A person pushes a cart in front of numerous tents and makeshift shelters lining a sidewalk, with another individual bending over among the tents. A tree and a fence are in the background.
An encampment on Jerrold Ave. near Bayshore Blvd. on Aug. 6, 2024. Photo by Abigail Van Neely.

San Francisco officials are reevaluating its rapid rehousing program after a city report released on Tuesday found that 49% of those enrolled in the program became homeless again once the help ended. 

The program provides rental subsidies, beginning at an average of $1,600 per month, to qualifying homeless adults and emancipated minors through nonprofits. The goal is to reduce the subsidy over time as participants find work. Subsidies are based on income and typically last two years. 

The rapid rehousing program was launched by then-Mayor Gavin Newsom in 2006 with the goal of quickly getting the city’s homeless population off city streets and into temporary housing.  

But the controller’s office, the chief auditor for the city, had not evaluated the program until today. A report from the office released Tuesday found that participants often returned to homelessness after the city’s aid stopped.

The program will continue under existing contracts but the department now plans to unveil a newly designed rapid rehousing program by April 2029 using the report’s recommendations, one of which is to reevaluate how those with mental illness or substance abuse disorders are matched with housing. 

The shift is the first major outcome in Mayor Daniel Lurie’s multi-year overhaul of the city homelessness department’s contracting system. The effort, announced in August, aims to reissue contracts based on results to improve San Francisco’s response to its homelessness crisis. 

“The Controller’s assessment shows where the program is working and where we need to do better, particularly for households facing significant affordability barriers or greater vulnerabilities,” said Mike Levine, director of the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing, in a statement. 

“We will use these findings to strengthen the program with providers and participants, so more people can remain housed after assistance ends.”

San Francisco spent $43 million on contracts with 12 nonprofits that provided rapid rehousing support in 2024 and 2025, the report said. The homelessness department said rapid rehousing is still less expensive than alternative housing solutions, like permanent supportive housing, which provides long-term housing along with wraparound services like case management. 

But the report, which tracked the results of the program over three years for clients housed in 2022 and 2023, found that outcomes varied dramatically based on those served. 

Single adults and those with mental or medical vulnerabilities fared the worst. 

The controller’s office found that 57% of single adults who participated in the program in 2022 and 2023 returned to homelessness once the assistance stopped — three years after they moved into subsidized housing. 

For adults with more than four “vulnerabilities,” defined as a mental illness, substance abuse disorder, disability, or chronic medical condition, 62% became homeless after leaving the program. 

Young adults aged 18 to 24, and families with children, fared better. 

About 48% of families became homeless again and the rest transitioned into other subsidized housing programs three years after receiving a voucher. Some 44% of young adults returned to homelessness, but the rest eventually moved into market-rate housing in San Francisco or elsewhere in California. 

One major reason for the program’s shortcomings, wrote the controller’s office, may lie in how the program treats those with major vulnerabilities. 

The vast majority of single adults reported having at least one medical or mental vulnerability that left them at a disadvantage in securing a job and participating in the program. Just under half reported having at least four complicating health issues. 

In interviews the controller’s office conducted with San Francisco homelessness nonprofits, “all providers” reported that they received a large number of referrals for people in “severe” states of physical or mental distress. Such people likely need much more support. 

Instead, the office recommended grouping people by their income potential and directing people with a significant number of factors, such as a disability or mental illness to an alternative program with more support. 

The homelessness department should also “clarify” the program’s expectations for long-term stability with case managers, strengthen the city’s workforce training programs, and work to make sure households participating in the program have access to the city’s other subsidized housing programs after their voucher expires. 

San Francisco expanded its rapid rehousing program by committing $13 million over two years to vouchers for hundreds of families and adults after the city banned people from living in RVs in public streets in 2025. 

Edith Alcaraz, who moved into an apartment in Daly City using a rapid rehousing voucher, said that her new apartment, a two-bedroom she shares with her son, is “lovely.” But she doesn’t know how they will afford the $3,000 a month rent after the subsidies stop.

“The two years are going to go by fast,” said Alcaraz. “Hopefully I will find another job so I will continue staying here, because we love it.”

Marina Newman is a staff reporter at Mission Local covering Bayview-Hunters Point. Marina began at Mission Local as an intern in 2025 and previously reported on national and international news for the Pacifica Evening News.

Marina was born and raised in San Jose and graduated from UC Berkeley where she studied American Studies and Digital Journalism. You can reach her securely on Signal @marinanewman.12.

Leave a comment

Please keep your comments short and civil. Do not leave multiple comments under multiple names on one article. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *