We’re producing maps with an undergraduate mapping class at UC Berkeley and would like your help in crowdsourcing. If you see anything we’ve missed, or any problems or issues, please comment. See the full map here.
Crowdsourcing: Dogs vs. Babies
See the full map here.
Filed under: Front Page, Maps - Printable to Guide You
You included scale, which is cool– although it’s not in metric, small typographic face indicating faint disappointment. But a compass rose or some other indication of which way north is would be a good idea.
Your map is sideways, which wouldn’t be a big deal (though always annoys me), but you completely left out the directional compass. If you ask any decent cartographer, they’ll tell you that without the compass, scale line, and legend, this is just a picture (all 3 required).
Also, you don’t need to explain the color differentiation in the summary. That info should be clear in the legend. If it’s not, then your legend has problems.
Finally, is this map providing any insight? Not really. You’re comparing number of babies to locations of dog stores. These two sets of data are completely unrelated, and don’t have any effect on each other. I’m actually perplexed. Why not make a map comparing the number of new cars vs. locations of donut shops?
Keep trying…
This map reeks of “Gangs and Cupcakes” vanity. In case you missed it: http://missionlocal.org/2011/03/gangs-and-cupcakes/
But I will say that “vs.” in the title is a lot funnier. I was hoping to see a map of where babies have been eaten by dogs. Eaten sideways, that is.
Stephan, Michael, Aaron, Thank you–we will definitely consider all of these points and will add to the map. And Aaron, it’s clear you don’t like the map, but at least you made me laugh. lc