Legislation that would have made it easier to create historic landmarks in San Francisco has been put off indefinitely after the Board of Supervisor’s Land Use Committee voted to continue the bill Monday.
The decision followed pushback from the city’s YIMBYs, who argued that landmarking buildings could limit housing production; historic sites are protected from redevelopment.
But the conflict was also seen as a proxy battle between two supervisors: Rafael Mandelman, who had championed the law, and Bilal Mahmood, whose plan to amend the law ultimately killed it.
Mandelman and Mahmood are expected to fight for a seat on the California State Assembly in 2028, part of a game of political musical chairs: Matt Haney, who currently holds the seat, will next year run for the State Senate seat held by Scott Wiener, who is off to Congress.
Mandelman has opened a campaign committee for that contest; Mahmood has denied that he’s running but many political observers expect that he will.
Mandelman’s proposal would have reduced the number of hearings needed to create a historic landmark, speeding up what is often a multi-year process.
It was also part of a larger push to expand the number of city landmarks. Mandelman and Mayor Daniel Lurie announced the legislation in May alongside plans to do a citywide survey to identify any buildings that should be landmarked. That effort will continue even though the legislation has been shelved.
All in all, Mandelman and Lurie hope to add around 2,500 of new landmarks, more than doubling San Francisco’s current count.
Mandelman said that while he broadly supports the city’s efforts to build more housing — he voted for last year’s upzoning, for example — he thinks that building should go hand in hand with preserving.
“If we do not get ahead of the game with historic preservation, we could see the ministerial demolition of important historic resources without any real process to try to save them,” he said.
Nevertheless, YIMBY dissatisfaction found a champion in Mahmood. He planned to introduce an amendment to the legislation at Monday’s hearing that would have required the city to evaluate how much housing could have been built on a landmarked site.
The city, under Mahmood’s amendment, would then be forced to upzone a site elsewhere in the city to offset that potential loss of housing.
“We’re in an affordability crisis right now,” Mahmood said. “San Franciscans want us to be doing everything in our power to make it easier to build housing.”
Mahmood said not amending Mandelman’s proposal would have also opened up the city to lawsuits, pointing to state requirements for cities to balance any constraints with new opportunities to build.
Mandelman was displeased with Mahmood’s amendment and said it would “gut the legislation.” He kicked Mahmood off the Land Use Committee in August, pointing explicitly to the planned amendments.
“His approach to my historic preservation legislation has been quite aggressive,” Mandelman said at the time.
With Mahmood off the Land Use Committee, he could not introduce amendments directly, but Supervisor Myrna Melgar agreed to do so for him. Mandelman then pulled the plug.
YIMBYs celebrated the outcome.
“We are extremely grateful to Supervisor Mahmood for his work to ensure that historic preservation doesn’t prevent the building of much needed housing in San Francisco,” said Brandon Powell, an organizing director at YIMBY Action.
“We wish that Supervisor Mandelman had considered the production of housing to be as important as the protection of some random number of buildings in the city, but apparently he did not.”
Mandelman pushed back.
“I understand that there are concerns about any directionality toward more preservation in the city,” Mandelman said. “I think it’s wrong, and I think it’s a mistake.”


Mahmood is 100% correct on this one.
The city should not be landmarking a single additional building.
No one should be required to subsidize someone else’s nostalgia.
On this issue alone I cannot support Mandelman for the Assembly.
I’ll definitely be voting for Mahmood.
Yes and moreover it is ridiculous for anyone to claim that there are 5,000 houses in the city that are “landmarks”. By definition there cannot be many landmarks. Maybe if we had Tudor or Georgian houses like in Europe then there would be a case for wholesale mass landmarking. But some crappy 1950s shack in the Sunset is not historically interesting by any standard,
A not-uncommon phenomenon in poor eastern/southern European cities is for some routine underground infrastructure project to accidentally dig up a 2,000-year-old architectural relic, the relic is painstakingly extracted and/or incorporated into the ultimate design (hooray, 6am commuters get to trudge past an ancient Roman mosaic floor on their way through the Metro station), the entire project quadruples in cost, and maybe some of the resulting gigantic hole in the municipal budget ends up partially offset by a patchwork of EU-level archaeological grants.
Meanwhile, San Franciscans are out here arguing over whether the randomly copy-pasted architectural accents on cookie-cutter 1949 Doelger Home #4722 are historically significant compared to the ones on 1949 Doelger Home #4723.
Only the wealthy should be able to afford nostalgia!
Given the negative impact it has on housing costs, it’s one of the reasons — along with a slew of anti-housing creation policies over the course of 5+ decades — that presently only the wealthy can afford to own home in SF.
When you continually restrict a city’s ability to adapt and change and make it very expensive to do so, then that city becomes a museum that only the wealthy can enjoy.
The median home price in SF has now reached a stratospheric $1,520,000.
Which means with a 20% downpayment ($304,000) one must have a consistent annual income of at least $382,000 over the course of 30 years in order to crack a monthly payment nut of $9,540.
This, of course, is insane and Mandelman wants to make it worse.
No thanks.
The fact that Mandelman is not willing to pass the legislation without the amendments tells us preventing new housing is more important to him than preservation. The amendments Mahmood tried to introduce are required by state law (no net loss and AB2580). Without them the city would have been sued, would have lost, and would have still been required to add them. In the process the city could lose valuable affordable housing and transit grants, lose control over zoning, and would have had to pay significant legal costs defending the legislation.
The problem is that “historical preservation” has been forever used not so much to preserve real history but as an obstacle to building more housing.
I fail to see how a one for one up zoning for each historic landmark downzoning would “gut the legislation” in Mandelman’s words. Seems like a reasonable compromise.
Id really appreciate more information about the Excelsior District neighborhood, that was my old neighborhood, my father sold his house in 2019 on the 600 block of London Street, so any news on the Excelsior neighborhood would great news
Robert Kriletich,
Here’s some info on what 5+ decades of NIMBY-driven anti-housing creation policies has done to your father’s once naturally affordable neighborhood:
The typical home on the 600 block of London Street in San Francisco’s Excelsior neighborhood now sells for roughly $1.05 million to $1.25 million.
Sorry to tell you this is not “great news”, but at least it’s the truth, as sad as it is.
Another option would be to require owner consent for landmarking.
Every time there’s a housing article here, the comments become swamped with YIMBY cockroaches.
It’s so wild and incoherent to see Lurie and Mandelman buck the free market in favor of historic preservation (what obstructionist NIMBYs!!) and to see Bilal favor letting developers tear it all down if there’s money to be made (what a capitalist!).
I think this incoherence stems from the fact that discourse on housing has itself become incoherent. We’ve achieved almost TOTAL deregulation (thanks to these very policy makers), and run straight into the reality that the free market will NEVER build enough housing that prices will drop substantially– we know this because the City Economist released a report in 2025 on Lurie’s Family Zoning Plan that said BEST-CASE market conditions would result in the developers building 14,600 units being in the next 20 years, and that BEST-CASE scenario would only reduce rents by $75-125 a month. This is hardly a solution given that rents are up like 100% in the last five years. https://missionlocal.org/2025/10/sf-upzoning-housing-city-controller/
So now we’re in this weird place were the YIMBYs have achieved everything they want, almost TOTAL deregulation, and now we’re waiting for the market to magically make housing affordable…. right? Unless…. Daniel Lurie and Rafael Mandelman are the anti capitalist obstructionist NIMBY bogeymen now, blcoking us from free market utopia? Do I have that right?
Its like the free-market zealots are just kind of circling, not really sure what to do next, and so we’re starting to see these weird fissures.
Q: Who grew the food that “Albert” eats?
A: A farmer.
Q: Who created the home that “Albert” lives in?
A: A developer.
GrowUSA is Yimby cancer and gentrification for that purpose. Wiener is bought.
Personally, I wouldn’t be all that annoyed by Wiener if he actually found the money to build housing for everyday people. Where was he and the rest of the YIMBYs to salvage the full scale of the SFMTA Potrero yard development? Where is he to get all these permitted and ready-to-roll projects (e.g. Treasure Island, Stonestown, Divis carwash, Lucky 13) going? Instead, what we get is desirable neighborhoods getting cracked open using his rules to build ultra-luxury housing a la Marina Safeway.
It really doesn’t matter that much what housing gets built or where. If there are enough luxury apartments available for all the high earners, they will live in them. If not, they’ll bid up crappy apartments in the Mission to $10k/month.
Trickle down hosing, is this you, George W.?
You well know that’s a joke of a response.
This is the BS YIMBY “argument” that basically kicks the can on affordable housing to appease Billionaire developers and gentrifier schmucks. Congratulations, you’ve completely fallen for a lie that benefits the wealthiest and most government-controlling .01% while ignoring the actual issue.
No, Millionaire techbros are not swooping up the $1,200 in-laws. It’s just a dumb thing to believe.
“M”,
What’s your explanation for why the median selling price for the typical piece-of-crap house in the Sunset District is now ≈ $2 Million?
Note: Actual selling prices: Inner Sunset ≈ $2.28M; Central Sunset ≈ $2.00 Million; Outer Sunset ≈ $1.78 Million.)
Homes area typically going into contract within 12 to 14 days and regularly closing at 33% to 44% over list price
Well yes, is it somehow surprising that if you bring a steam tank to dangerously high pressure and then crack the safety valve a teensy weensy bit open, the first bits of steam to escape are going to be dangerously high pressure blasts?
My understanding is that the single biggest roadblock to the SFMTA development has been the endless rounds of haggling over “affordable housing” requirements. From a YIMBY perspective, these requirements and the resultant horse trading are a sham that places multifamily housing development outside the purview of impartial rule of law in favor of a bespoke “Art of the Deal” neo-feudalism, and ultimately only helps to keep the overall cost of housing higher.