Body camera footage showing two officers in gloves restraining a person on the floor.
Three San Francisco police officers arrested Kevon Gibson at a SoMa apartment building on August 17, 2025. Still photo taken from body camera footage.

Three San Francisco police officers allegedly beat a man so severely last year that he nearly lapsed into a coma, according to his public defenders, who also accused District Attorney Brooke Jenkins of trying to cover up the incident.

Kevon Gibson, 33, was staying with a friend at a Sixth Street apartment in SoMa in the summer of 2025 when another resident of the building called the police on Aug. 17. The caller claimed Gibson had threatened him and flashed a weapon, his attorneys said in a press conference at the public defender’s office Thursday. 

But Gibson’s attorneys, public defenders Bonnie Chan-Silen and John Paul Passaglia, said it was the opposite. They said that the caller, a white man, had “confronted and threatened” Gibson earlier that morning. 

Police first arrived around 8 a.m. that day, after the man’s call. At the time, they did not confront Gibson, but body camera footage released today by the public defenders shows the man called Gibson the n-word in front of the officers and said that he would “stick this knife into his Black ass.” 

After a second complaint from the caller later that day, police returned to the apartment building around 1 p.m. They asked Gibson’s roommate to open the door so they could talk to her and her “giant-ass boyfriend,” the video shows. “Ain’t nobody gonna do shit if I kick this door down,” one officer says.

Then the body-camera footage shows that when officers found Gibson, they threw him to the ground and repeatedly punched his head. In the video, Gibson pleads with the officers.

“Please, please sir, don’t,” he says. “Can you please listen?” 

“I’m scared to death,” Gibson says later. One officer kneels on his body and pulls his hair. “I can’t breathe,” Gibson says.

Body camera footage shows Kevon Gibson’s Aug. 17, 2025, arrest. Video released by the San Francisco public defender’s office.

The officers later claimed that Gibson had bitten and punched them as they tried to arrest him. Gibson was taken to an intensive care unit after his arrest and sedated for several days. He was subsequently charged with a slew of crimes, including felony counts of resisting arrest for fighting those officers. 

Gibson stayed in jail for a year, after pleading not guilty and rejecting a plea. Chan-Silen, one of the public defenders, said that Gibson was blind in one eye for a long time and urinating blood for nearly a year after he was released from the hospital. He faced a jury trial in the summer of 2026. 

Gibson was found guilty at that trial for illegally possessing a gun as a felon, and for misdemeanors of resisting arrest, in August 2026, but a jury acquitted him of all three felony charges for resisting arrest after seeing the body-camera footage.

His attorneys successfully argued that the officers’ allegations of biting and punching were not credible. 

Gibson will appeal the gun charge the jury substantiated, his lawyers said, since he purportedly only received the firearm from a friend shortly before the incident.

Public defenders say DA sought to cover up beating

Gibson’s attorneys also claim that the district attorney’s office tried to hide evidence of the police abuse, and that they’re now preparing to lodge complaints against the officers involved. 

They said that prosecutors in the 2026 trial asked, unsuccessfully, that all audio from body camera footage be excluded and that jurors not see police interacting with the complainant, who threatens to kill Gibson. 

The public defenders also claimed that investigators with the district attorney’s office woke Gibson from his medically-induced sleep and interviewed him. 

The district attorney’s office wrote in response to the Gibson case that he was convicted of several crimes.

“Calling this a ‘cover-up’ isn’t just an attack on our prosecutors — it shows remarkable disrespect for the court and the jurors who heard the evidence and rendered the verdict,” the office wrote.

The San Francisco Police Department wrote that the district attorney’s Independent Investigations Bureau “found this use of force was justified under California law,” but that the “SFPD is conducting an administrative investigation,” which is standard procedure when the Independent Investigations Bureau gets involved.

The three police officers were identified as Brendan Caraway, Brian Conway, and Gabriel Rivera. 

The public defender’s office intends to file a complaint with the Department of Police Accountability about Gibson’s case, and it will notify the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training to request Caraway, Conway and Rivera be decertified as police. 

This most recent allegation of police violence comes shortly after an investigation by the city’s Department of Police Accountability determined that SFPD officers used excessive force against another city resident, Matthew Ludwig, in a case of mistaken identity which nevertheless resulted in him losing “virtually everything,” as his attorney said at the time. 

“This is an egregious case where our client was violated brutally, and there was a misrepresentation of what happened in the trial,” said Public Defender Mano Raju. “I think San Franciscans want to know the truth about what happened.”

Frankie Solinsky Duryea is a staff reporter covering criminal justice for Mission Local. He was born and raised in Burlingame, and he first worked with Mission Local as an intern in 2025, where he covered immigration and ICE.

Frankie Solinsky Duryea's work has appeared elsewhere in the SF Chronicle and in SFGATE. He speaks Spanish fluently, and Arabic and French conversationally. You can contact him securely on signal @frankiesd.28

Join the Conversation

12 Comments

  1. Shameful coverup by District Attorney Brooke Jenkins!! They should step down. Kudos to the 2 public defenders! My vote goes to Mano Raju, who stands with them.

    +5
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
  2. I have zero faith in the objective judgment of Brooke Jennings, the SFPD or Mayor Lurie . They are a daisy chain of overreach and denial

    +2
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. Hey K, I’d love to hear more about what’s happening in San Bruno County Jail. Reach out to me on signal or at my email.
      – Frankie

      0
      0
      votes. Sign in to vote
  3. “Miss Jenkins, the President is on line 2 offering you a position in the DOJ. He says he knows he can trust you to ignore the violent crimes ICE is committing on his orders and that you will eagerly keep the jackboot of the state on the necks of the underclasses.”

    0
    -2
    votes. Sign in to vote
  4. I don’t think a DA making a legal attempt in court regarding evidence really constitutes a “cover up.” If they were trying to hide the existence of this evidence, that’d be a different kettle of fish. But “cover up” sure does make for a splashy headline!

    0
    -2
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. Hey if you think beating a man half to death for a gun he wasn’t carrying, you should apply to the SFPD. Or you can do PR for Brooksie

      +5
      0
      votes. Sign in to vote
Leave a comment
Please keep your comments short and civil. Do not leave multiple comments under multiple names on one article. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *