Two theaters within two blocks of each other on Mission Street share some striking similarities. Both were built after the 1906 earthquake spurred a construction rush along Mission. Both were modernized with New Deal-era loans during the 1930s, adding ornate neon signs, deluxe interiors, and huge facades.
Now, more than a century after they first opened, the Tower theater at 2465 Mission, and the old Cine Latino theater at 2555 Mission — both owned by Vera Cort — face very different futures.
The Tower is being renovated and will reopen as a site for the City College of San Francisco’s film school and movie theater.
In contrast, Cine Latino has been reduced to its beams — a demolition of the front facade that the San Francisco Planning Department says was illegal — destroying the iconic neon sphinx that rested atop the ornate marquee. The department has ordered Cort to stop all work on the building and the demolition that left the facade looking like an undistinguished hulk is now being investigated by the City Attorney’s office.
Cort and her architect argue that the demolition occurred before the city designated the building as historic, while the city says the scope of work on site went beyond what was allowed by Cort’s permit.
Meanwhile, down the street at the Tower, between 20th and 21st Streets, the marquee barely hangs on. The metallic skin that covers the vertical sign is partly gone, and only the faint outline of two letters — E and R — remain.
That, says Rodrigo Santos, a structural engineer and former trustee on the board of City College, will soon change as he moves ahead with plans to fully renovate the theater.
It will be the fourth iteration of the theater since it first opened in April 1912 with 1,000 seats. Back then, it was known as The Majestic, and its developer was Mary Heffernan, an “extensive real estate owner,” the San Francisco Chronicle wrote in 1913.
The façade first changed during the New Deal modernization of Mission Street, and again in 1942 when the mural, which depicts the founding of California and the industries of San Francisco, was added to the interior. That year, the Majestic also changed its name to The Tower.
The blueprint for the project includes a plan to restore the neon lettering and the mural.
Santos says the mural is the most “crucial element” of the redesign, because its restoration must be complete before the construction of the interior and exterior proceeds.
“We were a little surprised at the emphasis that Planning placed on the restoration of this mural,” said Santos, a dapper, energetic man, during a tour of the site. “But at the same time, we embraced it.”
He’s in the process of hiring an artist, who must be approved by the Planning Department’s Historic Preservation team.
Santos, a trained structural engineer who was part of the restoration team responsible for renovating the Mission Theater, is accustomed to the slow pace of historic renovation. Describing his interactions with planning staff as “painful” but productive, Santos said that his plan has been well received. “We submitted drawings and got a very enthusiastic response,” he said. “They were happy it wasn’t another brewery. ”
“Historic preservation is challenging,” he added. “It’s hard to lengthen the lifespan of an old building without modification.”
Still, he sees the benefit in maintaining the historic elements of the building.
No date has been set for the opening of the film school. Still, Santos — who says he’s the sole investor in the space — is clear on the reason he’s invested so much in the project: his love of film.
“In old days, you had to be wealthy to be involved with filmmaking,” he said. “The school (City College) is back on track with enrollment. There are a tremendous number of students who will be able to take advantage of a new film school.”
Santos, who has been renovating the building with Cort’s agreement, is in talks with her to purchase it. He declined to state a figure, but expects the deal to go through sometime this year.
The future is less rosy for the former Cine Latino theater. It stands stripped to its steel frame, its lengthy vertical marquee illegally demolished by Cort sometime after 2011, according to city planning records. In 2012, Cort said it would become a gym and a branch of Poets and Busboys, a salon-like restaurant space.
Those plans are on hold as the Mission’s second-oldest theater (the oldest is the Victoria Theater) clears up a conflict with the Planning Department on the demolition of the facade.
Its history reaches back to 1906, when Joseph Bauer, the owner, purchased the lot with a $5 gold piece from George Crim, the “richest miser in California,” according to Bauer’s unpublished memoirs — and a man who had vast real estate holdings in the Mission District.
Bauer writes in his memoirs that the first theater was a tent before becoming the Wigwam Theater, a “class A steel frame building,” in 1911. Inside, viewers watched movies, vaudeville and sometimes burlesque theater. Bauer notes proudly in his memoirs that his theatre was the only “girl show” in San Francisco from 1922 to 1925.
Bauer sold the Wigwam to the Nassar Brothers in the mid-1920s. They changed the name to the New Rialto and hired the architect Fernand Frederic Amandes, famed for his work designing glamorous movie houses throughout the state, to modernize the building in the Streamline Moderne style that characterized Mission Street during the Depression. Curvilinear lines, ornate Art Deco features and neon signage distinguished that style.
The name of the theater changed twice more. In 1947, it became the Crown and, in 1978, the Cine Latino. The theater ceased operations in 1988.
Charles Hemminger, Cort’s architect, who specializes in adaptive re-use renovations, said the old theater, which has been empty for 30 years, was beyond help. The concrete had completely deteriorated, he said, a fact that was only discovered after construction work began.
Hemminger also said that the aging building wasn’t considered historic in 2003 when the permit for work was granted.
However, Gini Simi, communications manager for San Francisco’s Planning Department, said the permit only covered an alteration, and did “not include demolition of the theater’s façade.”
Furthermore, Simi said that the demolition took place after 2010 when the property was evaluated and listed as a historic resource eligible for inclusion on the California Register of Historical Resources.
Hemminger, in an email, stated that he couldn’t recall exactly when the demolition commenced, but did say that he believed that the “majority” of it took place between 2011 and 2012, at least one year after the building was listed as a historic.
The loss of the marquee has not gone unnoticed by the neighborhood but, like the project planners, no one is really sure when it happened.
Joanna Sacks, who lives on 21st Street, has noticed its absence; she remembers the grand marquee that soared above the street. She thinks the facade should have been preserved. “We live in the shadow of the Miracle Mile,” she said. “I’ve seen pictures of people dressed up to go shopping on the Mission. The sign was a part of the Mission’s history.”
So what does the future hold for the theater? After the city attorney completes its investigation, Cort may be fined for unpermitted demolition. In the meantime, Hemminger has submitted blueprints, showing the full restoration of the facade, including plans to reconstruct the original iconic “blade”-shaped marquee to a “similar size.”