The unfinished mural in Mission Creek Cafe. Photo by Emily Gibson.

When Thomasina DeMaio paints, she sweats and she curses, but she also dances, and sings and smiles. She paints despite a swollen dislocated thumb, and even after paint thinner seeps into the uncovered cut. But most importantly, she paints fast.

This is why it came as a surprise when it seemed as though DeMaio’s most recent work, a mural inside Mission Creek Café on Valencia Street, was taking a long time to complete. For six weeks, arms remained without hands, heads were without faces, and a large section in the center of the approximately 50-foot mural disappeared entirely.

The Mission Creek mural is an extension of a series DeMaio began five years ago at three places near the corner of 21st and Valencia streets – Decamere Supermarket, Valencia Whole Foods and Sidewalk Juice. Each display a DeMaio mural on their façades and Valencia Whole Foods also has a mural on the interior of the store.

“The murals are mainly allegories,” DeMaio said. To illustrate them she uses people who walk by her as she works. “I do a quick sketch and I put them in. It’s really mostly local people.”

DeMaio, 63,  feels very strongly about the integrity of her artistic process and the content of each of her works, and seeks to retain creative control of the murals she paints—including those commissioned by local businesses.

Yousef Nazzal, owner of Valencia Whole Foods said of DeMaio, “It is hard to convince an artist. She wants to do certain colors. She speaks her mind.”

That, it turns out, explains the reason for the lack of progress on the Mission Creek piece.

DeMaio, who moved to the Bay Area to attend the San Francisco Art Institute where she received both a bachelor’s and a master’s degree in painting, said that as she progressed on the piece, the owner become increasingly controlling over the types of people he wanted in the café scenes, forcing her to paint out portions of the mural. After a week and a half of work, she was fed up and walked out, DeMaio said.

On Tuesday, the woman at the counter, who declined to identify herself, said that the artist comes in when she wants, and whether or not the mural is finished is “up to her.”

DeMaio said that according to the terms of her verbal contract, Mission Creek must paint over the unfinished mural since she was never paid for the work. The white space currently in the center of mural shows Mission Creek has begun efforts to paint over the piece.

The woman at the Mission Creek counter said the artist had already been paid, but DeMaio said that was only for materials.

Nazzal at Valencia Whole Foods was aware that there had been a disagreement about the mural, explaining that the desire of both parties to speak their minds was likely to blame.

A muralist here for decades, DeMaio can’t remember where all of her murals are. She knows there is one at Pause Bar on Market Street (two actually), one at Marines’ Memorial Theater and perhaps another at 18th and Hartford streets. Her favorite mural, which is actually a large canvas painting on display at Pause Bar, is of a room full of tango dancers with a mushroom cloud in the distance.  Titled “Last Tango,” it was painted in 1981 after she attended a speech on the dangers of nuclear proliferation.

Few of her pieces have overt political messages but much of her art is driven by charitable purposes, she said. In 1990, DeMaio offered to do a series of ceramic sculptures and large-scale portraits for the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence to help the group raise money. She subsequently became a nun herself, Sister Donatella Donaska. She failed to last.

“I got thrown out, I was excommunicated, but I am still a saint,” she insists, adding that she has taken some revenge by destroying the portraits of those who have fallen into her disfavor.

Follow Us

Living in the Mission District feels a lot like home for former Brooklyn resident Emily Gibson. Both neighborhoods are happening cultural centers with their own unique stories to tell. As an arts reporter, Gibson, 28, hopes to highlight under-reported Latin cultural events and their role in the larger contemporary art scene.

Join the Conversation


Please keep your comments short and civil. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and very easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published.

  1. I’m just thrilled that Thommy’s still pissing people off. There are a lot of people that need pissing off, and if they think they can fuck with her, they have never been in a fight. Keep up the good work, and fuckem’.

  2. Thommie is an artist’s artist. The real thing in a world where many put on paint stained jeans and spend their time writing “statements.” It’s the art that counts, and hers counts exponentially!

  3. Hello, Thomasina is an intense, independent voice in the world of visual art and should be allowed to express her ideas without censorship. Letting her finish a mural projetc is the least one can do in the name of “freedom of expression” If someone wants an artist to be a secretary for being underpaid, there are plenty of unimaginative people around to obey.

  4. it is hard to say why I was asked to leave but I did gladly. the group made quite a bit of money from the sale of images and buttons over the years,with absolutely no thanks given to me or accounting of how much. I could have used this for taxes. The problem was another female nun who didnt like me or the attention I was getting and created a “chick” fight thing having the other nuns gang up on me. It was a fund raiser for RCH and I criticized her for setting her own bar up in the parking lot of this event to sell booze,something that was already taken care of in our event planning..from that complaint I was asked to leave. I have since redirected my efforts to those who need it