The mural by Manuel Paul on the corner of 24th and Bryant, vandalized Monday and Tuesday. Photo by Joe Rivano Barros.

A mural portraying a gay couple, a lesbian couple, and a transgender man was defaced Monday and Tuesday after online threats and homophobic remarks were made against the mural’s artist Manuel Paul.

“The defacing happened the last two nights after a conversation on social media shifted and turned negative,” said Ani Rivera, director of Galería de la Raza.

The Galería released a statement Wednesday afternoon condemning the “homophobic hate speech and physical threats” made online against both the Maricon Collective, of which Paul is a member, and the artists of “The Q-Sides,” who were also targeted for their exhibit on queer and low-rider culture currently on display at Galería.

Though the mural, located outside Galería on 24th and Bryant, was only unveiled Saturday, Rivera said that already on Monday night blue and red graffiti had appeared over both the gay and lesbian couple, followed Tuesday by spray paint defacing the transgender man in the middle of the mural. She speculated that the delay might have been caused by the perpetrators’ ignorance that the man was transgender.

Resistance to the mural seems to have centered on belief that the art was “glamorizing and claiming gang affiliation,” according to Galería’s statement. This they wholly reject, stating that both the mural and the “Q-Sides” exhibit are a “declaration of love for oldies music and lowriders – and how these art forms have informed and shaped queer Chican@ LGBTQ identities” and that “there is no intent of disrespect.”

“I think it’s a hate crime when you’re vandalizing like this, based on everything that’s been happening on social media,” Rivera said. “This cult of violence — that’s the shocking part. This visceral reaction to male on male love — you’re wrong to call for violence for something you don’t understand.”

Though not all were shocked. Maria Alvarado, an employee at Precita Eyes, said she guessed the mural would be defaced when she first saw it.

“Latinos are very macho and homophobic,” she said. “When you put two men like that outside — they’re not going to like that. If you’re a little gang-banger, you’re not going to go for that.”

Another employee of Precita Eyes, who asked to remain anonymous, said there’s a history of that site being vandalized and of resistance to some kinds of art in the Mission.

“The work that they [Galería] are doing is challenging for some folks,” he said, “and these are some old school folks. They don’t know how to do things in a sensible way.”

While Rivera agreed that this isn’t the first time they’ve faced pushback (she cited a case back in 2000 when a lesbian mural drew homophobic remarks and even a gunshot through the gallery’s window), she also said she doesn’t think the Mission is opposed to this kind of art.

“This isn’t one community. This is communities plural,” she said. “This is just one sector of a community. Everyone’s entitled to their opinion — we always know there’s going to be two sides to everything — but we’re going to continue to expand on the narratives of Chicano and Latino identities.”

She was even somewhat optimistic.

“This has had a positive impact in some way,” she said. “We’ve had endless emails and phone calls from as far away as Arizona and Texas telling us not to give up. We know there’s a community in need of this, the visibility of LGBT Latinos. We’re trying to stay positive.”

The incident has been reported to the police. Galería de la Raza welcomes anyone to help with the restoration of the mural, which will start Thursday at 9:30 a.m. and will last all day.

Follow Us

Join the Conversation


Please keep your comments short and civil. We will zap comments that fail to adhere to these short and very easy-to-follow rules.

Your email address will not be published.

  1. Dear “Nette”: I seriously hope the lapse of six years has increased the social, cultural, political, gender, and self awareness which is so obviously lacking in your posting. I grew up in a 95% Raza community and I helped put Low Riding on the map. When the publisher Sonny Madrid RIP called me to clean up the Low Rider Magazine #1 paste-up I did so, and soon joined the staff of an obviously winning publication. We had previously been teaming up on outing vendidos in Sanjo.You claimed to speak for cholos but you only spoke for the homophobes. Your comment that cholos have nothing to do with homosexuality is totally uninformed, because any group of cholos anywhere is likely up to their eyebrows on CLOSET CASES. Any conservative social, cultural political or militaroid group is the same, for obvious reasons.Your comments about “understanding” can be taken as encouragement of more violence towards gays, and your claim of neutrality concerning the gays and lesbian community is an outright lie, because because your “understanding” is not shared with gays, but only with your more criminal and violent heroes, which can be read as encouragement to more violence. So clearly your knowledge of this issue is zilch, but even worse your thinking process is unknowing, uninformed, bigoted, decidedly unhealthy, and no decent rôle model for any community. Your clumsy language belies your clumsy thinking. I posted on the blog of a Mission “community leader”‘s blog that his support and “understanding” for violence against gays was simplistic and irresponsible, and having no response, and not wishing to debate me publicly he erased my comment. Clearly neither on if you knows fully what you are talking about and should be working to unite your community rather than dividing us up into who you like and who you don’t, and specially since your community awareness is poverty-stricken.

  2. Cholo movement has nada to do with homosexuality. I can understand the homies being somewhat offended by this. I have nothing against the gay/queer/ transgender community but I understand why the mural keeps being defaced and it will continue to de defaced.