A deputy escorts a man in orange jail clothing through a courtroom.
Troy McAlister exits court after a hearing related to his plea deal, on Nov. 17, 2026. Photo by Frankie Solinsky Duryea

Troy McAlister, the man who in 2020 crashed a stolen car while high and killed two people, eventually playing a major role in the recall of then-District Attorney Chesa Boudin, agreed Wednesday to a plea deal that will effectively end the case against him. 

The plea deal is for  21 years and four months in prison but he will receive credit for time already served. McAlister’s sentencing is scheduled to happen on December 11th. His time served will be calculated at that point, but it is estimated that he will get 12 years off his sentence.

Judge Eric Fleming accepted the deal — which defense attorneys and prosecutors had negotiated in October — at the Hall of Justice this afternoon. The deal convicts McAlister of two counts of “Gross Vehicular Manslaughter While Intoxicated,” landing him 10 years in prison, and one count related to a stolen vehicle, adding another 8 months. But because of a prior conviction, that 10 year and 8 month sentence is doubled. 

On Dec. 31, 2020, McAlister drove a stolen car through a red light at the intersection of Second and Mission streets. He smashed into another car and careened into two pedestrians, 27-year-old Hanako Abe and 60-year-old Elizabeth Platt. 

Both Abe and Platt were killed. 

McAlister, who grew up in Bayview, was on parole at the time. At 45, he had been in and out of prison for drug and theft offenses since the age of 19. He was arrested in 2015 for robbing a market with an airsoft gun — and because of his prior record, he was eligible for California’s “three-strike rule,” which imposes a mandatory prison sentence of 25 years to life for anyone convicted of a third felony after two prior such convictions. 

When DA Boudin took office in early 2020, McAlister was still in jail awaiting sentencing for the 2015 robbery.

Boudin had run for DA on a progressive agenda and opposed that “three-strike rule.” He had instructed his prosecutors, in the vast majority of cases, to charge defendants based only on the accused crime before them, not for defendants’ prior record. As a result, McAlister’s sentence for his 2015 robbery fell from a maximum of life to just five years — time he had already served. McAlister was released on parole in April 2020. 

He was arrested four more times for drug or property crimes over the next year but never charged and instead referred to parole. The state parole office, however, never revoked McAlister’s parole, leaving him free to commit a series of purported crimes that culminated in the Dec. 31 killings of Abe and Platt. 

On Dec. 29, he reportedly stole the car of a woman who he met on a dating app. Two days later, he was driving that car into the intersection of Mission and Second streets, while allegedly high on methamphetamine, when he struck the two innocent pedestrians. 

“We all lie awake at night wondering what we could have done differently,” Boudin later said of the case. 

A number of miscommunications and failures appeared to have contributed to the tragedy that took place Dec. 31, 2020. But the person singled out in the aftermath was Boudin.

Mission Local subsequently reported that Brooke Jenkins, then a little-known prosecutor in Boudin’s office, had forwarded McAlister’s confidential case files to a colleague’s personal email address on Oct. 9, 2021 despite neither of them being involved in the McAlister case. The California penal code states that the furnishing of such a record to a person who is not authorized to receive it is a misdemeanor. 

Jenkins and that colleague, Don du Bain, had already turned in their resignations from the district attorney’s office. They would both leave within a week and, shortly thereafter, work on the recall campaign against Boudin. Details from the leaked files, somehow, found their way into pro-recall campaign activities and materials, and the McAlister case became a rallying cry against Boudin. 

Hiroko Abe, Hanako Abe’s mother, was prominently featured in one campaign advertisement. 

The California State Bar last year announced that Jenkins’ accessing and disseminating those confidential case materials was unethical, and ordered Jenkins, San Francisco’s sitting DA, into a diversion program. But this came years after Boudin was recalled in 2022, with Jenkins being appointed his successor and, ultimately, winning election and reelection. 

McAlister’s case has been in the hands of Jenkins’ prosecutors since then. Assistant district attorney Kourtney Bell helped negotiate Wednesday’s plea deal.

Ultimately, Judge Fleming called the plea “fair” and “reasonable” given all the factors of the case. The families of the victims, however, differed in their feelings on the arrangement. 

Alison Platt, sister of Elizabeth Platt, one of the women killed by McAlister in 2020, thanked the attorneys for finding a conclusion and not bringing her family into court for a long jury trial.

“After all these years we believe it’d be helpful to reach some closure at this time,” she said.

Hiroko Abe, mother of the other victim, Hanako Abe, said – speaking to the court through a Japanese-language interpreter – that she wished the case might have gone to trial. In an earlier hearing, Abe said that she was disappointed with the communication that she’d had with the district attorney’s office about the case. 

“It isn’t that I’m seeking a long sentence against McAlister,” Abe told the court. “What I am seeking now is to make public and make clear what happened up to now, so that the citizens would understand well what the term of his sentence is going to be, so that the people of San Francisco can live in safety.”

District attorney Brooke Jenkins told Mission Local that she wished the case had included more of McAlister’s priors, possibly putting him in prison for life. But, she said, Boudin’s office had filed the initial charges, and she was concerned that if her office upped the charges, her prosecutors might be recused from the case by judges who worried it had been politicized. 

Instead, she said, her office decided to take a plea after considering the risk that a trial might ultimately result in a lighter sentence.  

“This is probably one of the toughest decisions we have ever had to make,” Jenkins said. “This isn’t a day where we feel any relief. This is a tough day.”

Frankie Solinsky Duryea is a staff reporter covering criminal justice for Mission Local. He was born and raised in Burlingame, and he first worked with Mission Local as an intern in 2025, where he covered immigration and ICE.

Frankie Solinsky Duryea's work has appeared elsewhere in the SF Chronicle and in SFGATE. He speaks Spanish fluently, and Arabic and French conversationally. You can contact him securely on signal @frankiesd.28

Join the Conversation

4 Comments

  1. “ ‘ We all lie awake at night wondering what we could have done differently,’ Boudin later said of the case. ”

    What we could have done differently was to not let you become DA in the first place. Fortunately, we corrected that error and you will never hold political office again.

    Case closed.

    +2
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. Karl and I agree for once: boudin is majorly full of shit. And I for one sleep soundly at night since I never attempted to take powers that neither I nor any reasonable person wishes to take. Aspiration to political office is a personality defect, full stop. Prosecutor doubly so.

      Where we don’t agree is that he will not hold office again: he’s way too thirsty to ever give up and he’s selling an epic tale of heroism that more chumps will buy eventually.

      0
      0
      votes. Sign in to vote
  2. Given Troy McAllister’s track record, he looks to be completely unsafe behind a wheel. What’s going to make him any more trustworthy when he gets out? I think serious limitations need to be placed on him if and when he gets out.

    +1
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
  3. The way this tragic case was weaponized was cynical in the extreme. Both Mission and 2nd Street were and are on the high-injury network, known to the city to be especially dangerous. Their design — two extremely wide, ruler-straight streets with many lanes of traffic and no median — makes them inherently dangerous to cross. This was never pointed out in the press coverage at the time, and nothing has been done to fix it. A month before Boudin was recalled in May 2022, a driver killed two pedestrians a block away at Mission and 3rd Street, also on the high-injury network, but because that driver didn’t have a criminal record, the story was barely reported because it didn’t serve the narrative.

    If Mission, 2nd Street, and 3rd Street underwent a road diet with the addition of a median with a pedestrian refuge, bulbouts, and a reduction in lanes, both crashes would likely have happened at a slower speed and been non-fatal, and all four of these deaths could have been avoided. But in order to push an agenda of more funding for police and prisons instead of education and services, unethical actors like Brooke Jenkins selectively focused on just one factor in just one of these crashes. As a result, we’re stuck with the same deadly SoMa streets we had in 2020.

    0
    -3
    votes. Sign in to vote
Leave a comment
Please keep your comments short and civil. Do not leave multiple comments under multiple names on one article. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *