Malia Cohen served on the Board of Supervisors for eight years beginning in 2011. She was the president of the board, and now she's the president of the Police Commission. Photo by Lola M. Chavez

Malia Cohen, a former San Francisco supervisor, was elected president of the San Francisco Police Commission on Wednesday. 

The vote of the five sitting commissioners was unanimous. In the same vote, the commission elected Commissioner Cindy Elias to serve as vice president of the commission.

The election of Cohen comes after Damali Taylor, who led the commission as vice president since spring 2020, following the resignation of Bob Hirsch, announced her resignation days before Christmas. Her resignation came shortly after she canceled a meeting despite a quorum of commissioners being available. 

Cohen scolded Taylor for that misstep. “It makes us look bad as a body,” Cohen said during a meeting on Dec. 16. “There were four members able to meet, and we didn’t meet.” 

Now, weeks later, Cohen has assumed the leadership position. She is the newest member of the commission, having joined in August — nominated by Mayor London Breed and unanimously approved by the Board of Supervisors. In addition to her new duties, she sits on the state Board of Equalization, a body that oversees tax administration in California. 

Following the vote on Wednesday, Cohen said she was “excited to be taking the helm and taking it with Cindy.” She said the scene Wednesday of Trump supporters storming the Capitol in Washington D.C. only underscored the “need for good strong leadership — transparent leadership.”  

Cohen served as a member of the Board of Supervisors from 2011 to 2019, and was the president of the board for six months beginning in June, 2018. During her tenure as supervisor, she authored a successful 2016 ballot measure that strengthened the powers of the Department of Police Accountability. She also authored a law that requires the police department to release quarterly statistics on stops, searches and use of force.  

Shortly after her second term as supervisor expired in January 2019, Cohen was elected to the State Board of Equalization. 

The Police Commission’s leadership roles are largely ceremonial — although the commission president is in charge of scheduling agenda items and generally sets the tone and pace of meetings. 

And Cohen wasted no time in suggesting changes on Wednesday. She made a recommendation, which will be discussed at a later date, that a 30-minute public comment session be held at the beginning of each meeting. General public comment is usually held at the end. 

“I do believe it’s unfair for people to wait hours to give public comment,” she said. 

Other commissioners seemed happy — even relieved — that Cohen will be leading the commission. 

Congratulating Cohen, Commissioner John Hamasaki said: “It’s a good sign that we’re returning the commission to acting on behalf of the city and its people.” 

Follow Us

Julian grew up in the East Bay and moved to San Francisco in 2014. Before joining Mission Local, he wrote for the East Bay Express, the SF Bay Guardian, and the San Francisco Business Times.

Join the Conversation


Please keep your comments short and civil. Do not leave multiple comments under multiple names on one article. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and very easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. isn’t Cohen’s service on this board a violation of the law?

    Gov. Code, sec. 15603.
    The annual salary of each member of the State Board of Equalization representing one of the equalization districts of the state is provided for by Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 11550) of Part 1. The member shall devote his or her entire time to the services of the state in performing the duties imposed upon the board and its members by the Constitution and statutes of this state.

  2. Where are all the bright minds and fresh faces ? Are we stuck recycling the same politicians ?

    Maybe the good folks at Mission Local can put forth someone of high intelligence and moral turpitude to be a part of the Police Commission.

    Julian Mark!! Are you up to the task ?? Don’t just write about it. Be a part of it.

  3. Maybe not many care that Malia Cohen went from one government job to another after being termed out, and appears to now be setting the table for her return to the action after sitting out a year. Is it just a coincidence?

    1. She’ll fire a few cops for some administrative violation so that she can say she held the cops “accountable” and then use that to propel herself past other rivals when running for office (again).

  4. Campers!

    At a Board of Supervisors meeting to approve a building’s construction in 2017, Malia Cohen said the most asinine comment and had to recuse herself from the vote at the end. the reason she had to recuse herself was that she was implying that somebody could bribe her, and she said it with a serious face. We already have enough corrupt politicians and corrupt nonprofit organizations taking millions a year, the people don’t need Malia Cohen in office, they need her to hang it up. Unfortunately they’ll probably vote for her based on race alone, which if you think about it is racist in itself.

    Look it up: OceanWide Center @ 50 First Street & 512 Mission Street at the board of supervisors vote, Malia Cohen recused herself before voting for *joking that she could be bribed with a Mercedes Benz*

    Go Warriors!