For Carlos Rodriguez, a self-declared undocumented immigrant, tax day isn’t about refunds or money he’ll have to pay to the government. It’s about establishing a record.
“I don’t have any reason to hide,” he said on a recent evening, while waiting along with a handful of other immigrants, for his appointment at a free tax clinic on Mission Street.
Tax preparers throughout the Mission District, say that tax filers like Rodriguez are increasing, despite the recession. They are walking, W-2s in hand, into storefronts along Mission Street advertising tax prep services in Spanish or the handful of free clinics run out of non-profits and community centers on evenings and weekends.
Such tax services in the Mission rival taquerias for the highest number of storefronts and have become ubiquitous in most heavily Latino communities as millions of undocumented immigrants file tax returns each year, even without collecting the benefits for which they pay.
For ten years, Rodriguez, a roofer who is now unemployed, has diligently declared his income to the Internal Revenue Service so that he can prove his tenure in the country if there is immigration reform and that he—like a legal resident—has contributed to government coffers.
Paying income taxes is the law for anyone who earns wages in the United States. Yet undocumented immigrants face special challenges in filing a return.
To work legally in the country, an employee needs a valid social security number. But undocumented workers are ineligible for one.
That leads many undocumented workers to make up social security numbers or acquire somebody else’s number, said Francine Lipman, a professor of tax law at Chapman University in Los Angeles.
Since 1996, the IRS has issued Individual Taxpayer Identification Numbers, or ITINs, which has reduced the confusion this creates, she added. The nine-digit codes are issued to anyone ineligible for a social security number and serve as a unique identifier for the purpose of paying taxes.
ITINs can also be used for other things, like opening bank accounts or getting a car loan. But they do not give a person the right to work legally in the country.
“The system is oxymoronic,” said Lipman. “The tax return has an inconsistency in that the W-2s don’t match the ITIN.”
That inconsistency has not diminished their popularity.
Peter Gomez, a tax preparer who works out of the back of a travel agency on Mission Street, said that every Saturday people walk in off the street after spotting a folding sign he puts out on the sidewalk: “Federal & State Income Tax Service / se habla español.” He said that many clients have a similar request: “Quiero mi ITIN.”
Between 1996 and 2007, the last year of available data, the IRS issued 12.5 million ITINs nationally. And in 2007, more than 2 million tax returns were filed with them. The Pew Hispanic Center estimated that there were 8.3 million undocumented workers in the United States in 2008.
The IRS does not ask about immigration status when taxpayers apply for an ITIN, says Jesse Weller, a spokesperson for the agency, so there are no statistics on how many people using them are undocumented.
But Lipman said there is only one likely explanation for the rapid growth of tax returns with ITINs in recent years: more undocumented workers are using them to file.
For many undocumented workers, she added, there’s a more immediate upside to filing taxes than staying right by the government in case there is immigration reform. Many lower-income workers are eligible for refunds.
Taxpayers who file with an ITIN do not receive social security benefits or the earned income tax credit. But they are eligible for the child tax credit, said Lipman. And if they have dependents in Canada or Mexico, they can claim those, too.
This year, undocumented immigrants who are married to legal residents are also eligible for the Making Work Pays tax credit. The stimulus measure gives $800 to a married couple filing jointly, as long as either the husband or the wife has a valid social security number, said Lipman.
These benefits have made ITINs an attractive option for Evelyn Herrera’s more than 1,000 clients, many of whom are Mexican nationals. The accountant, who works out of an office cramped with desks on 24th Street, says that roughly half of her clients use ITINs. Usually, she said, they are the first to complete their returns.
“They want to pay taxes and comply with the law,” she said.
Still, some neighborhood tax professionals said that there are plenty of undocumented immigrants who are afraid of paying taxes or choose not to.
Carlos Loucel, who runs an accounting business near 16th and Mission Streets, said he still hears lots of undocumented workers give excuses for not paying. Some, he added, have no intention of becoming legal residents. Others are afraid to give the government information about their whereabouts.
The IRS’s Weller said that the agency is prohibited by law from sharing taxpayer information with other government agencies, including Homeland Security, except in cases involving terrorism or fraud.
That assurance brought Manuel Lozano and his brother, Alberto, to Liberty Tax Services on 24th Street on a recent afternoon. The siblings sat in a tidy waiting area across from a wall where dozens of IRS forms—in English and Spanish—were neatly arrayed for clients.
Lozano says he started going to Liberty because it is clean and the staff are professional. His first tax preparer in the Mission lost his birth certificate when he was applying for an ITIN.
Asked why he was filing taxes, the restaurant worker said that he and his brother had done so ever since they came to the United States four years ago from Guanajuato, Mexico. “If you’re here, I believe you should follow the rules,” he said.
I wish a real NATIVE AMERICAN could write something about this!!!! !!!!THIS IS A NATION OF IMMIGRANTS!!!!
i love these debates. doubt many of you anti immigrant jack holes know that the number one group of immigrant based population in america is german. number two, irish. send them all home and i’ll happily support the deportation of anyone with darker skin.
Whats next,shoplifters get Amnesty,a big fat refund if they pay taxes on the items they stole using a fake SS# & an ITIN ?
Throw all the Bums out of Washington who allow such blatant theft of taxpayers money ! No wonder the USA is going bankrupt while these Foreign Nationals are laughing at our stupidity all the way to the bank.
Dear Concerned Citizens,
The reason that California is in fiscal trouble is that Californians apparently prefer to not pay any taxes, then blame the inevitable bankruptcy on poor people. If we replaced every California skinflint with a Mexican, the state might be in better shape. At least the immigrants take work for the crappy wages you and your neighbors pay, and are happy to pay their taxes, unlike those of you who prefer to enjoy the fruits of society but play the parts of eternally complaining victims. For you, queue the really tiny violin music.
But if you prefer to not subsidize immigration I’d suggest you stop buying restaurant food, getting fast-food, taking your laundry out, getting your cars washed, or enjoying half a hundred services that would cost twice as much if Americans were doing the work. Go ahead (if you can). Or, you may focus on stopping those people who hire and exploit undocumented workers and end up driving everyone’s wages down as a result. I might even support that one myself. Just shut up about the “illegals”. I’m deadly sick of resentful cranks finding fault with people working and feeding families the best way they can. Selfish law breakers my a**. More like selfless parents, sons, and daughters, working their fingers to the bone to raise families and add value to the economy.
If you were in their shoes, you would rush at the same opportunity — unless you were as irresponsible as you are crass.
Yes, you may kiss my professionally employed, second generation Italian-American behind. My kind may be assimilated, but I’ve heard enough stories at my grandparents’ knees to know attitudes like yours for what they represent. Your opinions are neither new, nor true, nor deserving of any further consideration.
Tony – your statement is really ignorant. The vast majority of illegal immigrants get more in refunds than they pay in taxes. And that includes contributions to SS and Medicare. God help us taxpayers if illegal immigrants get amnesty because low income workers get much, much more in benefits from SS than they ever put in. Just another form of wealth redistribution (welfare). Low income workers, legal or illegal, are a huge burden to society because they do NOT pay their way. Think someone earning $30k a year is paying anything in taxes to fully fund the $9k per child for public education or the free/subsidized healthcare, or free lunches or food stamps? The answer is NO! The millions of low paid illegal immigrants in CA who are using these services are one huge reason CA is in fiscal trouble.
Kat: This is a complicated topic and there was an excellent piece in the New York Times magazine in 2006 looking at the economic side of the cost/benefit equation of undocumented immigration. It’s worth a read. The Immigration Equation
By ROGER LOWENSTEIN. Here is a link and hope that it still works. Best, Lydia Chavez, ME http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9901E6DE1330F93AA35754C0A9609C8B63
Better to comply with some laws than none at all. And everyone else is probably better off given the amount of money they contribute in taxes but don’t get back in social security, etc.
“They want to pay taxes and comply with the law,” she said.
The law that they agree to, or like, not the law that prohibits them from being here to begin with. That LAW they just assume ignore for their own selfish reasons.