Photo by Lydia Chávez

Julian, 20-something, and Mark, 70-something, will be hunting for the Mission’s best fried chicken sandwich. If you have suggestions, write a comment — or, if you prefer, send an e-mail to Julian at

I’m no expert, Mark, but this seems to be your classic fried chicken sandwich. It has the slaw, the mayo, and of course the fat slab of fried chicken, which made the sandwich stand a towering four inches off the plate. That didn’t mean it was cumbersome — in fact, it was quite comfortable to eat.

Slightly unnerving, however, was the Pepto Bismol-colored juice that spewed out of the sandwich and onto my hands at first bite. That must be what happens when purple cabbage coleslaw collides with chili aioli.   

The chicken was crunchy and tender and hinted with a perfect amount of spicy-sour Buffalo flavor. Some parts were a little burned, giving the chicken, at times, minor notes of “Safeway hot case.” That’s never the end of the world (I love fried-food hot cases), but when you remember you paid more than $10 for a sandwich that’s no bigger than your hand, you have to wonder.

The owners of the Salumeria were sitting next to me as I ate, so I took the opportunity to ask what their batter recipe was. They said some Aleppo pepper, fennel pollen, coriander, black pepper and buttermilk, which mingles over a 24-hour period. The chicken, they said, is twice-breaded with the batter for the extra crunch.

I give it three and half “chirps” out of four, you? 

 — Julian

“We got Chicken Red Light
We got drive-in chicken
We got felony chicken
We got chicken gravy
But we ain’t got no fried chicken”
— June Jordan, Menu

That’s the way it was in the Mission back in the day. We had cashew chicken, broasted (!) chicken, mole chicken and Pollo Supremo. But no fried chicken (we won’t count the Colonel’s old hangout on Valencia and Hill — though fried, no one dare call it “chicken”). Once a fried-chicken wasteland, the Mission 4.0 now cackles with fried chicken on every block. Now we got more fried chicken per capita than burritos. If it wasn’t for Oakland, the Mission would be the fried-chicken capital of Northern California.

Julian, you live and work at ground zero of a historic transformation. So I am shocked — and mildly amused — to hear you sing the praises Salumeria’s soggy sandwich. First of all, it’s considered bad form in fried chicken circles to swoon over your first sandwich. There is context to consider. Also history.

Most particularly, the problem with the Pepto-Bismol-colored slaw juice is not the mess it makes, though there is that, but what it does to the chicken. More precisely, the batter. That rich glorious Italianate “Aleppo pepper, fennel pollen, coriander, black pepper, buttermilk” batter, “mingled” for 24 hours, then added twice for “extra crunch” gets soaked and subverted by the wet slaw. At best, you get half-crunch, half-glop (BTW, what is “Aleppo” pepper? I hope you’re not insinuating politics into gastronomy.)

Unfortunately, the slaw also undermines the taste, overwhelming not only the batter, but the chicken itself.

Nice try, Julian, but you need to get out more, eat more fried chicken. Can we ever get enough (a question we’ll be exploring)? There are no end of options. Undreamed of marvels await you.

Monk’s Kettle next?


The search

The fried chicken showdown begins at the Salumeria, Dec. 7, 2017

The fried chicken showdown takes a detour to Wes Burger, Dec. 18, 2017

The fried chicken showdown goes to Monk’s Kettle, Jan. 4, 2018

The fried chicken showdown goes to Rhea’s cafe, Jan. 23, 2018

The fried chicken showdown at Buttermilk, Feb. 22, 2018

The fried chicken showdown at Bi-Rite, March 30, 2018

The fried chicken showdown stops at West of Pecos, April 23

The fried chicken showdown at Son’s Addition, May, 24, 2018

The fried chicken showdown at Los Picudos, July 26, 2018

Follow Us

Julian grew up in the East Bay and moved to San Francisco in 2014. Before joining Mission Local, he wrote for the East Bay Express, the SF Bay Guardian, and the San Francisco Business Times.

Mark Rabine has lived in the Mission for over 40 years. "What a long strange trip it's been." He has maintained our Covid tracker through most of the pandemic, taking some breaks with his search for the Mission's best fried-chicken sandwich and now its best noodles. When the Warriors make the playoffs, he writes up his take on the games.

9 replies on “The fried chicken showdown in SF’s Mission begins at Salumeria”

  1. “That’s the way it was in the Mission back in the day. We had cashew chicken, broasted (!) chicken, mole chicken and Pollo Supremo. But no fried chicken (we won’t count the Colonel’s old hangout on Valencia and Hill –” Have we forgotten about the Popeye’s on 22nd and Mission already?!?

  2. If Hog and Rocks is selling the same fried chicken they sold at Maverick, you gotta get you some of that. But this list must include the fried chicken from the stabby gas station at South Van Ness and 17th.

  3. I love the fried chicken at West of Pecos on Valencia between 16th and 17th. It comes with delicious sides of mashed potatoes, steamed spinach, and creamed corn.

  4. Cross the street to Rheas and you will find the best fried chicken in the Mission.

    1. Rhea’s fried chicken is of the Gods, especially when hungover. Can’t recommend it highly enough.

Comments are closed.