steel bollards blocking off a street, between buildings
The Capp Street steel bollards on 22nd and Capp. Photo by Lingzi Chen, taken May 12, 2023.

Leer en español

Steel bollards meant to discourage johns from cruising up and down Capp Street are being installed by the city this week, replacing the concrete barriers that have sat on the street for months.

Public Works staff were at intersections from 18th to 22nd on Capp this morning, slicing into concrete and installing the 30-inch-tall yellow steel barriers. 

Work proceeded in stages: At 21st and Capp, crews quickly installed the posts in trenches previously dug out and filled in with concrete; that work was done in less than 90 minutes.

At 18th and Capp, a backhoe dug out a long trench across the street and crews padded down the ground. Concrete will be poured into that trench and the barriers installed sometime next week, according to a crew member. 

work crew standing around steel bollards being installed on the street
Public Works crew members on 21st and Capp during today’s installation. Photo by Lingzi Chen, taken May 12, 2023.
backhoe next to a trench in the street
A backhoe digging a trench at 18th and Capp, where concrete will be poured in and new steel posts installed. Photo by Lingzi Chen, taken May 12, 2023.

Work began Monday, according to an Municipal Transportation Agency spokesperson, with crews marking out the sites to avoid hitting underground pipes or wires. The entire installation up and down Capp Street should be finished next week.

The bollards are the latest iteration in an attempt by the city to crack down on johns who have historically sought sex on Capp Street: In February, the city installed “Road Closed” signs along the street; those were routinely pushed aside or driven over by drivers.

Just a week later, they were replaced by large “k-rail” concrete barriers, impenetrable to drivers but also to the Fire Department, which raised concerns that they would prevent emergency access. They were also deemed unsightly by neighbors and frequently covered in graffiti.

The steel bollards were the agreed-upon solution by the city: They are padlocked at the bottom and can be turned down in emergencies. 

The bollards only block off access to one side of Capp Street per block, allowing cars to enter on the other side. The blocked portions are the southside entrance on 18th and Capp, and the northside entrances of 20th and Capp, 21st and Capp, and 22nd and Capp.

The concrete barriers that will be replaced by the steel bollards being installed this week. Photo by Lingzi Chen, taken May 12, 2023.

The concrete barriers were, for their part, seemingly successful at deterring sex work on Capp Street itself. Residents, workers, and business owners along the street said in April that they no longer saw as many sex workers, though some said they had simply moved a few blocks away. 

Regulars on Capp Street added that the street itself was much more idyllic without car traffic, similar to Shotwell and 20th streets nearby, two of the city’s so-called “Slow Streets” where through traffic is discouraged by plastic posts. 

More Capp Street Coverage

Stephen Chun, a spokesperson for the MTA, said that Capp Street should not be considered a “Slow Street,” however. Though the bollards will remain up and will only be turned down for emergency use, the bollards are meant to be a crime deterrent, he said, not a traffic solution.

“It’s not a permanent street closure,” he said. “These bollards are not meant to in any way have the official jurisdiction that it is a street closure.”

backhoe next to a trench in the street between buildings
A backhoe digging a trench at 18th and Capp, where concrete will be poured in and new steel posts installed. Photo by Lingzi Chen, taken May 12, 2023.
backhoe next to a trench in the street
A backhoe digging a trench at 18th and Capp, where concrete will be poured in and new steel posts installed. Photo by Lingzi Chen, taken May 12, 2023.

Follow Us

Joe was born in Sweden, where half of his family received asylum after fleeing Pinochet, and spent his early childhood in Chile; he moved to Oakland when he was eight. He attended Stanford University for political science and worked at Mission Local as a reporter after graduating. He then spent time in advocacy as a partner for the strategic communications firm The Worker Agency. He rejoined Mission Local as an editor in 2023.

Join the Conversation

13 Comments

  1. I lived on Capp St between 18th and 19th years ago, and everyone in our building had a rapport with the sex workers on the block. I don’t remember many break-ins, vandalism or violent episodes back then. Hope this traffic calming method works.

    0
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
  2. As someone who lives on Capp, the street barriers (and now the bollards to hopefully) have made a tremendous difference in the quality of life for my family and I, as well as my neighbors on the block. HUGE difference! Not only is the non stop traffic and party from cruising johns gone, but other crime on Capp is down too. Just ask Mission Station PD (they’ll confirm it): other types of crimes like assault, robbery and home invasion also decreased with the installation of the barriers and the increased police enforcement in the area.

    0
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
  3. My thought is that the families that live on those blocks are happy the danger of drug addicts hanging out in front of their homes has decreased

    0
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
  4. Once again, this is not “anti-sex work” This is about a red light district (insane traffic, crime, violence, nasty garbage) versus a residential street.

    0
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
  5. “At 18th and Capp, a backhoe dug out a long trench across the street and crews padded down the ground. ” Usually in construction ground is tamped or packed. Padded is usually associated with additional cushioning, or clothing (shoulder pads, jackets etc).

    0
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. In the sense that they were prepping the concrete pad, it works. Generally speaking, the substrate for a road is “compacted” before it is topped.

      0
      0
      votes. Sign in to vote
  6. Great article, but, IMO, the title seems inflammatory. Perhaps is just my perception as a ESL speaker?

    0
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
  7. It’s so much safer on Capp St now that car traffic has been calmed. Why can’t we get this same type of protection on the “Slow Streets” in SF too? Or get some steel bollards on Valencia to protect the bike lanes? The city cares more about stopping sex workers than it does about keeping it’s citizens safe from cars.

    0
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
    1. Do you really want to be cycling at 20mph and, one false move, one defect in the pavement, you’ll go hurtling into a steel pole?

      0
      0
      votes. Sign in to vote
      1. Slow down. I always make sure to pull the truck into a 4-way stop intersection slowly to make sure that bicyclists respect their stop signs. I do that every time with eye contact.

        Also, the bollards look like little hard dicks. They should be painted hot pink ASAP.

        Also, the oce bucket, hostess bar Trebol is on 22nd and Capp, so not too far to go for fun.

        0
        0
        votes. Sign in to vote
  8. “These bollards are not meant to in any way have the official jurisdiction that it is a street closure.”

    I’d love for ML to do some follow up on this: they’ve closed the street (more definitively than any non-alley/non-park street in SF that I’m aware of?), so why can’t they say “it’s a street closure”? I assume there’s a policy reason for it, but I can’t imagine what it is?

    0
    0
    votes. Sign in to vote
Leave a comment
Please keep your comments short and civil. Do not leave multiple comments under multiple names on one article. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and very easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *