Stacey Milbern urged Gov. Gavin Newsom to reject hospital and nursing homes' request for legal indemnification from COVID-related suits. Without checks and balances on such facilities she said, 'disabled people of color are left alone in a system that already doesn’t care about us.'

Stacey Milbern took a deep drag off her ventilator. For her, it’s not a last-ditch means of staving off COVID-19, but an everyday requirement. 

“Doctors,” she says, “take an oath to treat all patients equally. Yet we know this is not the case.” 

Milbern joined a handful of disabled people and advocates in a Wednesday morning virtual press conference organized by Senior and Disability Action. The speakers described Gov. Gavin Newsom as “poised” to approve a pending request from powerful hospital and assisted living lobbying groups to provide these facilities with broad immunity from civil and even criminal liability during the COVID-19 pandemic. 

They urged him to not do this.  

If the governor were to grant this sweeping request, Milbern and others said it would have disastrous consequences for people like them. It would also provide a potential windfall for hospitals and nursing facilities no longer facing legal repercussions for the predictable results of placing contagious COVID-19 patients alongside society’s most vulnerable individuals.  

“In an ideal world, a skilled nursing facility would treat me well. But, instead of lobbying to improve care, they’re lobbying for immunity if they kill COVID patients like me,” said Ira X Armstrong. 

Armstrong, a Berkeley resident, has ostensibly beaten coronavirus, but only after weeks of debilitating pain and weakness that resulted in persistent lung damage. 

“I really don’t know where to go,” Armstrong continued. “If I go to a hospital, I may not come out.”

Liability Protection Coalit… by Joe Eskenazi on Scribd

Mike Dark, the staff attorney at the San Francisco-based California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform last week painted a disturbing picture for Mission Local. He noted that, outside of particularly hard-hit parts of New York, acute hospitals are reeling, not from a crush of sick COVID patients — not yet, thankfully — but the inability to do cash-generating elective surgeries. 

Skilled nursing facilities and assisted living facilities, he continued, could reap four times as much compensation from a COVID patient as an average Medi-Cal patient. But for the obvious danger and likely legal fallout, shunting COVID patients into nursing facilities could be a profitable enterprise for all involved. 

The broad gift of legal immunity would solve that problem. For the institutions, at least. 

“Under the immunity proposal that Gov. Newsom is considering, a nursing home could recklessly and dangerously put a resident at risk — by not giving them necessary care, by knowingly ignoring residents who are desperately sick, and they could not be sued,” Dark said today. 

“That also means that nothing is left to discourage them from putting residents in danger.”

Mission Local’s messages for Gov. Newsom’s office have not yet been returned. 

“Remember, Governor: If you live long enough, you’ll get old yourself,” said Elizabeth Grigsby, a disabled woman and former board and care facility resident. “When you need someone to take care of you, you might be in the same boat. Just because you’re young and vital now, it’s not gonna last forever.” 

Hello, everyone! If you can help, we could sure use the money.

Follow Us

Managing Editor/Columnist. Joe was born in San Francisco, raised in the Bay Area, and attended U.C. Berkeley. He never left.

“Your humble narrator” was a writer and columnist for SF Weekly from 2007 to 2015, and a senior editor at San Francisco Magazine from 2015 to 2017. You may also have read his work in the Guardian (U.S. and U.K.); San Francisco Public Press; San Francisco Chronicle; San Francisco Examiner; Dallas Morning News; and elsewhere.

He resides in the Excelsior with his wife and three (!) kids, 4.3 miles from his birthplace and 5,474 from hers.

The Northern California branch of the Society of Professional Journalists named Eskenazi the 2019 Journalist of the Year.

Join the Conversation


  1. The letter requesting immunity ends with a justicifation:
    “This request is made with the deep understanding that every care provider is doing all they can to protect all Californians during this unprecedented crisis.”

    This blog quotes Ms. Milbern, disabled and presumably under medical care, with:
    “..disabled people of color are left alone in a system that already doesn’t care about us….Doctors take an oath to treat all patients equally. Yet we know this is not the case.”

    Those statements can’t both be true. So with no supporting data accompanying either, a opinion using only the information presented here boils down to which do you believe more based only on personal ideology.

    votes. Sign in to vote
  2. Again and again, Mission Local reporters, especially Joe E., show how large or abstract issues impact our many communities.
    The practicality of their writing still seems lost on some on the [ virtual ] 2nd floor at City Hall.

    votes. Sign in to vote
Leave a comment
Please keep your comments short and civil. Do not leave multiple comments under multiple names on one article. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and very easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *