Photograph courtesy of Ricardo Liberato.

En Español

A $100,000 check went up in smoke last week in a spiritual ceremony at the offices of the Center for Young Women’s Development, a San Francisco nonprofit that serves at-risk women.

With the ritual of burning sage and copal to cleanse and energize, the center joined other organizations around the country in refusing large donations from the Craigslist Charitable Fund on the grounds that the website hasn’t done enough to eradicate sex trafficking.

Craigslist shut down its adult services section last week, after being pressured by 17 state attorneys general and receiving a torrent of bad publicity, but that failed to satisfy the center.

“Getting that money was stressful and difficult,” said Marlene Sanchez, director of the Center for Young Women’s Development. “I didn’t know getting money would be so damn difficult.”

Craigslist strategically targeted her organization, Sanchez said, in an effort to improve its image.

“When I get a grant, it’s a partnership. Someone says, ‘We believe in your work and we want to support it.’ It was clear that with Craigslist, that wasn’t the case. They didn’t really know who we were or what we do.”

Sanchez asked Jim Buckmaster, Craigslist’s CEO, if the donation meant a sincere commitment, and if Craigslist wanted to work with her organization. He seemed annoyed by her questions, she said. Other people would have been ecstatic to receive the money, he told her.

Buckmaster and others at Craigslist could not be reached for comment.

It was difficult for Sanchez to reject the money, but she said it was more important for her organization to stand by its principles, and that taking the money would damage their long-standing relationships with other human rights groups.

Earlier this year, Minneapolis-based Advocates for Human Rights and the Center for Health and Gender Equity in Washington D.C. each returned a $25,000 check to the Craigslist Charitable Fund.

“When their profits are coming from the exploitation of children and women, to turn around and donate proceeds to organizations like ours was inappropriate,” said Robin Phillips, executive director of Advocates for Human Rights.

Craigslist made more than $30 million on sex ads this year, and was on track to make $44 million in 2010 before removing adult services last week, according to a report by the AIM Group.

When she received the donation in May, Robin Phillips called Craigslist numerous times and sent the company a letter that recommended the site discontinue adult services.

No one responded to Phillips’ calls and letter, but she hopes that pressure from organizations like hers influenced the company’s decision.

Serra Sippel, president of the Center for Health and Gender Equity, was also bewildered when she received an unsolicited check. She searched for information about the Craigslist Charitable Fund, but didn’t find any answers.

“Who are they funding? Why are they funding them? What is their overall mission?” she wondered. “I didn’t get a response and couldn’t find information online, so I decided to return the check with recommendations.”

Sippel’s recommendations, published in the Huffington Post, ask Craigslist for more transparency and advise the company to establish an advisory council of experts in sex work and human trafficking.

Sanchez said that as the $100,000 check burned to ashes in the courtyard of her office, she asked her ancestors for guidance. “Sometimes when things are hard, we are going on the right path. What it meant to stand firm on what we believe in is a big deal for us.”

Within two hours of burning the check, Sanchez found out that the Center for Young Women’s Development advanced to the next stage in competition for a large grant.

“The $100,000 will be here today and gone tomorrow, but it doesn’t matter if we’re not building relationships.”

Follow Us

Walking in the streets of the Mission takes Lauren back to the streets of South America. Up until now, she’s known the Mission through its bars and restaurants; now it’s the buzz on Mission Street that attracts her. She loves listening to the Spanish in the streets.

Join the Conversation

5 Comments

  1. It’s interesting that CL, the once-alternative to the mainstream, is so mainstream now that his “generosity” has to be denied. He might not appear to be a multi-millionaire elitist, but if CL’s projected revenue from sex ads alone is $74m in 2009/10, then certainly Mr. Newmark will accrue part of that stash.

    People still consider Mr. Newmark/CL alternative, but he/it is not.

  2. CL is damned if they do, damned if they don’t. I heard a long time ago that they had been attempting to give the $$ made from the adult services ads to harm reduction agencies, and that they were sometimes met with rejection like the above. They are publicly scolded for profiting from sex ads, but how much of those profits have they really kept, and how much has been given away? Or rather, how much have they *tried* to give away?? From what I understand, this is not a new “spin control” after the closure of adult services, but rather, something they have been trying to do with the money raised off those ads since having to institute fees in an effort to curb underage sex ads.

  3. I can’t believe the corruption of people today…the immorality of the people, corruption in government. Signs of the times….

    Either we turn back to Biblical law/principles, or the country will never recover from this pagan, Babylonian culture we now live in… 2Chronicles 7:14

Leave a comment
Please keep your comments short and civil. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and very easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published.