The Other Barrio: Crime, Gentrification, Noir

The Other Barrio, now finishing up post-production, offers viewers a feature-length noir crime-buster that uses the Mission’s evictions and gentrification as a backdrop.

Adapted from a short story by San Francisco’s Poet Laureate Alejandro Murguía, the film follows Housing Inspector Bob Morales as he investigates a fatal residential hotel fire in the city’s Mission District. It is based on the true tale of the Mission’s Gartland Hotel, which burned down in 1975, but instead of setting the film in the 1970s, the filmmakers placed the film in the present day.

Lou Dematteis, a long-time Mission resident who co-produced the film, talked to Mission Local about the film and its challenges.

“In 2013, we started focusing on what was happening in the Mission because by that time, evictions were heating up,” Dematteis said. “We wanted to add what’s happening more contemporarily in the Mission, since the short story is about redevelopment and historically, the fires in the Mission have happened for many, many years and are still happening.”

EMAIL_S

Courtesy of “The Other Barrio”

The Other Barrio has deep Mission roots. Founder and former artistic director of the Mission’s Galería de la Raza—who is now being evicted—is the film’s production designer. The lead actor, co-writer and co-producer, Richard Montoya, helped establish the 1980s Chicano American performance troupe Culture Clash in the Mission. A spoken-word piece by Mission resident Guillermo Gómez-Peña of La Pocha Nostra collective is featured. Murguía makes a cameo appearance.

“It’s almost like you’re watching a documentary but you’re not,” Dematteis said. “We have a realistic portrayal of the Mission, which I’m not sure any film has done….We were able to use this element of the community rising up to protest and to push back against the evictions and the gentrification.”

Using The Other Barrio as a starting point, Dematteis, who has lived in the Mission on and off for the last four decades, seeks to paint a more nuanced look at what’s happening in the Mission District.

“A lot of the criticism about what’s happening in the Mission is laid at the feet of high-tech and the hipsters,” Dematteis said. “We thought it was important to be more sophisticated as to what’s happening in the Mission. We basically lay it on the economic forces of development and the policies of the city of San Francisco.”

“We’re critical of high-tech and their part of this, but we were careful not to vilify anybody,” Dematteis said.”We want everyone to go and see it, to see what they think.”

Dematteis said the film cost $200,000 to make. The budgetary constraints came with challenges including a dramatic shift midway through the project that changed the film from a series of noir stories that would have included Chinatown and North Beach to one feature based in the Mission. With 50 minutes already shot, they brought in another writer to finish off the story. The femme fatale had already been killed off, but another was created, Dematteis said.

As a local filmmaker and photojournalist, Dematteis is a staunch believer in art with a purpose. For him, there is a certain poetry in connecting art with real-life events. Dematteis and his colleagues were active in the opposition to U.S. involvement in Nicaragua and El Salvador. Dematteis covered the U.S.-backed contra war in Nicaragua for six years and Murguía was also active in the opposition. 

Now, ground zero is their own neighborhood.

“There’s an incredible artistic pushback against the gentrification,” Dematteis said. “The Other Barrio is part of this artistic pushback. The Mission is always thought of being Latino, which it is, but artistically, it’s an incredible mix of people….and this is the sadness of the Mission—that we’re losing some of that.”

The Other Barrio has been submitted to the Mill Valley Film Festival, Toronto International Film Festival and the San Diego Film Festival. It is currently in post-production and is set to premiere in the fall.

11 Comments

  1. SFrentier

    A case of art initiating life. Unless the movie is really well done, clever in some ways, and brings new perspectives, why bother with it when we, de facto, live and breath this every day?

  2. Bob

    More ridiculousness… The Mission has not always been Latino, it was Irish very recently. Gentrification is making the neighborhood safer and more diverse, and the arts continue to play a major role. To say that Mission gentrification is like the Contras in Nicaragua is crazy.

    • gribble

      It hasn’t always been Latino, but they have certainly made their mark on The Mission.

      But you know what? I am more interested in the minority groups within The Mission. In particular the history of the Chinese immigrants that chose to open businesses in The Mission when it was really a gritty, hard place. Many of these families are changing as the older generation passes on. Look at the number of Chinese businesses that are on the way out of right now. Hom’s Grocery won’t last more than a few more years. ABC Locks, Sams Shoes, Kings and Guerrero Laundry.

      • Bob

        Good point. The contribution of all these groups is significant.

      • Orddu

        Yes…there have been a lot of people who moved through here. Lots of Germans made the Mission their home (Check out the German inscriptions on the Buddhist church on 22nd Street) …
        Mexican, Salvadorian, Nicaraguan, Chinese, Irish…They’re all interesting.

    • BJ

      Dearest Bob,
      Check your history. Mission District was part of Jose C. Bernal land grant, Mission Dolores church lands, and other adjacent land grants. The lands were register at the state when the borders changed. The maps are kept at the Bancroft library and are available on line for public viewing. Mexicans, Chileans and Peruvians have contributed much to the development of the San Francisco before the borders changes and after. North Beach was not Italian and Chinese but Mexican, Portuguese, Spanish and Chileans, Don’t forget the founding mother of San Francisco was Juana Briones. Please research Our Lady of Guadalupe church located in North Beach adjacent to the Broadway tunnel. http://sf.remezcla.com/2012/latin/nuestra-senora-de-guadalupe-faces-destruction/.

      • Sam

        Yeah but the Hispanic origins of the California missions reflect Euro-centric imperialism and so do not provide liberals with the perfectly nuanced anti-white rhetoric that they so crucially crave.

        They prefer to eulogize the grubby masses who break the law to suck up the American Dream – a specifically Caucasion desideratum.

        Card playing gets so messy, don’t you think? Let me help you. White/Asian – bad. Black/Hispanic = good. It’s easy if you try.

    • Russo

      Three murders in the last week. Yep, much safer.

Comments are closed.