the father of three of McClendon’s children staying at the apartment, in violation of her lease. 

Yet, by the time the eviction proceedings began in July, that man, Rasheed Loveless, was no longer living in the apartment, as he had begun a two-year sentence in state prison. A judge on Sep. 23 entered a final decision, stating that The John Stewart Company had acted dishonestly on four separate occasions in its attempts to evict McClendon.

Less than a month later, The John Stewart Company is not giving up. 

We are trying very hard to work things out with Ms. McClendon and her family in a way that does not result in her having to leave the property,” Jack Gardner, the president of the John Stewart Company, said on Thursday. “But the prior ruling left many substantive issues unresolved that we cannot turn a blind eye to.”  

Gardner did not specify what those “substantive issues” were, saying only that he wants McClendon to “come into compliance with her lease.” The notice filed Wednesday does not outline legal arguments. 

Election 2019: Register now to hear Joe Eskenazi grill the DA candidates and Mission Local and SF Public Press reporters explain the ballot measures. 44 Page St. October 28, 2019, 7-8:45 p.m.

“The notice of appeal we’ve filed is to preserve our options while trying to find an amicable resolution — and not require her family to leave the property,” he added, insisting it’s not necessarily a harbinger of further litigation. 

However, he said, “It is my sincere hope that we can find an alternative to eviction — but we will pursue our right to a jury trial if that only becomes absolutely necessary.” 

It may not be necessary. McClendon, who learned of the filing from Mission Local, said she’s actively trying to move out of Valencia Gardens. “I don’t feel safe there,” she said. “I feel like they’re harassing me now.” 

“I got the decision from the judge and you guys are still trying,” she said, directing her comments to the management company. “You guys are crazy to me.” 

Her attorney, Ryan Murphy, a lawyer with the Eviction Defense Collaborative, echoed McClendon, saying that the single mother has already had her day in court and won. “But still, The John Stewart Company will not give Ms. McClendon housing stability and peace of mind,” he wrote in an email. “Instead of just apologizing and moving on, their decision to appeal means that The John Stewart Company wants to keep Ms. McClendon and her children under the threat of eviction for at least the next several months pending a decision on appeal.” 

Added McLendon: “I already have five kids to take care of. I’ve been fighting for three years to get this decision — and I still didn’t win anything.” 

Follow Us

Julian grew up in the East Bay and moved to San Francisco in 2014. Before joining Mission Local, he wrote for the East Bay Express, the SF Bay Guardian, and the San Francisco Business Times.

Join the Conversation


  1. While I feel for the five children and mother, this is a PRIME example of how housing assistance is used as a crutch and not a hand up! In 15 years had this beautiful young lady used this time to nurture herself and her children in prayer and taken on a mindset of gratitude, she could have possibly created a better life for herself and her children and moved out of this place. This would have given the next person who may desperately need this hand up a chance to an apartment! Instead, as many young ladies do, she allowed this man to jeopardize the welfare of her and her children! How does he repay her? Gets himself locked up leaving her stuck with all the responsibilities. Young ladies have to learn to have some self worth and tenacity! Don’t be so quick to sacrifice yourself for a man who has not even taken your hand in marriage yet and is not able to take care of himself yet, less long you and 5 kids! Please know that I am not judging. I just want to see young ladies helped and doing better! These programs need to be revamped so that they push people to gain the skills to become self sufficient, not get on them for life and get comfortable in them!!!! Remember, someone else need this help too!!!!

    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. Are you delusional? San Francisco is one of the most expensive cities on the planet. A family of 6 needs a 2BR at least. That’d be $6,000 per month. How exactly were you thinking she’d come up with that kind of money?

      votes. Sign in to vote
  2. Another black family inexorably being pushed towards the Sunnydale concentration camp.

    Can’t have them troublesome Negros living smack dab in the middle of the high rent district.

    Since the end of WW2 and to this very day SF’s racial policies are more akin to the stereotype of Mississippi or Alabama. We just do a better job of interning them in their “special zones of occupation”. Outta sight. Outta mind.

    “black San Franciscans do not matter in San Francisco” – Phelicia Jones as quoted very recently by Mission Local.
    Never truer words spoken with decades of oppression as evidence.

    votes. Sign in to vote
Leave a comment
Please keep your comments short and civil. Do not leave multiple comments under multiple names on one article. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and very easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *