One of Concord’s newest immigration judges is a former police officer with a history of allegations of excessive force.
Michael Rapiejko, who was accused of using excessive force as a police officer in Arizona in 2005 and New York in 2015, has been hearing cases since July at the Concord Immigration Court.
He is based in Florence, Arizona, at a detention center complex, and hears cases remotely.
Before becoming a judge, the 2018 graduate of Quinnipiac University School of Law worked as a police officer in Arizona and New York, as a tax attorney, and most recently as an attorney for Immigration and Customs Enforcement from July 2025 to his court appointment in July 2026.
Rapiejko is one of the hundreds of recent hires to replace immigration judges fired by the Department of Justice in the last two years. Many, like Rapiejko, have little experience in immigration law, according to the 257 judges’ biographies reviewed by Mission Local.
Nevertheless, they heeded the call this spring, responding to the Justice Department’s advertising campaign calling for “deportation judges” and promising between $159,951 and $207,500 a year.

Take Ryan Beyers, another newly appointed judge in Concord, who had only a year under his belt working for ICE. He had otherwise worked as a prosecutor in Florida and at a private firm. Another newly appointed judge, Lucas Abbott, was hired with just four months of immigration experience working for ICE. Prior to that, he ran his own private law firm for about five years.
Rapiejko is not the only judge with an allegedly storied past as a police officer.
Brett Rogers, now an immigration judge in West Los Angeles, spent 18 years with the Seattle Police Department, and in 2002 he was one of two officers placed on administrative leave after the fatal shooting of a man brandishing a sword, the Everett Herald reported at the time.
Seattle’s police chief later praised the officers’ actions, the Seattle Times reported, and he was cleared of any wrongdoing in 2002.
In the biographies of the over 200 new hires across the nation, however, 45-year-old Rapiejko stood out.
In 2005, while Rapiejko was an officer with the New York Police Department, he arrested a man who later sued him, accusing Rapiejko of pointing his gun at him, ordering him back into his car, and then choking him.
Rapiejko’s lawyer acknowledged in court records that Rapiejko pointed his gun and ordered the man into the car, but denied threatening or choking him, according to court records.
Records show the city of New York settled the lawsuit and paid $20,000 to settle the case.
Years later, while working as a police officer in Marana, Arizona, in 2015, dashcam video shows Rapiejko using his cruiser to jump a curb and ram into an armed suspect who had threatened to kill himself. The dashcam video released by media outlets shows the incident.
Fox News reported that Rapiejko was placed on administrative leave for three days before rejoining the force. The police chief at the time told NBC that Rapiejko “took a very bold action” against a threat to the community, and the Marana police internal review board cleared him of wrongdoing the same year, arguing that his use of force was “appropriate, reasonable and timely,” according to the report.
A civil lawsuit filed by the suspect was dismissed in 2016.
The Executive Office for Immigration Review, the administrative body that oversees the immigration court system, declined to comment on Mission Local’s questions about Rapiejko’s background or qualifications, saying it does not comment on personnel matters.
Mission Local also tried contacting Rapiejko multiple times through a listed phone number and through the Concord and Florence, Arizona courts where he works. A legal assistant at the Arizona court told Mission Local she would pass along the message to Rapiejko, but he never responded.
Experience in immigration law is not required to be an immigration judge. The main requirements are a law degree, an active bar license, and at least seven years of experience practicing law. Rapiejko fulfills those requirements.
Rapiejko worked for one year as an attorney for ICE in Arizona, according to the Department of Justice. Before that, he spent most of his legal career doing tax law, including a seven-year stint as an attorney for the Internal Revenue Service. He is an active member of the District of Columbia Bar.
Since starting as an immigration judge, Rapiejko has yet to grant asylum to any immigrants in the 65 cases he has heard since he began in July, according to “Inmigreat,” which analyzes immigration court data. This is in line with the asylum grant rate of other judges at the court during the same time frame, which is far lower than the 32% nationwide rate of asylum approval the year before the Trump administration took office in 2025.
Maddie Boyd, an attorney with an immigration nonprofit providing legal advice to immigrants, called Rapiejko’s appointment another example “of the administration prioritizing fast-tracked deportation over a system that is neutral.”
Jeremiah Johnson, the vice president of the National Association of Immigration Judges and a former San Francisco immigration judge, said that under the Trump administration, the hiring and backgrounding standards have been weakened.
“The process is not as robust as it used to be, and that is concerning because of how important the job is,” said Johnson.

