The San Francisco Unified School District in mid-September quietly notified parents at Junipero Serra Annex Early Education School that the site would be closed in July 2027 and their children reassigned to two other district campuses.
Questions immediately arose about why the district did not engage the community or the Board of Education regarding its decision to close the Bernal Heights school.
Whether parents can challenge the district’s decision may hinge on how the Junipero Serra Annex is classified — either as its own, independent school, or as an extension of nearby Junipero Serra Elementary School.
Given a week to respond, the school district was unable to provide basic information that would settle the school’s classification.
If Junipero Serra Annex is, in fact, an independent school site, the district’s unilateral move to shutter the school would expose it to potential legal action. Individual school sites come under the state’s guidelines on school closures, which call for initiating a months-long process that engages the community — as best-practices but, also, to insulate school districts from legal backlash.
But if Junipero Serra Annex is an extension of the elementary school, the closure is simpler. Experts say these types of closures can occur without following the state’s guidelines, because it does not constitute the elimination of an entire school program (if the flagship campus remains open).
But if this is the case, the district may be miscategorizing the school — and has possibly done so for years.
Despite repeated requests from Mission Local over the course of a week, the district could not provide information that would establish the Annex as a standalone site or an adjunct of the nearby school. District staffers provided conflicting answers to Mission Local’s questions.

When asked about the closure, Board of Education President Phil Kim suggested that the Annex is an extension of the elementary school, since the decision to close the school didn’t come to the board for approval. But he ultimately referred reporters to district staff.
SFUSD spokesperson Katrina Kincaid then told Mission Local on Nov. 10 that Junipero Serra Elementary and Junipero Serra Annex are “two different schools,” which should trigger a lengthy public process.
Moreover, she could not provide the unique identification code assigned to every standalone school needed for funding, accountability, data reporting and tracking purposes.
Parents, meanwhile, said that it seemed unambiguous that the Annex was a separate entity from Junipero Serra Elementary.
“They are in a different location, they have a different principal, they have different administrators and teachers,” said Patrick Wolff, whose daughter is enrolled in pre-K at Junipero Serra Annex. “There is literally no overlap between them other than the name.”
In addition to different sites, different administrators and a different principal, Serra and the Annex also require different enrollment processes. Mission Local called the front office of both campuses, and staff at each said the two schools are not affiliated with each other.
Answer is in the code
School districts register individual schools under a CDS code, an identification number assigned to every independent school location. CDS stands for “county, district, school.” These are visible to the general public on the California Department of Education’s website.
A number of SFUSD schools have multiple campuses. But, across the board they only have one CDS number. Claire Lilienthal Alternative School, Bessie Carmichael School and Rooftop School all have two campuses with different addresses, only one principal and one CDS code.
Because split schools share the same identification code, all enrollment and other student demographic data show up in a combined format on the state’s public-facing data-tracking site, DataQuest.
This, however, is not the case with Junipero Serra Annex and Junipero Serra Elementary.
When searching DataQuest, enrollment data is only available for Junipero Serra Elementary. The data for Junipero Serra Elementary does not include enrollment data for the Annex, which has about 80 students. But searching for the Annex on DataQuest yields no results, which it should if it is an independent school.
While the school district claims the school on its website, the school doesn’t appear to exist on the state’s school directory. In fact, according to the most recent public information on the CDE’s website, the Annex shut down in 1984. That was the last time the school had a registered and up-to-date CDS code.
Starting Nov. 10, Mission Local made repeated requests to the SFUSD for the CDS code for Junipero Serra Annex so its enrollment data could be viewed online. This is a task that should take seconds, and members of the general public should be able to view the codes on the state’s website. But Junipero Annex does not show up on that list.
An SFUSD spokesperson requested more time to provide the code. As of Monday, Nov. 16, the district has not provided the information.

Why close the Annex?
The district has stated that its move to close the Annex was not for “portfolio reasons” — meaning it was not due to factors such as declining enrollment or campus capacity. Rather, the district says the decision was made out of concern for student safety, citing $1.5 million in repairs needed at the school site, which is owned by the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission.
A district spokesperson said that repairs are needed for the walls and roof, but there is no immediate danger to students.
“The building is safe to be in,” Kincaid said last week. “Our capital focus is maintaining district-owned buildings to ensure the longevity of our properties.”
Nancy Crowley, a Public Utilities Commission spokesperson, said any renovations or upgrades to the building are the responsibility of the school district. The PUC began permitting the school district to use the property in 1992 on a year-to-year basis for the cost of only $1 per year.
Crowley said that the school district notified the PUC on Oct. 22 that it would vacate the property — over a month after SFUSD officials notified parents of the closure.
On Oct. 29, a district representative held the only community meeting to date to discuss the school closure with parents and administration at the Annex, 44 days after parents received the first notice of the school’s proposed closure. Parents said answers from district staff about the construction needs were vague.
“I won’t feel good about this unless the district can actually back up their position and their numbers with some more legitimate documentation,” said Wolff, the pre-K parent.
Potential legal repercussion
Brianna Garcia is the vice president of School Services of California, a 50-year fiscal management consultancy organization for California school districts. She said the situation at Junipero Serra Annex was unlike any closures she’d helped facilitate and some of the confusion stems from a CDS code the district has yet to provide.
She said bypassing the state’s guidelines and unilaterally closing the school leaves the school district open to legal challenges. David Campos, the former District 9 supervisor and general counsel for the SFUSD, agrees.
“Parents will have a legal avenue to challenge that,” he said.

