Two people stand smiling together on a sidewalk, surrounded by various clothing items and objects displayed for sale along a metal fence.
Yolanda Valdez and Camanza Murillo stand in front of their goods on 16th Street. Photo by Abigail Van Neely on May 3, 2025.

The 16th Street BART plaza had long been important to Yolanda Valdez and Camanza Murillo as a place of business. Then it became a matchmaker. 

They were going through a difficult time, 76-year-old Valdez remembers. Both she and Murillo had recently lost their spouses, and one of Valdez’s eight children had been killed in a car accident.  

Still, they continued trying to make a living as vendors. One day, Murillo came over to Valdez’s spot to see if she was hungry. She was. They got tacos at Pancho Villa down the street. He paid. 

That was several years ago. Nowadays, Murillo bikes down 16th Street to fetch Valdez cups of water from the corner store when she’s thirsty. Meanwhile, Valez sits in a folding chair overseeing their goods, an eclectic collection now sold together near Caledonia Street, across from the taqueria.

Giants caps are laid next to a neat row of wrenches. Spanish music plays from a speaker. A fur coat flutters from a hanger on the fence next to Caledonia Street. 

That side street is one of the alleys near the plaza that the city has targeted for drug activity. Neighbors have complained of users loitering and littering the road with trash, saying they’re afraid to leave their homes

But Valdez, who has lived on Valencia and 15th Street for 40 years, isn’t afraid of people using drugs. “They’re in their own world,” she explains in Spanish. “They don’t bother anyone.” 

Two people stand on a city sidewalk smiling at the camera; one wears a vest and cap, the other an orange hat, with cars and buildings in the background.
Yolanda Valdez and Camanza Murillo on 16th Street. Photo by Abigail Van Neely on May 3, 2025.

On the contrary, Valdez recognizes many of the people who walk by pushing beat-up bikes or walking scruffy dogs. She greets them with a smile. 

“You ask them to move and they do,” Valdez says as she acts out someone hunched over, a side effect of fentanyl use. “They say sorry.” 

“They have feelings and lives,” adds Murillo, who is in the last phase of a recovery program. “They want money to eat.” 

Murillo says he understands why the presence of drugs makes neighbors nervous. But he agrees the people using the drugs are not scary. He thinks many want to change their lives. 

“We are doing this to live,” Murillo says of their street vending. In his free time, he adds, he volunteers at Centro Latino, a nonprofit that assists Latinos. 

In Valdez’s opinion, 16th Street is safer than it was when she first moved to the Mission from Texas four decades ago. There are more drugs now, she supposes, but fewer smashed windows and motorcycles racing down the street. “Es tranquilo,” she says with a wave of her hand towards the alleys. 

Since arriving at the plaza in March, she notes, the police drive by every hour. They help keep the sidewalk clear and prevent theft, which has been a problem, Valdez says as she clutches her small black purse closer. 

A busy urban street corner with pedestrians, palm trees, a food cart, graffiti-covered buildings, and overhead power lines under a clear sky.
5/3/25 Northeast BART Plaza. Photo by Abigail Van Neely.
A person with a red bag crosses a city street at a crosswalk; people are gathered on the sidewalk near urban buildings and street art.
5/3/25 Southwest BART plaza. Photo by Abigail Van Neely.

The BART plazas down the street are sunny and clear. Mission Street between 16th and 15th streets, however, is lined with vendors selling everything from quesabirria out of a pop-up tent to packaged electronics in a wheelbarrow to eyeshadow pallets on the bare concrete. 

Four workers from the Department of Public Works and a police officer chat on the corner of 16th and Mission streets. Despite a ban on Mission Street vending, the workers don’t bother the vendors.

Street vendors and shoppers gather on a busy sidewalk lined with tables, food stands, and assorted goods in an urban setting.
5/3/25 Mission Street between 16th and 15th streets. Passersby check out Paula Saulsby’s goods. Photo by Abigail Van Neely.

On 15th Street near Mission Street, Paula Saulsby is set up in the same spot she’s had for the last four years, selling jewelry, baseball cards, and vintage men’s magazines — to entice clientele, she jokes. 

Saulsby, 75, has worked as an in-home supportive service provider for over a decade, and is a member of SEIU, one of the largest unions for home care workers. She’s lived in San Francisco since she was two years old.  

The money she makes as a vendor is nice, she says, but she also got a permit to sell because “It’s fun, I like it, and I meet people from everywhere, everywhere, and that’s wonderful too.” 

A person wearing a patterned hat, orange sunglasses, blue gloves, and a floral shirt holds a small stuffed bear next to their face, standing in front of a dark background.
Paula Saulsby holds up a stuffed animal for sale. Photo by Abigail Van Neely on May 3, 2025.
Three people stand at a small sidewalk table with various items for sale, set up against a black building exterior.
Paula Saulsby speaks to buyers on May 3, 2025. Photo by Abigail Van Neely.

Some buyers are homeless. Some have two homes. Some are business owners. Some are entertainers. 

On Saturday afternoon, many do not speak English. They purchase children’s toys, compliment a sweatshirt that reads “I am a happy person who thinks pretty thoughts,” and flip through the “Busty Ladies” magazine. 

At first glance, Saulsby seems aloof in her sunglasses, bucket hat, and blue medical gloves. Given time, she’ll banter with anyone, offering deals and asking about people’s lives, even a man who stumbles up with a drink in hand and another in his tote bag. 

A group of people a few feet away from Saulsby are lighting a pipe, and the vendor says she thinks Mayor Daniel Lurie is “moving in the right direction” in his efforts to remove drugs from the streets.

Her comments on the issue, though, remain strictly courteous: “I don’t like it because I don’t like a person to be ill.” 

Several people sit and stand on a city sidewalk next to a brick building, surrounded by bags and personal belongings. Trees line the street in the background.
15th Street near Mission Street on May 3, 2025. Photo by Abigail Van Neely.
A variety of miscellaneous items in boxes and containers are displayed on a sidewalk, including books, toys, papers, a striped blanket, and a plush bear in a pirate hat.
Paula Saulsby’s goods on May 3, 2025. Photo by Abigail Van Neely.
Assorted sports trading cards, jewelry, and small items are spread out on a table, including a deck of cards, keys, and plastic containers.
Paula Saulsby’s goods on May 3, 2025. Photo by Abigail Van Neely.
People walk on a tree-lined sidewalk next to parked cars and buildings on a sunny day in an urban neighborhood.
5/3/25 15th Street. Photo by Abigail Van Neely.
A sidewalk scene with people sitting under a canopy next to a blue tarp tent, with more people standing and trees lining the street in the background.
Street vendors between 15th and 16th Street on May 3, 2025. Photo by Abigail Van Neely.
A narrow city alley bordered by yellow and beige buildings, with barricades, trash bins, and a closed taqueria on the right.
5/3/25 Weise Street. Photo by Abigail Van Neely.
Sunlight filters through green leaves and purple wisteria flowers hanging from a vine.
5/3/25 Julian Avenue. Photo by Abigail Van Neely.

Follow Us

I'm covering criminal justice and public health. I live in San Francisco with my cat, Sally Carrera, but I'll always be a New Yorker. (Yes, the shelter named my cat after the Porsche from the animated movie Cars.)

Join the Conversation

7 Comments

  1. I love when a transplant from NY tells us that we should allow criminals to sell stolen goods openly on the street because two illegal immigrants, who have been in this country for over 40 years and still cant speak English, say it’s OK.

    +2
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
  2. Glad to see them trying to support themselves .
    What about the majority of people who hang out on the sidewalks all day doing nothing, getting high , getting drunk, and not working?

    Those persons need to get off their butt and get working .

    The city should be most concerned about that section of society .

    They should be required to get off the street and get ajob .
    May be no job inSF , but there a hundreds of thousandsof jobs elsewhere in this country .

    Need to go and live where the jobs are .

    Welcome to America .

    Would rather see the city spending taxpayer money to pay for a ticket and get these people relocated to a place where they can work .

    Why the taxpayer needs to pay to support them to stay here where there are no jobs is stupid.

    +1
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
  3. I just wanted to comment on what I have witnessed firsthand. I’m not saying that the lady written about is doing this because I don’t know. However what I do know is that the majority of these street vendors are selling stolen merchandise that either they or someone else bought from the civic center area from homeless or drug users. During the day but mostly at night after 12am hordes of people flock around the area trying to sell what they stole from stores and/or from breaking into cars.

    0
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
  4. now that is the real of 16th street. been there for 40 years and knows it was way worst. not afraid of people just cus they re on drugs. recent transplants are just scared of anything that they re not used too. cant even walk down the street and look people in the eye or say hello. they should put these two in charge of community ambassadors.

    0
    -1
    votes. Sign in to vote
Leave a comment
Please keep your comments short and civil. Do not leave multiple comments under multiple names on one article. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *