New Skate Park Grinds Neighbors’ Nerves

Skaters flock to the new SoMa West Skate Park, located under the Central Freeway between Mission and Valencia. Photo by Joe Rivano Barros.

Skaters flock to the new SoMa West Skate Park, located under the Central Freeway between Mission and Valencia. Photo by Joe Rivano Barros.

En Español.

When the SoMa West Skate Park opened under the Central Freeway earlier this month, skateboarders greeted it enthusiastically, crowding the park with kickflips and ollies at all hours of the day.

To the chagrin of some neighbors, all hours of the day means all hours of the day.

Neighbors are less than thrilled by what they deem excessive noise coming from the park, both during its normal operating hours (9 a.m. to 9 p.m.) and well past dark. The park’s 5-foot fence and lack of security make late-night skate sessions a frequent occurrence.

“During the day, I can deal with skateboard noise,” said A., a Stevenson Street resident who did not wish to be identified for fear of future trouble. “For me it’s just an issue at 4 in the morning. Just don’t. Don’t hop the fence and skateboard. It’s real simple.”

Neighbors call the police on a nightly basis and say they’ve received prompt responses, but know the cops cannot come out every time. “The Southern Station is a big area, and they have a lot of violent crime going on, and here we are bothering them with this ridiculous nonsense,” said Meagan Makinson, another resident.

After-hours skating is not confined to the park itself. Residents often awaken to the sound of skateboards going up and down the cobblestone paving of Stevenson Street. The noise has quickly become a nuisance.

“When they come out of the skatepark, they use the corners to do jumps,” said A., who has recorded decibel measurements of the noise levels using a smartphone app. According to her readings, the levels ranged from 64 dBA at ambient street noise to 84 dBA when a skateboarder passes by, both at around 1 a.m.

The San Francisco Department of Public Health has noise limits intended to prevent health problems that result from “persistent exposure to elevated levels of community noise.” Within residences, these limits are 55 decibels during the day (7 a.m to 10 p.m.) and 45 decibels at night.

“We’re already on the edge of what you can tolerate for your health,” said Meagan. “So when you throw in more noise, even during the day, you’re throwing it on top of a really crappy situation.”

But the park’s users may not see this as their problem. One skater, known as ANT, says that neighbors are “just not used to noise” while another, who calls himself SirDenzel Lumsey, acknowledged the situation but said that everyone skates down the street “at least once.”

Others added that the freeway already makes this a loud area, and neighbors should accept that they live in a noisy space.

“We all moved in knowing the freeway was here,” said another of the park’s neighbors. “We’re not a bunch of newbies with sensitive ears. We could not have chosen to move into a louder space, so the fact that this is bothering us means it’s a real fucking problem.”

While noise has had the most persistent impact, there are also concerns about drugs and drinking, and there has been at least one instance of skater-related violence.

On July 13, a man living on Elgin Park, two streets down from Stevenson and the skate park, was assaulted by three skaters in their 20s. According to police reports, the resident asked the young men to move from his front stairs, at which point the skaters pummeled him with their fists before striking him repeatedly with a skateboard. All three were arrested, and the man was treated on the scene for his injuries.

And then there’s the public urination.

“I have multiple times stopped guys as they were in the process of urinating and said very politely ‘Please could you not? Respect the neighborhood,’” said a resident. “And every time I’ve gotten a response that included something about ‘Why don’t you make them put a bathroom in the skate park?’”

Local businesses agree. An employee of Scuderia, a motorcycle shop across the street from the park, said that his main interaction with skaters is over the use of the shop’s restroom. Another employee added that he has seen whole groups of skaters roll up just to use their bathroom.

Neighbors think building a public bathroom is just a first step. The city could erect a taller fence to eliminate after-hours skating and construct sound mitigation for daytime noise.

As for the skating down Stevenson Street, the city is already addressing the problem.

Steven Cismowski, a San Francisco city planner, approved the relocation of the park’s entrance from Stevenson to Duboce, nearer to Mission. The hope is that the new entrance will reduce pedestrian and vehicular traffic in the neighborhood.

Such solutions are precisely what Stevenson Street residents hope to accomplish by voicing their concerns. The issue, they say, is not so much with the skaters themselves, as with the lack of response from the city.

“We’re not anti-skater, I love looking out there and seeing them go. I think it’s a beautiful-looking space, certainly better than a parking lot,” said another aggrieved neighbor. “The problem isn’t with the skaters. The problem is with the planning process, the construction process and the lack of any reasonable foresight into mitigating what are entirely obvious problems with the design, and that fault lies with the city.”

20 Comments

  1. Kevin Smith

    They need to make the 2 surrounding blocks of the skate park a NO SKATE high enforcement zone, or tear the nuisance down !

  2. randolph mortimer

    Classic San Francisco stupidity – build a skate park with no bathrooms.

  3. Orrdu

    The “only newbies complain about noise” thing is ridiculous. Excess noise sucks. And it’s easily dealt with. And it needs to be prioritized as a health impact- the SFDPH clearly acknowledges it as such. I feel very sorry for the residents who have to listen to this at all hours.
    One simple solution is to drastically cut the operating hours. 9-9? No way. 9-6, more like.

    • Sk8parkfail

      The problem is that they just hop the fence whenever they feel like it. The hours are useless.

  4. mission resident

    Residents of stevenson street, go to home depot and by a bag of gravel. scatter the gravel on your street and sidewalks with a higher concentration at the entrance. Skateboarders won’t be able to ride over the gravel. Keep it up for a couple weeks. They will naturally start taking a different route. This along with moving the entrance should help the noise. Since the city won’t help you, you are forced to do something yourselves.

    • Sam

      There are a number of ways of making things very difficult for skateboarders. It is intolerable that the residents of this neighborhood were not allowed any say. I thought we were all NIMBY’s in this town

      • Bryan

        All the residents ten years ago wanted this park. If they didn’t want it then it would not be there now

        • Sam

          Wait, so every single last resident of an entire neighborhood wanted this? Without exception? Not even one opponent? Really?

          Why don’t you take a more positive attitude and advance, say, a code of conduct for the skaters in consideration of the neighbors? Why would that be a bad idea?

  5. Stevenson Neighbor

    The original Plan called for a Basketball Court in this Park that would have attracted a variety of people to this park, but that plan was scrapped quietly; without public input.

    I personally believe that the Basketball Courts were left out of the park, to keep persons of African Descent (Black People) out of the park.

    This is an example of institutional racism. The City of San Francisco Park Department should be ashamed of itself for these actions.

  6. Bryan

    The skate community worked for ten years getting this park built . Neighbors were involved et al. The fence was designed to be taller. A bathroom was cut. The people wanted cobblestone. Thier bad. We also designed a wall for sound, also cut. As for the guy with the gravel comment. Your lame. Why would you suggest hurting someone to keep it quiet? Super lame dude

    • Sk8parkfail

      Neighbors were quite vocal in their dissent about a skate park during planning meetings from the beginning.

  7. Sam

    The skate community? Did you just say that?

    So everything that is wrong with that park is the fault of someone else, and not the skate “community”?

    Are you sticking with that story?

  8. TEx84

    If you buy your child a skateboard he will end up a drop out. Skateparks attract delinquents, drugs, graffiti, vandalism, violence, litter, and noise. Why not use the space for wholesome sports clubs and develop athletes who can go on to compete for the city, county, or nation, instead of actively developing a generation of jackass-style delinquents?

    • Bryan

      You are super racist and pretty ignorant son

      • Deke

        Bryan,
        Nothing he said was racist… maybe ignorant and he drew ridiculous unfair assumptions… but “racist” is incorrect..

        • Sam

          Playing a race card is something so instinctive to some people that they can barely resist over-playing it with little or no pretext.

          And of course if you point that out, they call you a racist!

  9. Bryan

    You all are kinda weak with all your racist and ignorant stuff. Work a little harder on yourself and you might see through the crap in your minds

  10. Deke

    I want to see the skate park remain, but clearly the skaters are annoying the neighbors.
    I just saw a video (circulated on the neighborhood mailing list) where a skater jumped a fence (pretty cool trick) but he landed in traffic and slightly bumped a car.
    This kind of behavior is not only dangerous for pedestrians and drivers (say a car swerves to miss him and hits someone?), but it’s also going to cause issues for the skate park.
    Here’s some advice… be considerate to the neighbors and you’ll be fine… but be aggressive, rude, pissing on peoples doorsteps, putting people at risk, jumping the fence when it’s closed (all things I hear neighbors complain about) is going to result in one thing… neighbors constantly calling the cops and either the park will be closed or you’ll have cops patrolling it constantly.
    For your own sakes, be smart, considerate, respect the people who live there and you’ll be left alone.

Comments are closed.