San Francisco supervisors voted to extend a moratorium on data centers on Tuesday, halting new construction for at least another 10 months and 15 days, after the city said it needed more time to understand the environmental impact of these facilities.
In October District 10 Supervisor Shamann Walton had introduced legislation that passed unanimously to halt the production of new data centers for 45 days. The legislation applies to facilities ranging from small to large-scale properties that house digital information or computer systems.
Again, an extension of the moratorium did not face any pushback from city supervisors and was passed unanimously — except for Supervisor Connie Chan, who was absent from Tuesday’s meeting.
The analysis recommended policy changes the planning department said San Francisco officials should consider before approving new data centers, including banning the permitting of standalone data centers in certain locations, such as residential or commercial areas.
They also recommended modernizing the city’s definition of data centers, which relies on language from 2001, to better match the state’s definition, and requiring facilities to assess its impact on the surrounding community.
Two potential data centers, one located in Dogpatch and another in San Francisco’s now-closed Centre Mall, have been proposed or eyed by developers in the past year. NOVVA, an existing data center located at 400 Paul Ave. in Bayview, is scheduled to expand from nine to 36 megawatts by 2028. Those plans are now on hold.
A report published by the San Francisco Planning Department read that data centers present “opportunities” for supporting the city’s digital infrastructure — but also “challenges.”
Data centers, especially larger facilities, read the report, “can also place significant demands on electricity systems, generate air quality and noise impacts from backup power equipment, and raise questions about the use of limited land and infrastructure.”
The assessment analyzed the city’s three standalone facilities, but added it does not keep a “complete inventory” of other, smaller data centers used inside offices. The website Data Center Map, located 15 potential data centers in San Francisco, including smaller facilities incorporated in other buildings, many of which are located downtown.
Two standalone, larger data centers, at 200 Paul Ave. and 320-400 Paul Ave., are located in Bayview’s industrial hub. The southeastern neighborhood has for decades been subject to disproportionate levels of air pollution compared to the rest of San Francisco due to industrial operations, truck traffic, and in years past, a PG&E power-plant, which closed in 2006.
Walton, who represents the neighborhood, said that the city needs to “know what these impacts are,” and how they affect the neighborhood’s residents. “Until that happens,” he said, “It needs to stop.”

