No local issue divides San Francisco congressional candidates Scott Wiener and Connie Chan more than land use.
Urbanism is Wiener’s top focus. He has worked for his 16 years in office to create a San Francisco that has more transit, more bicycle lanes and far more housing. He was a YIMBY long before that stance was popular.
Like most city moderates, he believes in a market-based solution to the affordability crisis.
Chan, meanwhile, has been more cautious. She has advocated for avoiding changes that upset residents or risk displacement of existing San Franciscans.
Like most city progressives, she is skeptical that private development will decrease housing and rent costs.
That is not an unfamiliar divide. Land use has long been one of the city’s most contentious issues, to the point where it is often used as a de-facto litmus test for whether someone falls into the city’s progressive or moderate camp.
Though in Congress neither Wiener or Chan would make local land-use decisions, supporters and detractors alike feel that the two candidates’ records on housing and transportation show their priorities, and how they would approach governing at the federal level.
Here are some of the decisions Chan and Wiener have made in their careers.
Bus rapid lanes, car-free streets, and regressive taxes
Chan has frequently drawn the ire of bike and mass transit advocates because she has not supported some projects that come at the expense of cars.
One was a 2023 plan to build a rapid bus lane for the 38-Geary and 38R, dedicating one lane of the street exclusively to bus use. The proposal sought to implement the lane on the 32 blocks between Stanyan Street and 34th Avenue, letting buses speed down the boulevard without encountering traffic. Transit advocates strongly supported it.
But Geary’s small-business owners were concerned the plan would make it harder for customers to drive to their stores, because the plan would remove 31 parking spots, about one per block. This was scaled down from the original proposal, which removed 70.
They found a champion in Chan, who urged the city to delay the project.
“We appreciate Connie Chan, she really listened to us,” said Sean Kim, the owner of Joe’s Ice Cream.
But Chan’s request for a delay frustrated transit activists, who pushed back on the argument that the loss of parking would tank the commercial corridor. They pointed to Clement Street, arguing that it is a thriving corridor in part because it is less car-centric.
In August 2023, the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency moved forward with the bus lane. Chan criticized the agency for ignoring resident concerns, saying residents should not have to “suffer the mismanagement of our transit agency by ideologue bureaucrats.”
By late 2023, the bus lane was painted onto city streets, and according to an SFMTA report, sped up bus travel times by 6% to 11%. As for the parking concerns, “Median parking search time is less than 1 minute,” the report said.
Though transit activists got their project, several told Mission Local the process left them disappointed in Chan.
“It felt as if she was ignoring advocates or community members who really wanted better transit access up on Geary,” said Janelle Wong, a transit and bike activist and co-founder of Asian Urbanist SF.
It was not the first time Chan butted heads with transit advocates.
In 2022, she opposed turning John F. Kennedy Drive in Golden Gate Park into a pedestrian walkway, pushing for an alternative plan that would have partially reopened the road to cars. This would help improve “drop-off for seniors, people with disabilities and others,” she told the San Francisco Chronicle.
She later opposed Proposition K in 2024, which converted a portion of the Great Highway into a park, saying that it was a “winner-takes-all approach” and that she would support a solution “that provided both open space and maintained road access.”
Chan is currently supporting Prop. G to close Sunset Dunes park during the week and bring back the coastal road; Wiener has written the official opposition to it.
Wong described working with Chan on transit issues as “difficult.”
“She wasn’t very open to hearing why advocates wanted to have JFK car-free, not just for recreation purposes, but also for a safer route without cars for families and people riding bikes,” Wong said.
Chan’s stance on tax measures to fund transit has depended on whom the city is taxing. She supported Prop. L in 2024, which taxed ride-hailing companies to fund Muni, but in 2020 she opposed Measure RR, a sales tax to fund Caltrain and, in 2023, opposed a $1.50 temporary toll hike on Bay Area bridges for BART and other Bay Area transit agencies.
“We’re increasing bridge tolls to fund public transit, and it’s still not providing services that people actually need so they can ditch their cars to get to work, and that is a vicious cycle that I’m not going to enable,” Chan told the San Francisco Examiner in 2023.
As for Measure RR, she said the sales tax would be a burden on “small businesses and working people,” and that the city should instead focus on finding state and federal funding.
To transit and bike advocate Zach Lipton, though, this stance was “surprising and alarming.”
“This was a point where without this Caltrain was going to shut down,” he said.
Another sales tax, the Regional Transit Measure, which was negotiated by Wiener, is on the ballot this Tuesday to bolster Muni and BART budgets so they don’t have to slash service.
Chan is supporting the measure, though she said she will have to “hold my nose and vote for it.” She does not like that it is a sales tax, a regressive tax that hits lower-income people more. She criticized Wiener for not securing a more progressive tax scheme.
Wiener and other transit advocates, who spent years working on the measure, said that the progressive options explored — including a business tax and an income tax — would have likely failed, or been vetoed by the governor.
“It’s easy to shoot down other people’s solutions and be a Monday-morning quarterback when you refuse to engage in the years of hard work of bringing a diverse region together to solve a complex problem,” Wiener said.
Urbanist advocates say that Wiener has consistently been aligned with their vision for a San Francisco with better public transit and more walkable and bikeable streets.
Janice Li, a BART Board Director, said that with Wiener, transit advocates “knew you reliably had an elected official that you could go to, to work with to bring an issue forward.”
In 2025, for instance, Wiener secured an emergency state loan for Muni, BART and Caltrain, intended to stabilize them until the regional transit measures passes.
“It’s hard to think of someone who’s fought more on those issues than Scott has,” she said. “When the regional transit measure wins, Scott will be the very first person I’m texting to say thank you.”
Upzoning, streamlining, and tenants rights
Wiener, one of the original YIMBYs, has made the perennial quest to build more housing in San Francisco his No. 1 priority in his years as city supervisor and state senator.
The core YIMBY argument is that low housing supply drives up costs. Far more people want to live in San Francisco than there is housing, and the competition drives up costs, they argue.
When Wiener was elected to the California State Senate in 2016, it was a YIMBY dream come true. He proposed audacious bills, like SB 827, that would have radically rezoned cities up and down the state to allow apartment buildings near public transit. It brought the state senator national renown.
That bill died in committee, but Wiener persisted. Seven years later, and after two failed efforts, Gov. Gavin Newsom signed SB 79, one of the most sweeping zoning overhauls in modern state history.
Wiener also passed streamlining bills to guarantee that projects that follow city rules can quickly and easily get permits.
But this streamlining eliminated opportunities for residents to weigh in, which Chan sees as a loss. The review process was “empowerment for neighborhood input and for community input,” she told Mission Local in May. “Do we see then, at times, it could be abused? Absolutely, like any other law. But that does not mean we abandon it.”
Many YIMBYs feel these community meetings were venues for blocking housing, citing studies that found the attendees at these hearings were not fully representative of the general population.
“I think that prioritizes who can show up and who is able to do that, statistically speaking, we know is older, we know is whiter, we know is richer, we know is more likely to own a home,” said Jane Natoli, a Wiener supporter and former Bay Area director at YIMBY Action.
Chan, for her part, has argued that cutting red tape isn’t the main hurdle to building housing, it’s access to capital.
“The lack of financing has been a major impediment for major projects to move forward,” her campaign said, pointing to high interest rates, high construction costs and, more recently, a data-center build-out that has made it difficult for housing developers to access either capital or labor.
“There are only two key elements to building housing: land and money,” Chan told Mission Local in May.
“The way I see it,” Chan said, federal funding “through progressive taxation” should be used “to build housing that is not just for low-income or very-low-income” but also “to build middle income housing.”
Both Chan’s and Wiener’s platforms call for billions in federal investment for housing. And Wiener has said his permit streamlining is a necessary but not sufficient fix.
Chan has also criticized Wiener’s laws for streamlining not just subsidized affordable housing, but also market-rate housing that in San Francisco is astronomically expensive.
Chan does not think that the city needs more market-rate housing, saying it is “luxury” housing that will only go to “those people who can afford it.”
“New housing can be a good idea, especially if it’s affordable housing,” said longtime tenant advocate Mitchell Omerberg. “But it’s not how you protect people who live in San Francisco.”
YIMBYs counter that building market-rate housing benefits low-income people, pointing to studies that found that high-income residents who move into new units free up cheaper housing.
A planning department study commissioned in 2001 modeled that the reduction in prices brought about by a rapid addition of homes would be dwarfed by the increase in home prices brought about by new wealth flowing into San Francisco.
Other studies have found that new apartments lead to small decreases in nearby rents.
Chan has subsequently opposed some majority market rate housing projects, including the 22-story Safeway project in the Marina and a project in SoMa that would have converted a parking lot into 495 units of housing.
The Marina project, which would create 848 units including 86 affordable units, has been opposed by local residents — and Mayor Daniel Lurie — for being out of scale with the neighborhood.
The SoMa project was slated to be about 20% affordable but was opposed by local residents who argued that it would gentrify the neighborhood, bringing in wealthier residents.
Ian Krager, Chan’s spokesperson, said when in Washington, Chan will “fight for federal investments in affordable housing and public transit, Medicare for All and a progressive tax code that makes billionaires and corporations pay their fair share.”
Wiener hasn’t aligned with the YIMBYs on every single issue, though. In 2018, he opposed Proposition C, which raised taxes on businesses in order to dedicate $300 million every year to homelessness services, half of which was dedicated to helping people get into permanent housing.
Wiener said at the time that, while he supports raising business taxes and wants more money to go to homelessness, the tax measure was “not responsibly crafted,” pointing out that it did not go through negotiations with the mayor, Board of Supervisors, or other stakeholders.
“If Prop C passes, tax policy will have effectively moved out of City Hall and into the hands of outside groups,” he wrote.
Chan’s housing record has emphasized protecting existing San Franciscans over building new market-rate housing, something some tenant advocates think makes sense.
Shanti Singh, a longtime tenant advocate, said Chan’s work as budget chair was “critical” for restoring funding to programs like eviction prevention and tenant legal defense.
“Connie’s top priority is making San Francisco affordable for the people who call it home,” Chan’s spokesperson, Krager, said.
As a state senator, Wiener has also been a fairly reliable vote on tenant issues, but Singh said those were not a top priority compared to streamlining housing.
During his tenure as supervisor, Wiener at times clashed with tenant activists. They took issue with his support of a 2013 tenancy-in-common proposal, for instance, that would have given those buildings — jointly bought by several owners — a one-time chance to become condos for a fee.
But in activists’ eyes, tenancies-in-common were suspect; they took rental units off the market, and buyers had sometimes evicted tenants in the process. Bailing out tenancy-in-common owners by allowing condo conversions, which would increase their value, sent the wrong message, they felt.
Activists also took issue with some of Wiener’s stances on the Costa-Hawkins Rental Housing Act, the California law that bans local jurisdictions from expanding rent control. It is the reason why rent control only applies to buildings occupied prior to 1979 in San Francisco.
In 2023, Wiener supported a bill that would have reformed Costa-Hawkins to let cities extend rent control to apartment buildings more than 28 years old.
But tenant advocates have long wanted a full repeal of Costa Hawkins so rent control can be expanded to every unit. In 2024, Prop. 33 was put on the ballot to do just that, and Wiener took no position.
“Rent control is an important tool to keep housing affordable, and I’ve stood with tenants to expand it over and over throughout my time in public office,” Wiener said in a statement.
Chan and Wiener’s different land-use approaches came to a head last fall when the board considered an upzoning allowing taller buildings on commercial corridors in the city’s northern and western neighborhoods, including Chan’s home base, the Richmond.
The plan, which was mandated by the state due to a law Wiener wrote, increased heights from about four stories to between six and eight stories, creating more capacity for housing.
Chan hated the upzoning plan, and argued that tenants and small businesses were at risk of being displaced if their buildings were redeveloped. The city has strict criteria for redeveloping rental housing.
The board eventually voted 7-4 to approve the upzoning plan. Chan voted against it.
In her remarks about the plan, she took aim at Wiener.
“We cannot simply agree to demolish San Francisco for the sake of meeting a state mandate legislated by a single-minded legislator based on unproven housing ideology,” she said at a hearing on Nov. 17, 2025.
Three days later, on Nov. 20, Chan announced her run for Congress.
This story has been updated.


So we’re to believe Chan will fight for the things she’s fought against (ie transit) if elected? Having watched her career for years, she is more about pointing out problems – rarely getting her hands dirty to solve them.
Which is worse, cautiousness or selling out? Weiner already sold out to AI.
What specific legislation regulating AI has Chan authored and gotten passed into law? What significant legislation has Chan authored at all?
She didn’t “fight against transit” she fought against developer giveaways.
The distinction matters to people who have lived and have families in SF.
You’ve maybe been reading too many AI-generated Wiener propaganda pieces.
Sorry, I was there when she fought against transit, specifically the 38 Geary bus rapid transit second phase. I saw her in action. Yes, we have a “watered down” 38 BRT now owing to her making a cause celebre out of a few parking spaces. And I see why she has to attack Scott this way about AI — in the face of his being a national leader on AI relative to her …doing nothing but complaining from the sidelines.
THAT WOULD HAVE COST BILLIONS LOL.
You “transit nerds” crack me up with your crackpotism and bong loads of hyper-optimistic BS.
The 38 is the best running line in the city.
Find another tiny violin to play as if the only instrument in the symphony.
@Hum – Improving transit on the Geary corridor is not a “developer giveaway.” We voted 37 freaking years ago to extend Muni Metro to that corridor, it’s still a voter mandate with the force of law, and all we’ve got is weaksauce patches of paint. And Connie Chan impeded even that.
I bet you voted for the 2 Billion dollar subway station and 2 million dollar public restroom also.
Wieners. AI slop Nonsense spigots.
@Rilly – To clarify, that’s an editorial we, meaning San Francisco voters. I was in Oakland 37 years ago but I’ve been a San Francisco voters for most of the time since then.
But yes, 1989’s Prop B did mandate extending the Central Subway to the north, which at the time was understood to be an Portsmouth Square alignment. It wasn’t until Willie Brown and Rose Pak got their hands on things that it was moved to the far more expensive and unfinished $2 Billion alignment.
Nothing whatsoever to do with Wiener nor AI slop.
You are entitled to your own opinion but not your own facts. This article is slanted to imply that new market rate either does not reduce rents or only reduces them a little bit. I will quote in length to the linked article that the author claims “Other studies have found that new apartments lead to small decreases in nearby rents.” What the study actually says: ” be clear, this debate is not about whether new housing can reduce housing prices overall. At
this point, that idea isn’t really in doubt. There’s good reason to believe that in regions with high
housing demand, building more housing can help keep the prices of existing housing down. In their Supply Skepticism paper from 2018, Vicki Been, Ingrid Gould Ellen, and Katherine O’Regan offer an excellent introduction to the broader question of how market-rate development affects affordability. Citing numerous individual studies and reviews of dozens more, they conclude that “the preponderance of the evidence shows that restricting supply increases housing prices and that adding supply would help to make housing more affordable.””
I encourage people to read it themselves. Housing shortages make housing expensive. Real Progressives want more housing and Progressives like Mamdani support more housing. Vote Connie if you prefer high rents.
Chan is hardly “progressive”, she’s a status quo reactionary NIMBY who is fine with denying to others what she and her family currently enjoys, i.e., the opportunity for homeownership.
Scott Wiener, on the other hand is the only pro-housing candidate in this race and the only true progressive.
He has successfully fought NIMBYism his entire political career and has been the most effective State legislator in this century when it comes to housing, civil rights, healthcare, etc.
Whereas Connie Chan hasn’t done squat and hasn’t ever authored — much less gotten passed into law — a single piece of significant legislation.
“Scott Wiener, on the other hand is the only pro-housing candidate in this race”
This is one of the blatantly false claims Wiener makes in Youtube ads. Are you Scott?
If elected, Chan will be quietly delighted to be working with Trump on banning new housing construction in CA via federal regulations, and getting rid of all the “DEI bike lanes” that his administration hates so much because they get in the way of Musk et al’s profits.
Some of us remember vaguely when progressives stil professed some belief in making cities more livable for people.
“progressive” is when homeowners who voted for Dan White are able to realize high returns on their long-term real estate investments
and the higher the returns they realize, the more progressive-er it is
San Francisco must be the only city in the country, if not the world, where there are only “progressives” and “moderates”. Actually, if you read Joe’s recent piece, there are fewer and fewer progressives. So everybody is a “moderate”: Weiner is a moderate; Chris Larsen, who has bought the SFPD, is a “moderate”. Even a man who threatens the lives of others (looking at you Garry Tan) is a moderate. Chan is not expressly labeled a “progressive” but is implied so even though she opposes many “progressive” issues. That’s ok. Just words. Just language.
Chan seems to think that regressive taxes are inherently a bad thing. But they are no worse than progressive taxes. Both are necessary. Progressive taxes ensure that the rich pay more. Regressive taxes ensure that everyone pays something.
This guy is hilarious! Now do the bit about soylent green!
Very comprehensive!
Not a lot is being said about whether their local land use positions are relevant at all to what will await them in Congress. It’s entirely possible that none of those issues will matter when they are trying to create coalitions or get committee assignments or participate in hearings.
One of them has actually built successful coalitions to pass big bold laws–regardless of what you think about Wiener’s positions, it’s clear he knows how to get things done with big coalitions on difficult and complex policy issues. Chan, on the other hand, has done basically nothing that involved building a coalition of people who disagree with her — and basically nothing at all for the city.
I don’t trust either one of them. They both made it clear during the primary that they couldn’t care less what I think. I left the question blank.
There’s the insidious “moderate” framing again.
If people believe in a “market-based solution”, by definition they are economic conservatives, not “moderates.”
By today’s mainstream Democrat standards, Reagan would be a “moderate.”
moderate, adj: being for unrestricted gentrification and unfettered oligarchy, but willing to concede on renaming streets for deceased liberal icons (as long as it won’t raise taxes).
Moderates are Republicans with flexible pronouns.
A Progressive believes in progress which Connie Chan does not. She is a preservationist, which is a conservative position in every city in America except San Francisco.
New York City elected a real Progressive as Mayor and he believe in building housing. Someday we will have one too, but not until Chan has been sent to electoral purgatory where she can join Peskin and Preston.
What one believes to be “progress” is purely subjective.
In the context of American politics, “progressive” refers to the furthest left economic positions that the Democrat Party will acknowledge (although it routinely sabotages those who hold those positions).
Blanket statements like “build moar housing” are meaningless unless you specify which type of housing is to be built, where, by whom, for whom, and how it will be financed.
“If people believe in a “market-based solution”, by definition they are economic conservatives, not “moderates.”
No, a moderate believes in a mix of private and public development, which is what we have now.
A conservative wants to see no public housing and a progressive wants to see no private housing.
Lol, no progressive says there should be no private housing. Few socialists even say that. You are thinking of communists. Although, to be fair, you might think anyone left of the mythical center is a commie.
Your Overton Window has skewed so far to the right to the point where a mainstream liberal like FDR would be viewed as a radical pinko.
Thank you for demonstrating the utter vapidity of American political discourse.
Well-stated. Plus, “moderate” implies that “progressives” are immoderate, that is, extremist. As the positions noted by “two beers,” plus the tech money pouring into SF’s elections make clear, there’s nothing moderate about so-called moderates. Let’s call things by their right names. What’s labeled “moderate” is pro-Big Capital.
Zelda, by national standards most SF politicians would be considered “loony left” socialists. Only in the bubble that is San Francisco do we consider someone like Scott Wiener to be a billionaire tool rather than what he really is – a liberal moderate.
I highly recommend travel as a means of developing a sense of proportion on this topic.
@Ron – I have traveled and what you write is not true. Most SF politicians, particularly the ones with the most power, have been neoliberal for most of this century. The typical combo is conservative on fiscal policy (neoliberalism) and liberal on sociopolitical policy.
Sometimes the sociopolitical end goes off the rails, e.g. trying to rename Lowell High because someone, somewhere, unrelated to the school but named Lowell, was racist. But that’s a sideshow.
People who hurl the phrase “loony left” and especially if they call anyone in power here a “socialist,” they are the loony right.
Let’s name the “progressives” for what they are: a collaborative effort between public sector labor unions and a cartel of politically connected city funded nonprofits.
According to Trump’s AI and crypto czar David Sacks, Anthropic has already been buying politicians.
And their favorite product is Scott Wiener
I can’t understand how Wiener gets away with styling himself a champion of transit when on his watch, both Muni and BART (as well as Caltrain before them) are on life support and the electorate is repeatedly scared with “either you pass more regressive taxes or your transit systems are gonna get it.”
The advocates/activists are nothing but cheerleaders for management, and will demand we throw more and more money at these agencies without conditioning support on even the slightest of concessions.
Agreed.
The sales tax stuff is the worst thing on the ballot.
In a city with a ridiculous and critical cost of living problem – lets make everybody pay for the gross mismanagement of our transit systems.
The unions are on board because at the end of the day this is about jobs, pensions and benefits. Part of this is a manifestation of the underfunded pensions entailments that began with his majesty, Willie Brown, coming home to roost. This is to the benefit of a small slice of City workers. You pay. Everybody pays. Forever.
I’ve closely watched bike coalition and SFMTA for almost 3 decades and their argument of safety and more bike lane is dead. They haven’t progressed for 2 decades. No traffic flow hindering infrastructures can make a driver competent.
And more housing missed the point of lowering the housing cost to make it affordable for the working class, that would be below market rate.
The tech with no money sense jacked it up. Only a rent cap can stop that. And collecting tax from those overbearing tech companies destroying SF.
I’d rather bet on Connie Chang, to see what she might do.
Vote for Connie!
I voted for Connie!
Yeah, y’all have helped Wiener with your slanted coverage,
Wiener get’s piece after piece about him being a victim.
His very best work has always been to advance the interests of Developers to figure ways as a Corporate Democrat Real Estate Attorney to circumvent existing laws from your law offices on to City Hall where he advanced the interests of the same class and then on to Sacramento where he wrote laws that took away the power of local tenants and homeowners about how many fresh parking spaces they’re going to need on their block next year and the like.
So, at City Hall he conspired with David Chiu to destroy some 2,000 Rent Control housing units and at State he made it legal for a developer/speculator could tear down the place next door to you without even posting a notice beforehand because of one of Wiener’s laws which were unusually hard on San Francisco Small home owners and cleared the way for a quicker resort of developers favorite, ‘Builders Remedy’.
You know, that phrase (Builders Remedy) makes me whence.
It makes developers smile.
Hey, Chan’s made a few bad calls to keep her job or she wouldn’t be here at all but Scott has spent his entire career as a RE Speculator mouthpiece and legislator and he’s the best at it and I congratulate him but I’m pretty certain AI will negate the outcome of all these elections but, I drift …
Put bluntly, let’s send an immigrant to represent the #1 Immigrant City in the World.
Connie for Congress !!
Go Niners !!
h.
Q: Who created the housing that “h. brown” lives in?
A: A developer.
Yet “h. brown” vilifies them. I wonder of “h. brown” also vilifies the farmers who produce the food he eats?
Just the fact that Wiener used AI chatbots to lie about his opponent says it all.
I’m for anyone else and Chan is a strong legislative stand against techbro lies.
You either vote for a genocide apologist (for decades) or you don’t. I won’t.
Chan is for SF. Wiener has ambitions, delusions of grandeur.
“We cannot simply agree to demolish San Francisco for the sake of meeting a state mandate legislated by a single-minded legislator based on unproven housing ideology”
Well said.
Main reason Connie got our vote.
Unfortunately, the negative implication is that The Wiener will stay in California to continue mucking things up with his “ideas”.
“Demolish San Francisco” – looks like her scare tactics worked on you. Such an assertion is inaccurate and lazy, and the flimsy tool of those who have nothing solid to stand on.